TaxSolver : A methodology to design optimal income tax reform

Mark Verhagen, Menno Schellekens, Michael Garstka · 2025

Read TaxSolver : A methodology to design optimal income tax reform by Mark Verhagen, Menno Schellekens, Michael Garstka (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-03708.txt.

Introduction

Mark Verhagen, Menno Schellekens, and Michael Garstka present TaxSolver, a method that designs income tax reform as a constrained optimization problem. The head frames the work as a piecewise-linear framework with a software build, in a 2025 paper. Tax codes have grown into tangles of brackets, benefits, and deductions, and viable reform plans are hard to design by hand.

Under four mild assumptions, any tax code becomes a piecewise-linear function per taxpayer group. Reform then turns into a linear program over rates, bracket cutoffs, and transfers. The tool can rebuild current systems, find provably optimal reforms, or certify that no reform meets the set limits. A near complete rebuild of the Dutch tax code demonstrates the method.

Catalog record

CREATORMark Verhagen, Menno Schellekens, Michael Garstka
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE96 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-03708

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

TaxSolver : A methodology to design optimal income tax reform Thanks: We would like to thank the following people for helpful conversations and comments: Luka Boeskens, Jasper van Dijk, Yifan Duan, Joaquim Gromicho, Dick den Hertog, Elias de Korte, Romee Lind, Matthew Salganik, Dick van der Sluijs, Ole Teutloff, Vinzenz Ziesemer. We would also like to thank colleagues at the Centre for Information Technology Policy for helpful comments and support in realizing this paper. Mark Verhagen, Menno Schellekens, Michael Garstka Abstract Across the developed world, there are growing calls to streamline and improve ever more complex income tax codes. Executing reform has proven difficult. Even when the desired outcomes of a reform are clear, the tools to design fitting reforms are lacking. To remedy this, we developed TaxSolver : a methodology to help policymakers realize optimal income tax reform. TaxSolver allows policymakers to focus solely on what they aim to achieve with a reform—like redistributing wealth, incentivizing labor market participation or reducing complexity— and the guarantees within which reform is acceptable—like limiting fluctuations in taxpayer incomes, protecting households from falling into poverty or shocks to overall tax revenue. Given these goals and fiscal guarantees, TaxSolver finds the optimal set of tax rules that satisfies all the criteria or shows that the set of demands are not mathematically feasible. We illustrate TaxSolver by reforming various simulated examples of tax codes, including some that reflect the complexity and size of a real-world tax system. Evidence for Practice 1. Most tax codes can be defined as a simple system of equations that make it possible to solve tax reform as (linear) optimization problem. 2. Linear optimization allows policymakers to formulate both hard guarantees that the reform has to adhere to, as well as objectives that are maximized within these set constraints. This makes optimization a practical tool that is aligned with the reality of policy work. 3. Our approach allows for a tax reform process that does not consist of ad-hoc tweaking of existing rules but reasons over the entire system and returns an optimal solution in a matter of hours rather than weeks. 4. We illustrate our approach by reforming various example systems, as well as a system representing the complexity and scale of a real-world income tax code. 1 Introduction To illustrate the problem this paper is trying to solve, we start with a brief anecdote about a civil servant named Jesse. Jesse works in the finance ministry of a developed country and is part of a special team tasked with proposing a new income tax reform. The main objectives are (i) simplifying a bloated income tax system and (ii) incentivizing labor market participation. Naturally, the reform has to be budget neutral and protect households against large income swings. The team optimistically starts mapping out the various tax rules in existence, but quickly realize the tax code is more difficult to navigate than they had expected. Tax rules discriminate on the basis of myriad characteristics: renter versus buyer, affluent versus those with minimal savings, high income versus low income, households with children versus those without, partnered versus single individuals, pensioners versus the young, and so on. The number of potential modifications appear limitless, and tweaking one rule often results in unexpected ripple effects elsewhere. Having experienced the system’s complexity first hand, the team decides to start with simplification. They propose to merge the lowest two income brackets, providing a small tax revenue buffer. They also remove the top tax bracket—leading to a budget deficit—that further reduces complexity and increases labor incentives by slashing rates for high incomes. On analyzing the downstream effects of their initial reform, the team realizes a large proportion of low income taxpayers would fall into poverty due to increased lower end taxation. To remedy this, the team develops an income-dependent benefit. This benefit provides income support that falls with increasing income. By setting separate amounts for fiscal partners and single households, the benefit is less costly than reinstating the original lower bracket, reducing the budget deficit. As the team has now re-introduced complexity into the system, they merge the child benefit, formerly a separate rule, into this new benefit and dub it the “household composition income-dependent benefit”, or HCIDB. Reflecting on their work, Jesse would be the first to admit the reforms may not be perfect, but certainly progress. Little did Jesse know this was just the beginning. The team’s initial proposal will go on to be dissected by government advisory bodies who might identify loopholes or faults with the original proposals. This cumbersome review process will likely show that some of the changes are less effective than originally hoped or conflict in unambiguous ways with existing rules ( Lejour 2016a ) . At the same time, intense public and political debate will likely ensue. Politicians, policy think tanks and rights groups alike will scrutinize the proposals ( Alt et al. 2010a ) . These political actors are faced with the same challenges in overseeing the system as Jesse and her team, and this will force them to focus on anecdotal examples or cling to tax rules out of principle. Many of these actors will also have conflicting goals to those of the original reform. The team will scramble to save as much of the original proposal under a barrage of amendments and criticism, while the independent review process starts lagging behind and ultimately becomes disconnected through the changes that arise from the political horsetrading. At the end of all this, if at all, the tax reform that does occur will be unrecognizable from the already sub-optimal proposal the team originally started with. Some form of the above story has occurred across many of the realized and unrealized tax reform efforts in countries across the world. This fraught process has led to complex and suboptimal tax codes, often with unexpected quirks that have real impact. For example, the United Kingdom’s income tax code has a so-called 60%-tax trap where marginal pressure, the effective tax rate, becomes excessively high at incomes between 100,000 and 125,140 GBP, reducing work incentives and leading to workarounds like increased pension contributions ( Dodwell et al. 2024a ) . The Netherlands has marginal tax rates upwards of 80% for some middle-income households, far above what economic theory would prescribe ( Quist 2015a ) . Tax reforms in the US have inadvertently created ‘marriage penalties’ for certain demographic groups, where real income declines based on marital status ( Crandall-Hollick & Greenstein 2025a ) . In most cases, these ‘cliffs’ arose because well-intended reforms had unwanted consequences. In short, most realized tax systems are a far cry from what optimal tax theory recommends ( Feldstein 1976a ; Diamond & Saez 2011a ) . In fact, most tax systems and reforms are far removed from their own original intentions. How can this be? It is not due to a lack of ideas. There is a wealth of literature on optimal taxation theory. However, governments become stuck in an equilibrium far removed from any optimal form ( Slemrod 2018a ) . Key reasons why governments struggle to implement reform range from the inherent complexity of income tax codes, governmental capacity constraints, and the broader political economy challenge

Read the complete text