Entanglement Detection Beyond Local Bound with Coarse Calibrated measurements

Liang-Liang Sun, Yong-Shun Song, Sixia Yu · 2025

Read Entanglement Detection Beyond Local Bound with Coarse Calibrated measurements by Liang-Liang Sun, Yong-Shun Song, Sixia Yu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-03525.txt.

Introduction

Liang-Liang Sun, Yong-Shun Song, and Sixia Yu sharpen a tool for proving that particles are entangled. Their 2025 paper builds on Bell tests, which set bounds that separate quantum links from classical ones. For spotting entanglement, the bound for unlinked states can be raised when something is known about the devices.

The team gives a general method for raising those bounds when devices are only coarsely calibrated, meaning they are trusted to make nonlocal links but not described in fine detail. Worked through standard inequality families, the method yields trade-offs that tune detection for two-party and three-party systems. It extends to many parties and to mixed cases where some devices are known well, catching entanglement even in partly local data.

Catalog record

CREATORLiang-Liang Sun, Yong-Shun Song, Sixia Yu
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE52 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-03525

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Entanglement Detection Beyond Local Bound with Coarse Calibrated measurements Liang-Liang Sun, Yong-Shun Song, Sixia Yu Abstract Bell’s test, initially devised to distinguish quantum theory from local hidden variable models through violations of local bounds, is also a common tool for detecting entanglement. For this purpose, one can assume the quantum description of devices and use available information to strengthen the bound for separable states, which may go beyond the local bound, enabling more efficient entanglement detection. Here we present a systematic approach for strengthening Bell inequalities for qubit systems, using Mermin-Klyshko-Bell inequalities as examples, by considering measurement devices that are coarsely calibrated only by their ability to generate nonlocal correlations without requiring precise quantum characterization. In the case of bipartite and tripartite systems, we derive trade-offs between upper bounds for separable states and general states in terms of structure functions to optimize the entanglement detection. We then strengthen n n -partite Bell inequalities for the detection of states exhibiting a diversity of entanglement structures such as genuine multipartite entanglement. For general Bell scenarios with some measurements characterized, we demonstrate that entanglement can also be detected with some local correlations by exploiting the Navascués-Pironio-Acín hierarchy of tests. pacs 98.80.-k, 98.70.Vc I I. Introduction Quantum entanglement is a resource accounting for quantum advantage in many quantum information tasks, such as quantum computation and communication Briegel et al. 2009 and metrology Ekert 1991 ; Giovannetti et al. 2004 . One important issue in quantum information science is thus to detect quantum entanglement carried by a quantum system, for which, Bell’s test Brunner et al. 2014 is one of the most frequently used tools. Correlations violating Bell’s inequalities can firmly verify the presence of entanglement. Furthermore, in a multipartite system, the degree of Bell’s violation can also indicate how many particles are genuinely entangled with each other, thus witnessing entanglement depth Sørensen and Mølmer 2001 ; Lücke et al. 2014 ; Yu et al. 2003 . Standard Bell’s inequalities, initially designed for the purpose of testing quantum theory against local hidden variables models Brunner et al. 2014 ; Gühne and Tóth 2009 , are formulated in terms of experimental statistics and without involving device descriptions. For entanglement detection, they have inherent limitations. A single Bell inequality is typically violated by only a specific class of states. Furthermore, there are entangled states that do not demonstrate non-locality Werner 1989 and, thus, cannot be detected by any Bell test. To overcome these difficulties, one can employ a quantum description of the systems and use available information to strengthen the bounds for separable states Wiseman et al. 2007 ; Uffink and Seevinck 2008 ; Lougovski and van Enk 2009 . Assuming projective and orthogonal measurements, the bound of the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt inequality (CHSH) Clauser et al. 1969 for separable states can be strengthened from the local bound of 2 to \sqrt{2} , leading to more efficient detection and providing a quantitative statement on entanglement Lougovski and van Enk 2009 . When only partial measurements are characterized, one approach based on the cross-norm Rudolph 2005 or realignment criterion Chen and Wu 2002 is exploited in Ref. Moroder and Gittsovich 2012 . Another fruitful approach is generalizing the Bell scenario to a measurement-device-independent Bell scenario via introducing characterized sources on each local side Shahandeh et al. 2017 , which can, in principle, detect all entangled states. While these generalizations have significantly advanced the theory of quantum entanglement, a key practical open question remains: how to strengthen Bell’s inequality using general measurements for multipartite qubit systems–the standard platform for quantum information science, for which, previous considerations mainly focused on the minimal Bell’s scenario using projective measurements Clauser et al. 1969 ; Lougovski and van Enk 2009 . In this paper, we tackle this issue by tightening Bell inequalities for multipartite qubit systems in two experiment settings. In the first one, we consider measurements that are coarsely calibrated with capability of generating nonlocal correlation, which are referred to as nonlocal-correlation-generating (NLCG) measurements. In this setting, we first consider bipartite and tripartite Bell’s inequalities and derive trade-offs between upper bounds for local and general states. These trade-offs enable one to verify entanglement without requiring precise characterization of them except that they are NLCG, namely, capable of generating nonlocal correlations. We then consider n -partite Bell’s inequalities due to Mermin-Klyshko (MK) Mermin 1990 ; Klyshko 1993 ; Uffink 2002 and provide a systematic approach to derive analytical bounds for states with various entanglement structures. In the second experiment setting, we consider more general Bell’s scenarios and adapt the Navascués-Pironio-Acín (NPA) hierarchy Navascués et al. 2007 for our purposes, with some measurements are characterized. Given that qubit systems are a standard platform for generating quantum entanglement — a central resource in quantum information science — our protocol offers a significant enhancement in entanglement detection across a wide range of applications. II II. strengthen Bell tests for separable states. We begin with a brief overview of Bell’s scenario, where an n -partite state \rho is distributed to n spacelike-separated observers. In each round, every observer randomly selects a measurement from a given set and records an outcome with certain probabilities. For the purpose of enhancing entanglement detection, we utilize available information about measurements to strengthen the bounds for separable state. We first consider the case that measurements are NLCG, namely, they have been ever used to generate some nonlocal correlation thus being calibrated based on the capacity to generate nonlocal correlations. II.1 A. Strengthening Bell’s test in bipartite systems We begin with the minimal Bell scenario, where there are two parties with each party performing one of two binary measurements, \hat{A}_{\nu} and \hat{B}_{\mu} , with \nu,\mu\in\{0,1\} and outcomes a,b\in\{1,2\} . The relevant Bell inequality, namely, CHSH inequality, reads \beta_{\rho}\leq 2 for local correlations, where \beta_{\rho}={A_{0}B_{1}}+{A_{1}B_{0}}+{A_{0}B_{0}}-{A_{1}B_{1}}, with {A_{\nu}B_{\mu}}=\mathrm{Tr}(\rho\hat{A}_{\nu}\hat{B}_{\mu}) denoting the expectation value. In this section, we do not require that these measurements are well characterized. Theorem 1 . In the minimal Bell scenario, if the NLCG measurements that can generate correlations with a Bell value \beta_{\rho}>2 on some state \rho , generates a correlation with the Bell value \beta_{\rho^{\prime}}\geq\textstyle\sqrt{2+2\sqrt{1-\left(\frac{\beta^{2}_{\rho}}{4}-1\right)^{2}}} (1) then the underlying two-qubit state \rho^{\prime} can be certified to be entangled. For the proof, we first consider projective measurements \hat{A}_{\nu}=\vec{a}_{\nu}\cdot\vec{\sigma} and \hat{B}_{\mu}=\vec{b}_{\mu}\cdot\vec{\sigma} with |\vec{a}_{\nu}|=|\vec{b}_{\mu}|=1 , where \vec{\sigma} is the vector of Pauli matrices. In this case, a\equiv\vec{a}_{0}\cdot\vec{a}_{1} and b\equiv\vec{b}_{0}\cdot\vec{b}_{1} uniquely characterize the measurements up to a unitary operation. As a result we shall specify these projective measurements by their relative angles \Omega\equiv\{a,b\} . Corresponding to a measurement setting \Omega , the Bell value for a general state \rho and a separable state \rho_{(11)}=\sum_{i}p_{i}\rho^{(i)}_{A}\otimes\rho^{(i)}_{B} are upper-bounded by, respectively, \displaystyle\beta_{\rho}(\Omega) \displaystyle\leq \displaystyle 2\sqrt{1+\bar{a}\bar{b}}\equiv{\rm U}(\Omega), (2) \displaystyle\beta_{\rho_{(11)}}(\Omega) \displaystyle\leq \displaystyle\sum_{\pm}\textstyle\sqrt{1\pm\bar{a}\bar{b}}\equiv{\rm U}_{(11)}(\Omega) (3) where \bar{c}=\sqrt{1-c^{2}} . Here, 2\leq{\rm U}(\Omega)\leq 2\sqrt{2} and \sqrt{2}\leq{\rm U}_{(11)}(\Omega)\leq 2 . When \Omega=\{\pm 1,\pm 1\} , the measurements are compatible, for which {\rm U}(\Omega)=2 is the minimum value over the possible sets \Omega , while {\rm U}_{(11)}(\Omega)=2 is the maximum. For a general set of projective measurements \Omega , these two bounds exhibit a trade-off \displaystyle{\rm U}_{(11)}{=}\sqrt{2+2\sqrt{1-\left(\textstyle\frac{{\rm U}^{2}}{4}-1\right)^{2}}}\equiv f({\rm U}), (4) where the concave and decreasing function f(\cdot) is referred to as a structure function. Such a trade-off stands also for general measurements. To show that, let

Read the complete text