Evaluating the Accuracy of Reionization Prescriptions in Semi-analytic Models of the First Stars and Galaxies
Eli Visbal · 2025
Read Evaluating the Accuracy of Reionization Prescriptions in Semi-analytic Models of the First Stars and Galaxies by Eli Visbal (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-04808.txt.
Introduction
Thomas Behling, Ryan Hazlett, Mihir Kulkarni, and Eli Visbal check how well fast recipes for cosmic reionization match a full simulation. Semi-analytic models trade detail for speed when studying the first stars and galaxies. Reionization matters inside them because ionized gas is heated, which chokes new star birth in small halos.
Their 2025 study compares three recipes against the Renaissance simulations, which model gas and radiation together. Older recipes placed the big ionized bubbles correctly but missed neutral gas hiding in dense filaments. As a result they overstated how many halos felt the feedback, by up to tenfold. The team's new recipe accounts for the cosmic web's density and matches the simulation well. First-galaxy studies can trust it more.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Eli Visbal |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 30 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-04808
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Evaluating the Accuracy of Reionization Prescriptions in Semi-analytic Models of the First Stars and Galaxies Eli Visbal Abstract Semi-analytic models are a valuable tool to study the first stars and galaxies. Their numerical efficiency makes it possible to survey broad regions of astrophysical parameter space across large volumes and redshift ranges. Following reionization in these models is necessary since star formation is suppressed in ionized regions due to photoheating of the gas. Here we evaluate the accuracy of three semi-analytic reionization prescriptions (two previously developed and one new model) by comparing their three-dimensional distribution of ionized bubbles to the Renaissance hydrodynamical cosmological radiative transfer simulations. We find that the previously existing models accurately determine the distribution of the larger bubbles within our ∼ 6 {\sim}6 comoving Mpc simulation box, but that these models fail to take into account self-shielded neutral gas in dense filaments. Thus, these prescriptions overestimate the fraction of halos in HII regions impacted by reionization feedback by up to an order of magnitude (depending on halo mass and redshift). This leads to an unrealistically large effect of reionization feedback on Pop III stars and low-mass metal-enriched galaxies. Our newly developed model takes into account the density structure of the cosmic web, leading to good agreement with Renaissance in the fraction of halos found in ionized regions. 1 Introduction Understanding the earliest stages of galaxy evolution is currently an exciting frontier in astronomy. There are a variety of observations that can or will soon probe primordial Population III (Pop III) stars (for a review see [ 1 ] ). These include possible direct detections from the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) [ 2 , 3 , 4 ] , 21cm cosmology [ 5 , 6 ] , absorption systems found in high-redshift quasar spectra [ 7 ] , stellar archaeology in the local universe [ 7 ] , HeII line intensity mapping [ 8 , 9 ] , the optical depth of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) [ 10 ] , and supernovae or gamma ray bursts from Pop III progenitors [ 11 , 12 , 13 ] . Theoretical models are required to interpret these measurements. There are a variety of different modeling techniques, each with their own strengths. For example, hydrodynamical cosmological simulations [ 14 , 15 , 16 , e.g., ] can follow detailed physical processes with high fidelity, but are numerically expensive. Semi-analytic modeling is a complementary approach [ 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 , 22 ] . Here dark matter halo merger histories are first generated, typically with either cosmological N-body simulations or Monte Carlo (MC) methods exploiting the extended Press-Schechter (EPS) formalism [ 23 , 24 , 25 ] . Then analytic prescriptions are used to predict star formation within the dark matter halos. Semi-analytic models have the advantage of being very numerically efficient while still capturing the important physical processes of galaxy formation, and can be calibrated to agree well with hydrodynamical simulations [ 26 , 27 ] . Their efficiency enables semi-analytic models to survey the relevant parameter space (e.g., initial mass function (IMF) of Pop III stars), which is not feasible with hydrodynamical cosmological simulations due to their numerical expense. Theoretical models must include a number of feedback effects to accurately model Pop III stars and early galaxies. For example, Lyman-Werner (LW) radiation produced by stars and galaxies photodissociates molecular hydrogen, which delays subsequent Pop III star formation (since H 2 is the primary coolant in the formation of Pop III stars) [ 28 , 29 , 30 , 31 , 32 ] . It is also necessary to follow the process of cosmic reionization. This is because gas in ionized regions is photoheated to {\sim}10^{4}~{\rm K} , which suppresses star formation is low-mass dark matter halos [ 33 , 34 , 35 , 36 , 37 , 38 ] . Other key processes include inhomogeneous metal enrichment [ 39 , e.g., ] and the impact of the baryon-dark matter streaming velocities [ 40 , 41 ] . In this paper, we focus on understanding the accuracy of semi-analytic techniques modeling the early stages of reionization relevant to Pop III stars and high-redshift galaxy formation. Two previous semi-analytic models have implemented prescriptions of inhomogeneous reionization in this context following the three-dimensional (3D) distribution of HII regions and their impact on Pop III stars (A-SLOTH [ 20 ] and [ 19 ] which we refer to as V2020 throughout the remainder of this paper). As described in detail below, these models use relatively simple prescriptions to generate a distribution of spherical ionized regions around sources of ionizing radiation. We note that these models are used to compute reionization in boxes of length {\sim}3~{\rm Mpc} . This is too small of a region to accurately model the global process of reionization [ 42 ] , but it is necessary to accurately compute Pop III and early galaxy formation [ 19 ] . We test the accuracy of these models by comparing them directly to the Renaissance Simulations [ 43 , 44 ] , which are hydrodynamical cosmological simulations including star formation (Pop III and metal-enriched), supernovae feedback, and radiative transfer. This is related to a previous study comparing semi-analytic models of reionization to radiative transfer simulations [ 45 ] , but that test was performed on much larger scales and comparing different methods. We note that these authors refer to the approximate reionization schemes as “semi-numerical”, but we use the term semi-analytic throughout this paper. We find that when assuming the same sources of ionizing photons as Renaissance , the V2020 and A-SLOTH models recreate a similar large-scale distribution of ionized bubbles, but fail to capture self-shielding within neutral dense filaments in the cosmic web. This motivates us to create a new semi-analytic model of reionization that includes the 3D density field (using the only the dark matter component from the simulation). This leads for much better performance than the previous models. The rest of this paper is structured as follows. In Section 2 , we describe the Renaissance Simulations . In Section 3 , we discuss the previous semi-analytic reionization schemes from V2020 and A-SLOTH. We also introduce our new method. In Section 4 , we present a direct comparison between these semi-analytic methods and Renaissance . Finally, we summarize our results and conclude in Section 5 . Throughout we assume a cosmology consistent with Renaissance using parameters from the WMAP7 \Lambda CDM+SZ+LENS best fit [ 46 ] with \Omega_{\mathrm{M}}=0.266 , \Omega_{\mathrm{\Lambda}}=0.734 , \Omega_{\mathrm{b}}=0.0449 , h=0.71 , \sigma_{\mathrm{8}}=0.81 , and n=0.963 . 2 Renaissance Simulations The Renaissance Simulations are a set of hydrodynamical cosmological simulations focused on the first stars and galaxies [ 43 , 44 ] . They were run with the adaptive mesh refinement code (AMR) enzo [ 47 ] , and include Pop III and metal-enriched star formation, supernovae feedback (including the pollution of halos and the intergalactic medium (IGM) with metals via supernovae winds), and radiative feedback. Radiative transfer is performed with a ray-tracing code, moray [ 48 ] . Primordial chemistry and cooling is computed for nine species of H and He [ 49 ] and metallicity dependent cooling is also