UnMuted: Defining SARS-CoV-2 Lineages According to Temporally Consistent Mutation Clusters in Wastewater Samples

Dr. Devan Becker, Wilfrid Laurier University · 2025

Read UnMuted: Defining SARS-CoV-2 Lineages According to Temporally Consistent Mutation Clusters in Wastewater Samples by Dr. Devan Becker, Wilfrid Laurier University (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-03508.txt.

Introduction

Tracking COVID variants in sewage usually leans on clinical samples, and a 2025 paper by Devan Becker offers a way to let the sewage data speak for itself. The method, called UnMuted, defines virus lineages from groups of mutations that rise and fall together over time.

Standard practice ties lineages to a family tree built from patient samples, then adds up mutation counts in wastewater to guess each lineage's share. Becker instead uses many samples over time to estimate both the lineage shares and the lineage definitions at once. Three models are compared, two with a built-in time trend. The recovered lineages matched known ones, with matching time trends, despite using no clinical data at all.

Catalog record

CREATORDr. Devan Becker, Wilfrid Laurier University
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE49 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-03508

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

UnMuted: Defining SARS-CoV-2 Lineages According to Temporally Consistent Mutation Clusters in Wastewater Samples Dr. Devan Becker, Wilfrid Laurier University Abstract SARS-CoV-2 lineages are defined according to placement in a phylogenetic tree, but approximated by a list of mutations based on sequences collected from clinical sampling. Wastewater lineage abundance is generally found under the assumption that the mutation frequency is approximately equal to the sum of the abundances of the lineages to which it belongs. By leveraging numerous samples collected over time, I am able to estimate the temporal trends of the abundance of lineages as well as the definitions of those lineages. This is accomplished by assuming that collections of mutations that appear together over time constitute lineages, then estimating the proportions as before. Three main models are considered: Two that incorporate an explicit temporal trend with different constraints on the abundances, and one that does not estimate a temporal component. It is found that estimated lineage definitions correspond to known lineage definitions with matching temporal trends for the lineage abundances, despite having no information from clinical samples. I refer to this set of methods as “UnMuted” since the mutations are allowed to speak for themselves. 1 Introduction The SARS-CoV-2 pandemic has clearly demonstrated the efficacy of wastewater-based epidemiology. Many recent studies have used wastewater to predict case counts based on the concentration of SARS-CoV-2 in wastewater, detect current lineages of concern, and measure their relative abundance. Wastewater has also proven useful in detection of cryptic lineages and cryptic mutations. SARS-CoV-2 RNA molecules will break down in wastewater, making it impossible to reliably sequence entire genomes ( Lin et al., 2021 ) . Instead of whole genomes, Janssen et al., 2023 have found that approximately 400 base pairs (as implemented in the ARTIC protocol ( Quick et al., 2017 ; Quick, 2020 ) ) is an appropriate balance between recoverable genomes and efficiency of information gain. This means that we do not obtain sequences long enough to determine the SARS-CoV-2 lineage to which they belong ( e.g. , using NextClade Hadfield et al., 2018 or PANGO O’Toole et al., 2022 definitions). We instead obtain a collection of mutations, how often they were observed (count), and how often their position on the genome was observed (coverage/depth; i.e. , the number of times the mutation could have been observed). To determine lineages, we first must define what a lineage is. NextClade ( Aksamentov et al., 2021 ) and PANGO ( Rambaut et al., 2020 ) both assign lineages according to placement on a phylogenetic tree built from clinical sequences; lineages are not defined according to a set of mutations. Wastewater genomic sampling results in a set of mutations and thus requires lineage definitions as a list of mutations. These definitions are often found by querying clinical sequences to see how often a mutation was observed within a given lineage compared to how often it was observed in other lineages, thus creating an alternate definition of a lineage based on it’s “representative” mutations ( Ellmen et al., 2024 ; Swift et al., 2021 ; Karthikeyan et al., 2022 ; Valieris et al., 2022 , see, e.g. ,) . Given lists of mutations which define a lineage, estimations of relative abundance of the lineages proceeds according to the following principle: The frequency of a mutation should be equal to the sum of the proportions of each lineage for which it is present. For example, let f_{m_{1}} be the frequency (count divided by coverage) of mutation {m_{1}} . Let \rho_{X} , \rho_{Y} , and \rho_{Z} be the relative abundance (proportion) of lineages X , Y , and Z in the population, respectively (I will always use “frequency” for mutations and “proportion” or “abundance” for lineages). If mutation {m_{1}} is present in lineages X and Z but not Y , then we posit that f_{m_{1}}\approx 1\rho_{X}+0\rho_{Y}+1\rho_{Z} , that is, the frequency of mutation 1 is approximately equal to the sum of proportions of lineages to which it belongs. This assumption has been imposed by various authors, including: Ellmen et al., 2021 ; Karthikeyan et al., 2022 ; Valieris et al., 2022 ; Schumann et al., 2021 . As is implied by the equation, almost all estimators for the relative abundance are based on a linear modelling or generalized linear modelling framework. The dependent variable is f_{i} , the independent variables represented as 0s or 1s depending on whether mutation i is present in the lineage j , and \rho_{j} taking the place of the coefficients. Estimation procedures attempt to impose constraints to ensure that the the sum of the abundances is less than or equal to 1 and all of the abundances are between 0 and 1, with some of the estimators incorporating the coverage to ensure better estimates of the standard errors. These estimators assume a known definition of lineages as a list of mutations, although we know such definitions to be imperfect. In this work, I leverage repeated wastewater samples to get a temporally varying abundance estimate of each lineage while simultaneously estimating the definitions of those lineages. Wastewater mutation data are very noisy, so the temporal model smooths out some of the noise, with clusters defined accooding to the temporal pattern that best suits a mutation. I accomplish this with the following assumption (which replaces the assumption of perfectly known lineage definitions): lineages are defined according to clusters of mutations that persist over time. My definitions of lineages, then, are lists of mutations that tend to appear together consistently in wastewater (rather than in clinical sequences). This removes the dependence on clinical sampling, which is costly, subject to bias in the choice of whose infection to sequence and requires many more sequences than we currently obtain in order to get a complete estimate of the genetic diversity of SARS-CoV2. Other authors, including Ellmen et al., 2024 and Zhuang et al., 2024 , also leverage multiple samples to determine lineage definitions from wastewater alone. Ellmen et al., 2024 use non-negative matrix factorization to find patterns that exist in the observed frequencies of mutations. Zhuang et al., 2024 use independent component analysis (a form of blind source separation) to separate mutation frequencies into a collection of signals. They then take the largest signals from each source as evidence of presence of a mutation. Further post-processing is performed to determine the relative abundance of each estimated signal. Both of these approaches require an a priori choice of the number of lineages (clusters), but there are well-known diagnostics to help with this choice. In this work, I leverage the explicit temporal structuring of the samples to develop estimates of the proportions of lineages, which are estimated as clusters that are stable over time. This estimates a smooth temporal component, which differentiates the method from non-negative matrix factorization. The estimates of the lineages are part of the estimation procedure, rather than based on post-processing, and are not assumed to be independent, which differentiates this method from independent component analysis. 2 Methods The following model for the relative abundance within a wastewater sample was independently developed by myself and Valieris et al., 2022 . My version is available as an R package called provoc , which is short for

Read the complete text