Why Teach Quantum?: Elementary Teachers Initial Beliefs about Quantum
Xiaolu Zhang, Nancy Holincheck, Jessica L. Rosenberg, Stephanie Dodman, Ben Dreyfus, Jennifer Simons · 2025
Read Why Teach Quantum?: Elementary Teachers Initial Beliefs about Quantum by Xiaolu Zhang, Nancy Holincheck, Jessica L. Rosenberg, Stephanie Dodman, Ben Dreyfus, Jennifer Simons (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-03849.txt.
Introduction
Xiaolu Zhang and co-authors report what elementary teachers first thought about teaching quantum topics in this 2025 study. Eleven teachers joined a funded project to build their own quantum knowledge and make classroom materials for young students. The teachers began with limited knowledge of the subject themselves. Even so, they voiced excitement about bringing the ideas to their classes, and they believed early contact with quantum concepts would open future doors for their students.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Xiaolu Zhang, Nancy Holincheck, Jessica L. Rosenberg, Stephanie Dodman, Ben Dreyfus, Jennifer Simons |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 20 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-03849
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Why Teach Quantum?: Elementary Teachers Initial Beliefs about Quantum Thanks: This work was funded through the NSF EAGER: Quantum Teaching and Learning in Elementary Classrooms, award 2329874. Xiaolu Zhang, Nancy Holincheck, Jessica L. Rosenberg, Stephanie Dodman, Ben Dreyfus, Jennifer Simons Abstract This paper examines the initial beliefs held by elementary educators (n=11) and their students about teaching and learning quantum concepts at the elementary level. All teachers were participants in a grant-funded project focused on developing teachers’ quantum content knowledge and creating curricular resources to use in elementary classrooms. Although elementary teachers had limited knowledge of quantum at the beginning of the project, they expressed excitement and a belief that learning quantum would create future possibilities for their students. I Introduction Quantum education research has traditionally focused on undergraduate student learning in physics courses [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] . At the K-12 level, research has predominantly focused on high school physics, with some additional research on computer science applications of quantum [ 4 , 5 ] . In recent years, efforts have been made to connect quantum concepts to a variety of high school disciplines and in middle school [ 6 ] . Our research team is working to introduce quantum to students at an even earlier age, beginning in elementary school. Bringing quantum science to students in the early grades is critical, as children begin to develop their interests and career aspirations during their elementary years [ 7 ] , and they are best positioned to develop positive attitudes towards STEM disciplines before they enter middle school [ 8 ] . Our two-year project examines elementary teacher learning and curriculum development through an extended professional learning program during year 1, as well as classroom implementation and elementary student learning in year 2. This paper focuses on year 1 data and examines the perceptions of 11 elementary educators about quantum teaching and learning. II Methods Design-based Implementation Research (DBIR) [ 9 ] was used as an overarching framework for program design and development. DBIR is particularly appropriate because it focuses on problems of practice from multiple perspectives, is expected to evolve iteratively over the course of the grant, and focuses on developing the capacity for sustaining change in teaching and teacher education [ 10 ] . As a model that emphasizes iterative cycles of design and testing and simultaneous attention to multiple levels of systems in design, DBIR provided a framework for our team to inquire about how to best educate elementary teachers about quantum so that they can learn to integrate quantum in their teaching and develop quantum curricular resources that are relevant to their elementary classrooms. The following research question directed our inquiry: What are teachers’ perceptions about introducing quantum concepts in elementary classrooms? II-A Context of the Study In year 1 of the project (2023-24), we led teachers in twelve sessions of professional learning and curricular resource development. Teachers participated in three in-person sessions on campus with the research team and nine online synchronous sessions using Zoom. Early sessions focused on discussing quantum concepts, including atomic scale and structure, properties of electromagnetic waves, wave-particle duality, quantum superposition, quantum entanglement, applications of quantum, and potential future careers in quantum. Recommendations from prior research for integrating quantum into K-12 education [ 11 , 12 ] have focused on how to help learners make sense of this challenging and often abstract topic. Strategies to do this include using visuals and hands-on approaches in teaching quantum, using analogies to make abstract concepts more accessible, focusing more on concepts than mathematics, and aligning quantum with existing educational standards. We designed our teachers’ professional learning experiences around these strategies, using a spiraling method to return to concepts over subsequent professional development sessions. In our PD we used interactive Google Slides and small group discussions around the concepts to support and assess teacher learning. Elementary teachers in the United States are subject-matter generalists who may have only a cursory understanding of some STEM concepts and often lack confidence in their ability to teach STEM [ 13 ] . To address this, we engaged teachers in different ways to help them learn about quantum and to reflect on their learning. We provided books related to quantum to our teachers and compiled online resources for them to refer to at key points during professional learning. We were purposeful in surfacing misconceptions about atomic structures and quantum concepts and engaging teachers in discussions and activities to address these misconceptions. Beginning in the fifth session of professional development, our teachers began working in small groups to identify small classroom-based inquiries they could engage in to explore the questions they had about their students’ learning of quantum and to design and develop new quantum curricular materials. Teachers were encouraged to design small activities that fit within their curriculum and to make discrete connections to quantum concepts. II-B Participants During the first year, the research team recruited elementary teachers from schools and districts in Northern Virginia, Washington, D.C., and Maryland. A total of 40 teachers applied to participate, only 31 of whom were elementary teachers. The research team reviewed the applications and selected 11 teachers to participate in the project. In our selection, we prioritized teacher teams from the same school and aimed to include teachers from multiple school districts. When choosing between teachers from the same school district, we prioritized teachers from Title I and majority-minority schools. Our 11 participants included elementary school teachers and STEM or STEAM specialist teachers. These participants were from eight different schools spanning five counties. Five of these schools are Title I schools. The researchers facilitated bi-weekly meetings, amounting to a total of 12 sessions over a six-month period. The structure of these sessions was diverse, blending in-person, virtual meetings via Zoom, and one-on-one check-ins. The in-person meetings were designed to allow participants to engage in hands-on activities that illustrated quantum principles. Meanwhile, the Zoom meetings aimed to clarify quantum concepts and explore how these ideas align with existing curriculum standards. The individual check-ins served as a more private forum, offering participants a chance to voice questions or concerns they might have been hesitant to share in the larger group settings. II-C Data Sources Before the initial session, the research team conducted virtual interviews with each participant. These interviews were intended to gather baseline data on the participants’ understanding of quantum science, any connections they perceived with current curriculum standards, their views on STEM education, and their self-perception as STEM educators. The interviews were all recorded on video for thorough analysis. Alongside the interviews, the participants were asked to fill out a survey. This survey aimed to draw out the participants’ questions about quantum concepts and the nuances of integrating these ideas into elementary-level teaching. Additionally, each participant was asked to maintain a journal throughout the study. The journal served as a personal log for them to document new insights, ’Aha’ moments, misconceptions regarding quantum, and their emotional journey during the research. The researchers also encouraged participants to prompt questions about quantum with their students, such as “what is quantum?” This paper includes data derived from the interviews, surveys, and journal entries of the participants. Institutional Review Board approval was obtained