Theory of circular dichroism in resonant inelastic x-ray scattering
M. Furo, A. Hariki, J. Kuneš · 2025
Read Theory of circular dichroism in resonant inelastic x-ray scattering by M. Furo, A. Hariki, J. Kuneš (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-04388.txt.
Introduction
Furo and co-authors develop a theory of a light effect in X-ray scattering from magnetic materials, in work from 2025. The effect compares scattering for two twists of incoming light. Such contrasts can reveal hidden magnetic order that plain spectra miss.
The authors treat each atom on its own, setting aside cross-talk between atoms. They then sort common magnetic layouts by symmetry, covering both standard and newer magnet types. Computer models with real crystal fields support the analysis. A key trait sets this effect apart: it does not flip when time direction flips. It can thus appear even in the disordered phase and stays fixed when magnetic order reverses.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | M. Furo, A. Hariki, J. Kuneš |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 41 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-04388
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Theory of circular dichroism in resonant inelastic x-ray scattering M. Furo, A. Hariki, J. Kuneš Abstract We analyze circular dichroism (CD) in resonant inelastic x-ray scattering (RIXS) in magnetic materials. We define RIXS-CD as the difference between scattering amplitudes for the right- and left-circularly polarized incoming photons and unpolarized (total) outgoing photons. We employ the impurity approximation, in which the interference between scattering events on different atoms is neglected. We perform the symmetry analysis of several common antiferromagnetic and altermagnetic structures and outline the general approach. The analysis is supported by numerical calculations using atomic model with realistic crystal fields obtained from first principles. We show that RIXS-CD is distinguished from first-order spectroscopies such as x-ray magnetic circular dichroism by insensitivity to the time-reversal symmetry breaking. As a result we find that RIXS-CD is present in the normal (disordered) state of materials with lower symmetry. In antiferromagnets the RIXS-CD is invariant under Néel vector reversal. In altermagnets and ferromagnets the RIXS-CD spectra for time-reversed states are, in general, independent except for the special case when there is a unitary symmetry of the Hamiltonian connecting the two states. I Introduction X-ray magnetic circular dichroism (XMCD) has recently demonstrated its utility as a tool for characterizing some classes compensated magnets Yamasaki et al. 2020 ; Kimata et al. 2021 ; Sakamoto et al. 2021 ; Sasabe et al. 2021 ; Sasabe et al. 2023 ; Hariki et al. 2024a ; Hariki et al. 2025 ; Hariki et al. 2024b ; Hariki et al. 2024c . It enabled mapping out of antiferromagnetic domains Amin et al. 2024 . Resonant inelastic x-ray scattering (RIXS) a related technique Ament et al. 2011 ; Mitrano et al. 2024 ; de Groot et al. 2024 ; de Groot and Kotani 2014 . While experimentally more demanding, RIXS with more control parameters provides a more detailed insight into the excitations of the studied material, e.g., momentum resolution, and is less restricted by selection rules. RIXS experiments with circularly polarized x-rays have recently been reported for several materials from the currently much studied altermagnetic group Takegami et al. 2025 ; Jost et al. 2025 ; Biniskos et al. 2025 . The resonant nature of RIXS process makes the interpretation of the measured spectra rather non-trivial requiring some theoretical input Fukui et al. 2001 ; Kotani 2005 . The key question in circular dichroism (CD) experiments concerns the selection rules. When does the effect vanish due to symmetry constraints and conversely what a finite CD implies about the symmetry of the studied material? The selection rules for XMCD in the dipole approximation are quite restrictive, in particular, it is forbidden in systems with time reversal symmetry. In this paper we develop the theory of RIXS-CD and present numerical simulations for selected materials. We find that RIXS-CD is much more prolific than XMCD and can be found even in non-magnetic systems with lower symmetry. We employ two approximations. The dipole approximation, which provides the leading order in x-ray absorption, means that the wave vectors of incoming and outgoing photons enter only by selecting the corresponding polarization planes. The impurity approximation, means that we neglect the interference between the scattering events on different atoms. In the impurity approximation, the momentum transfer to the electronic excitations, and material final state in general, is neglected and thus dispersion of excitations cannot be described. This may be rather crude for dispersive low-energy excitations such as magnons, which are described as local spin flips. Importantly, the final state symmetry in the impurity approximation is higher that in general and thus the derived selection rules are more restrictive. This means that RIXS-CD may be weakly allowed even when it is forbidden in the present theory. We start by discussing the time-reversal symmetry. We show that on-resonance RIXS process itself breaks the time-reversal symmetry and thus experiments performed on time-reversed states are not related to one another. The RIXS spectra are therefore sensitive only to unitary (geometric) symmetries of the system. Next, we show that the dependence of RIXS-CD on the incoming and outgoing wave vectors in the impurity approximation can be written as a sum of an isotropic part depending only on the incoming wave vector and characterized by a pseudovector, analogy of a Hall vector, and an anisotropic part described by a rank-3 tensor. The form of this tensor is determined by the unitary subgroup of the magnetic point group. We derive these for some materials of current interest. II Theory The RIXS intensity for an initial state |i\rangle 1 1 1 The initial state projector \sum_{i}|i\rangle\langle i| may contain Boltzmann factors at a finite temperature, which are not shown for sake of readebility. is given by Kramers-Heisenberg (KH) formula Kramers and Heisenberg 1925 ; de Groot and Kotani 2014 ; Ament et al. 2011 \begin{split}F(\omega_{\text{out}},\omega_{\text{in}})=&\sum_{f,i}\left|\sum_{m}\frac{\expectationvalue{f|\hT_\text{out}|m}\expectationvalue{m|\hT_\text{in}|i}}{E_{i}-E_{m}+i\Gamma}\right|^{2}\\ &\times\delta(E_{f}-E_{i}).\end{split} (1) Here, |m\rangle , and |f\rangle are the intermediate and final states, respectively. The energies of the initial state E_{i}=\tilde{E}_{i}+\omega_{\text{in}} and final state E_{f}=\tilde{E}_{f}+\omega_{\text{out}} include the energy of the incoming ( \omega_{\rm in} ) and outgoing ( \omega_{\rm out} ) photon. \Gamma represents the inverse lifetime of the core hole in the intermediate state. Importantly, this term does not vanish even in the limit of an infinite core-hole lifetime in which case one has to take the \Gamma\rightarrow 0^{+} limit yielding a finite imaginary part if a continuous intermediate-state spectrum is resonant with the initial/final states. This reflects the irreversible nature of the initial-state decay to the intermediate-state continuum. Interference between these transitions and transitions via a virtual (non-resonant) intermediate state, described by the real part of the denominator, makes the RIXS intensity insensitive to the time-reversal symmetry breaking. To show this let us compare the RIXS intensity between a given state and a state related by an anti-unitary operation. \begin{split}&F^{\mathcal{T}}=\sum_{f,i}\left|\sum_{m}\frac{\expectationvalue{\mT f|\hT_\text{out}|\mT m}\expectationvalue{\mT m|\hT_\text{in}|\mT i}}{E_{i}-E_{m}+i\Gamma}\right|^{2}\delta_{fi}\\ &=\sum_{f,i}\left|\sum_{m}\frac{\overline{\expectationvalue{ f|\mT^{-1}\hT_\text{out}\mT| m}}\ \overline{\expectationvalue{m|\mT^{-1}\hT_\text{in}\mT| i}}}{E_{i}-E_{m}+i\Gamma}\right|^{2}\delta_{fi}.\\ \end{split} (2) Thanks to the complex nature of the denominator there is no linear relationship between the RIXS spectrum of the original and time-reversed system 2 2 2 Unless all the terms in the numerator have the same phase, which we find unrealistic. . This is different for the unitary transformations. \begin{split}&F^{\mathcal{U}}=\sum_{f,i}\left|\sum_{m}\frac{\expectationvalue{\mU f|\hT_\text{out}|\mU m}\expectationvalue{\mU m|\hT_\text{in}|\mU i}}{E_{i}-E_{m}+i\Gamma}\right|^{2}\delta_{fi}\\ &=\sum_{f,i}\left|\sum_{m}\frac{\expectationvalue{ f|\mU^{-1}\hT_\text{out}\mU| m}\expectationvalue{m|\mU^{-1}\hT_\text{in}\mU| i}}{E_{i}-E_{m}+i\Gamma}\right|^{2}\delta_{fi}.\\ \end{split} (3) In this case, F^{\mathcal{U}} and F are related by rotations of the dipole operators, i.e., F transforms as the fourth power of the vector representation. This may be used to relate the spectra from different states, e.g., magnetic domains, or to constrain the form of F , if \mathcal{U} is the symmetry of the system 3 3 3 This means that projectors \sum_{f}|f\rangle\langle f| , \sum_{m}|m\rangle\langle m| and \sum_{i}|i\rangle\langle i| are invariant under the action of \mathcal{U} . The above analysis has an important implication for the RIXS-CD and its relationship to CD in x-ray absorption. The XMCD vanishes in systems with time-reversal symmetry and thus it is typically observed in magnetic systems with broken time-reversal symmetry. In the RIXS process the time-reversal symmetry by itself cannot make CD vanish. Instead RIXS-CD reflects only the unitary symmetries and their changes across the phase transitions. The momentum deposited in the system by the RIXS process substantially reduces the number of unitary symmetries as these must preserve the transferred