The Milky Way and M31 rotation curves in Yukawa gravity: phenomenology and Bayesian analysis Journal: -

Davendra S. Hassan e1,addr1, M Dio Danarianto e2,addr2, Anto Sulaksono e3,addr3 · 2025

Read The Milky Way and M31 rotation curves in Yukawa gravity: phenomenology and Bayesian analysis Journal: - by Davendra S. Hassan e1,addr1, M Dio Danarianto e2,addr2, Anto Sulaksono e3,addr3 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-04018.txt.

Introduction

Davendra Hassan and co-authors let two galaxies vote on a tweaked theory of gravity. Yukawa gravity adds a coupling strength and a reach to Newton's pull, and spiral galaxy rotation curves are a natural courtroom. The team built velocity models stacking bulge, disk, dark halo, and central black hole, then ran Bayesian contests on Milky Way and Andromeda data.

Four scenarios faced off: Yukawa alone, dark matter with coupling, fully modified gravity, and plain Newton. Short-reach Yukawa fits flattered the Milky Way but risked overfitting, while Andromeda's richer shape data favored Newton outright. The authors conclude that sharper data and honest priors, not cleverer curves, will decide whether gravity needs the extra terms.

Catalog record

CREATORDavendra S. Hassan e1,addr1, M Dio Danarianto e2,addr2, Anto Sulaksono e3,addr3
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE103 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-04018

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Milky Way and M31 rotation curves in Yukawa gravity: phenomenology and Bayesian analysis Journal: - Davendra S. Hassan e1,addr1, M Dio Danarianto e2,addr2, Anto Sulaksono e3,addr3 Abstract Yukawa gravity provides a generalized framework for modeling gravity modification. We investigate the rotation curve profiles of spiral galaxies under Yukawa-like theories governed by the coupling strength β \beta and the interaction range λ \lambda . We develop a unified analytical and numerical framework to calculate rotational velocities under Yukawa gravity, which includes contributions from all major galactic components: stellar bulge, disk, dark matter (DM) halo, and central supermassive black hole. The calculations show that β \beta and λ \lambda strongly influence velocity distributions, shifting peaks, creating double-peak structures, or enhancing dark matter dominance in the bulge or disk. To assess observational implications, we perform Bayesian analyses using data from the Milky Way (MW) and Andromeda (M31), which offer complementary characteristics: MW provides precise velocity profiles across multiple scales, while M31 includes broader morphological constraints. We examine four scenarios: Yukawa gravity without dark matter, dark matter with non-trivial coupling, fully modified gravity, and standard Newtonian gravity. Results show that MW models with λ < 1 \lambda<1 kpc yield high Bayes factors but risk overfitting, as dark matter mimics baryonic kinematics, while M31’s photometric priors from conjugate observations mitigate this, yielding robust parameter estimates. However, in M31, Bayes factors favor Newtonian gravity, suggesting that current data lack the precision to resolve more complex models. This finding highlights two key needs: (i) realistic, physically or empirically informed priors to avoid biased constraints, and (ii) high-precision data with independent photometry to guard against overfitting. Our framework offers a scalable approach for testing gravity with large galactic rotation curve datasets. ∎ 1 1 1 e-mail:[email protected] 2 2 2 e-mail: [email protected] 3 3 3 e-mail: [email protected] 1 Introduction Rotation curves (RCs) of a galaxy represent the average circular velocity of matter as a function of its distance from the galactic center and, under certain assumptions, can serve as a fundamental measurement of the approximate mass within a galaxy Bertone2018 . Assuming the mass is concentrated in the cores of galaxies, based on Newtonian gravity and general relativity (GR), these curves are expected to follow Kepler’s laws, where the velocity declines as v\propto 1/\sqrt{r} . However, empirical data in general, such as that gathered through optical (H \alpha ) observations and HI line spectroscopy Honma1997 , reveal flat RCs in the outer regions of the galaxies, i.e., v\propto constant, which highlights the mass discrepancies and possible modification of GR theory in galaxies. The explicit conclusions regarding the need for invisible matter, known as dark matter (DM) and or modified gravity (MG) theories, began to emerge. See Ref. Bertone2018 for a historical review of DM, Ref. Cirelli2024 for a complete review of the theoretical, observational, and experimental aspects of DM, and Will2018 for an overview of theory and experiments regarding gravitational physics. Despite the compelling nature of the DM hypothesis, it faces significant challenges, including the absence of direct observational evidence Bertone2018 ; Bertone2005 . DM is predominant in the galaxy’s outer regions, with the contribution of mass significantly surpassing that of luminous matter to account for the flatness of RCs Mannheim2006 . Thus, the nature of DM remains unknown. It is usually assumed that an unknown particle is not contained in the Standard Model of particle physics, where the possible mass of proposed DM particles depends strongly on the specific model and ranges span dozens of orders of magnitude. The most widely studied is cold DM (CDM), which has successfully predicted properties of the large-scale structure and some CMB anisotropies. An alternative model is Fuzzy DM (FDM), which has attracted attention recently because it predicts the scaling relation between DM particles and density parameters. Please see Ref. Khelashvili2023 for a recent study on using FDM to understand SPARC galaxies. However, while GR has passed numerous tests, some argue that the DM problem comes from the nature of gravity on galactic and cosmological scales, which indicates a deviation from GR. Exploring alternatives to GR offers a better way to probe its validity, ensure its universal applicability, and establish more precise constraints. Within the context of the gravity scale, galaxies and galaxy clusters offer an extensive range of gravitational potentials and curvatures ideal for testing gravity. However, high-resolution observations of the central regions are currently limited to the Milky Way and a few neighboring massive galaxies Baker2015 , such as Andromeda M31 and the Milky Way, which are both massive spiral galaxies, and hence useful for comparisons. The Milky Way and M31, Andromeda, are prime examples of spiral galaxies characterized by their distinctive spiral patterns. These galaxies feature relatively flat disk structures and are often called disk galaxies. The precise mechanisms underlying the formation of these disk and spiral structures remain a subject of ongoing problems within the field Binney2008 . This fact makes the Milky Way and M31 galaxies interesting subjects for testing theories of gravity, so that we can test gravity throughout all regions of the galaxy, compared to the more simplistic dataset in other spiral galaxies, such as that derived in the SPARC dataset used in previous studies. Using these galaxies, we can study the impact of somewhat precise rotational velocity v(r) observations/derivations, such as the MW rotation curve, and extragalactic observations, such as that of the M31, enabling independent galactic morphology measurements. Various MG theories, such as f(R) , scalar-tensor, and massive gravity theories, result in an additional exponential decay function to the gravitational potential, similar to the Yukawa potential in particle physics. Please see the examples in Refs. Almeida2018 ; Clifton2008 ; Stabile2011 ; Moffat2013 ; Rahvar2014 ; Henrichs2021 and the references therein. The Yukawa-like correction is often used to constrain gravity in experimental tests and literature, as it can represent a simple deviation from the Newtonian inverse square law. It is a generic representation of the weak-field limit of the aforementioned MG theories. The physical motivation behind introducing this Yukawa-correction can stem from a modified gravitational interaction between DM and ordinary matter (baryons) Piazza2003 ; Jusufi2023 ; Berezhiani2009 . Some of these studies have tried to relieve the core-cusp problem in galaxies through the Yukawa correction, hence it has become a central focus in recent cosmological research. Recent studies have investigated the Yukawa-like correction in late-type galaxies to establish a model that fits better with observed data. For instance, Ref. Henrichs2021 examined the Milky Way, while Ref. Almeida2018 examined the SPARC catalog of spiral and irregular galaxies. However, these studies are conducted assuming that baryons are weakly coupled to gravity to meet local gravity constraints, which impacts the constraints on the Yukawa parameters at the small-scale range of the galaxies, resulting in the analysis of the Yukawa correction only in the DM halo of the galaxies, with no studies specifically analyzing the baryonic sector. Moreover, they overlook the presence of a central supermassive black hole (SMBH) and the established experimental constraints on the Yukawa parameters, such as in Refs. Murata2015 ; Jovanovic2023 . Hence, this motivates the consideration of the Yukawa correction in all components of the galaxies, not just the DM distribution, but also in baryonic matter components. Building upon our previous preliminary

Read the complete text