On Shelah’s Approachability Ideal

Hannes Jakob, Alejandro Poveda · 2025

Read On Shelah’s Approachability Ideal by Hannes Jakob, Alejandro Poveda (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-04374.txt.

Introduction

Hannes Jakob and Alejandro Poveda wrote a paper from 2025 solving a long-open problem of Shelah about the approachability ideal, which concerns which sets of ordinals can be approached by short sequences. Granting strong large-cardinal premises, they build a model of standard set theory in which a named set of ordinals falls outside the ideal. They also build one model where the property fails at every singular cardinal at once.

Catalog record

CREATORHannes Jakob, Alejandro Poveda
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE131 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-04374

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On Shelah’s Approachability Ideal Hannes Jakob, Alejandro Poveda Abstract . We solve a long-standing open problem of Shelah regarding the Approachability Ideal I ⁡ [ κ + ] I[\kappa^{+}] . Given a singular cardinal ℵ γ \aleph_{\gamma} , a regular cardinal μ ∈ ( cf ⁡ ( γ ) , ℵ γ ) \mu\in(\cf(\gamma),\aleph_{\gamma}) and assuming appropriate large cardinal hypotheses, we construct a model of 𝖹𝖥𝖢 \mathsf{ZFC} in which ℵ γ + 1 ∩ cof ⁡ ( μ ) ∉ I ⁡ [ ℵ γ + 1 ] \aleph_{\gamma+1}\cap\cof(\mu)\notin I[\aleph_{\gamma+1}] . This provides a definitive answer to a question of Shelah from the 80’s. In addition, assuming large cardinals, we construct a model of 𝖹𝖥𝖢 \mathsf{ZFC} in which the approachability property fails, simultaneously, at every singular cardinal. This is a major milestone in the solution of a question of Foreman and Magidor from the 80’s. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification 03E35, 03E55 1. Introduction The study of singular cardinals stands out as one of the most fascinating areas of inquiry in modern set theory. It was Georg Cantor who first formalized the concept of the infinite and initiated the investigation of the continuum. As part of his pioneering analysis, Cantor formulated the Continuum Hypothesis ( \mathsf{CH} ), which posits that the cardinality of \mathbb{R} (i.e., 2^{\aleph_{0}} ) is as small as possible—namely, \aleph_{1} , the first uncountable cardinal. The status of \mathsf{CH} within the broader mathematical paradigm remained elusive to many leading figures until Kurt Gödel [ Göd40 ] showed that \mathsf{CH} cannot be refuted from the standard axioms of mathematics ( \mathsf{ZFC} ), and later Paul Cohen [ Coh63 , Coh64 ] , inventing the set-theoretic method of forcing , showed that \mathsf{CH} cannot be proved from \mathsf{ZFC} either. These two results established the independence of \mathsf{CH} from the standard foundation of mathematics, setting the tone for sixty years of groundbreaking discoveries in which the phenomenon of independence played a central role. With the subsequent development of forcing, Easton demonstrated that there are virtually no \mathsf{ZFC} -provable restrictions on the behavior of the power-set function \kappa\mapsto 2^{\kappa} [ Eas70 ] . This inaugurated a series of results showing that, at least for (so-called) regular cardinals —such as \aleph_{0} (the cardinality of the integers) or \aleph_{1} — \mathsf{ZFC} alone settles little about cardinal arithmetic. Confounding all expectations, a series of groundbreaking results pioneered by Galvin–Hajnal [ GH75 ] , Silver [ Sil75 ] , Magidor [ Mag77 ] and Shelah [ She94 ] revealed that singular cardinals (such as \aleph_{\omega} and \aleph_{\omega_{1}} ) obey far deeper constraints, and that \mathsf{ZFC} itself proves remarkable structural theorems. For instance, a celebrated result of Shelah shows that if 2^{\aleph_{n}}<\aleph_{\omega} holds for all integers n then there is a provable upper bound on 2^{\aleph_{\omega}} . This is in stark contrast with power sets of regular cardinals, where no such upper bound can be established in \mathsf{ZFC} alone as per the work of Easton [ Eas70 ] . Signs of the striking nature of singular cardinals have been found well beyond the realm of cardinal arithmetic. A paradigmatic example is Shelah’s Singular Compactness Theorem [ She75 ] in infinite abelian group theory, which shows that every abelian group G that is \aleph_{\omega} -generated and almost free must be free. Magidor–Shelah extensively studied such phenomena in their classical paper [ MS94 ] , and they are now considered part of the standard landscape of the field. Singular cardinals have also surfaced in functional analysis. Improving a classical, influential, work by Gowers and Maurey [ GM93 ] , Dodos, López-Abad, and Todorcevic [ DLAT11 ] showed that, consistently, every Banach space of density character at most \aleph_{\omega} contains an unconditional basic sequence—a result that is arguably optimal. The present manuscript continues this major line of research in modern set theory by analyzing a related core construction: Shelah’s approachability ideal, I[\kappa] . Let \kappa be a regular uncountable cardinal. A set S\subseteq\kappa is called stationary if it intersects every club set C\subseteq\kappa – that is, it intersects every subset of \kappa that is closed and unbounded in its ordinal topology. Intuitively speaking, club sets correspond to measure one sets whereas stationary sets parallel sets having positive measure . Stationarity is a cornerstone concept in infinitary combinatorics which has been critically utilized in Module Theory [ EM02 , CP24 ] , Cohomology [ Ber21 ] or Analysis [ Far11 , Far19 , MP17 ] among many other areas in mathematics. In set theory, the preservation of these objects after passing to generic extensions becomes pivotal in the proof of some central results in the field [ Mag82 , CFM01 , PRS23 , BHU24 ] . In his classical paper [ She79 ] , Shelah introduced (if implicitly) the approachability ideal I[\kappa] and the corresponding notion of the approachability property \mathsf{AP}_{\kappa} , asserting that \kappa^{+}\in I[\kappa^{+}] (i.e., I[\kappa^{+}] is improper). Through an incisive analysis, Shelah bridges I[\kappa] with the preservation of stationary sets under set-theoretic forcing. Specifically, he shows that if S\subseteq\kappa\cap\cof(\lambda) 1 1 1 \kappa\cap\cof(\lambda) is the standard notation for the collection of ordinals \alpha<\kappa with cofinality \lambda . is stationary and S\in I[\kappa] then the stationarity of S is preserved by so-called {<}\lambda^{+} -closed posets (see Section 2 ). Thereby, under \mathsf{AP}_{\kappa} any stationary set S\subseteq\kappa^{+}\cap\cof(\lambda) is preserved by {<}\lambda^{+} -closed forcing. This is somewhat sharp as if S\notin I[\kappa] , then even garden variety {<}\lambda^{+} -closed forcings, such as the Levy collapse \Coll(\lambda,\kappa) , destroy the stationarity of S . Shelah showed that I[\kappa] is a normal ideal and demonstrated that it is rich enough to contain many stationary sets. Namely, if \lambda<\kappa are both regular and \lambda^{+}<\kappa then I[\kappa] contains a stationary subset of \kappa\cap\cof(\lambda) . Moreover, if \kappa itself is a regular cardinal then \kappa^{+}\cap\cof({<}\kappa)\in I[\kappa^{+}] , and thus I[\kappa^{+}] is completely determined by membership of stationary subsets of \kappa^{+}\cap\cof(\kappa) . As usual, the situation with successors of singular cardinals is way more subtle – in this case \mathsf{ZFC} can only establish \kappa^{+}\cap\cof({\leq}\cf(\kappa))\in I[\kappa^{+}] . Whether or not this result is sharp constitutes a major problem and is one of the issues that is under investigation in this manuscript. Ever since its conception, investigations of I[\kappa] have constituted a major area of research in set theory. Today’s understanding of this subject has been substantially enriched by the work of Shelah [ She91 , She93 ] , Foreman–Magidor [ FM95 , FM97 ] , Mitchell [ Mit09 ] , Gitik–Krueger [ GK09 ] , Sharon–Viale [ SV10 ] , Gitik–Rinot [ GR12 ] , Unger [ Ung17 ] , Cummings et al. [ CFM+18 ] , Krueger [ Kru19 ] , and Mohammadpour–Velickovic [ MV21a ] , among many other authors. Current interest in I[\kappa] extends beyond its original connection with the preservation of stationary sets. This is due to the interplay between I[\kappa] and other central principles in combinatorial set theory, such as Jensen’s \square_{\kappa} -principle and its relatives, and the Tree Property ( \TP ). In turn, this connects I[\kappa] with two major questions in the field, which have inspired the present work. Namely, Question 1.1 (Shelah, 80’s) . Let \kappa be a singular cardinal. Must the approachability ideal I[\kappa^{+}] contain a club set relative

Read the complete text