Nonlinear analysis of causality for heat flow in heavy-ion collisions: constraints from equation of state
Victor Roy · 2025
Read Nonlinear analysis of causality for heat flow in heavy-ion collisions: constraints from equation of state by Victor Roy (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-03265.txt.
Introduction
Victor Roy tests whether heat flow in nuclear collisions can stay causal in a 2025 paper. Heavy-ion collisions create a hot fluid that theory describes with a second-order heat model. Causality fails if the model's signals outrun light, and the safe zone depends sharply on the fluid's equation of state and transport settings.
Solving the model's signal equations numerically, Roy maps zones of healthy, weak, and broken behavior against heat flux size and relaxation choices. With a realistic lattice-based equation of state, standard estimates of heat conductivity imply heat flows hundreds of times too large for typical collider conditions. A pressure correction trims the flow only slightly. Either the transport numbers are overestimated, he concludes, or the fluid picture itself strains here.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Victor Roy |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 43 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-03265
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Nonlinear analysis of causality for heat flow in heavy-ion collisions: constraints from equation of state Preprint: APS/123-QED Victor Roy Abstract We explore the causal parameter space of the Mueller-Israel-Stewart second-order theory for heat-conducting fluids in nonlinear regimes for one-dimensional fluid flow. We show that this parameter space is highly constrained and particularly sensitive to the equation of state and second-order transport coefficients. Through numerical analysis of the characteristic equations, we identify regions of strong hyperbolicity, weak hyperbolicity, and non-hyperbolicity, mapping the boundaries of causality violation as functions of the heat flux to energy density ratio q / ε q/\varepsilon and relaxation parameters. We also explore the causality conditions using a realistic lattice QCD-based equation of state. Using the Navier-Stokes approximation, we estimate the heat flow magnitude to assess causality criteria for one-dimensional heat conduction in heavy-ion collisions. Our calculations reveal unrealistically large heat flux values ( | 𝐪 | / ε ∼ 330 − 811 |{\bf{q}}|/\varepsilon\sim 330-811 ) for typical RHIC conditions when using thermal conductivity estimates from kinetic theory models, suggesting either significant overestimation of transport coefficients or breakdown of the fluid approximation in these extreme conditions. The pressure gradient corrections reduce the heat flow by approximately 15% but do not resolve the causality concerns. I Introduction The study of relativistic dissipative fluid dynamics has gained significant attention due to its relevance in describing extreme physical conditions such as those in the neutron stars, and ultra relativistic heavy-ion collisions. Among the most established frameworks for relativistic dissipation the oldest and widely used is the Mueller-Israel-Stewart (MIS) theory MIS1 ; MIS2 , which addresses the acausality and instability issues inherent in the straightforward relativistic generalization of the Navier-Stokes equations NS1 ; NS2 . Among some of the recent improved formulation are DNMR theory Denicol2012 , developed by Denicol, Niemi, Molnar, and Rischke; BRSSS theory developed by Baier, Romatschke, Son, Starinets, and Stephanov Baier2008 , and the BDNK framework, introduced by Bemfica, Disconzi, Noronha, and Kovtun Bemfica2019 . DNMR is a second-order relativistic hydrodynamics formulation derived from kinetic theory using the 14-moment approximation. It extends the Mueller-Israel-Stewart (MIS) framework by truncating the moment equations to include only the slowest eigenmodes of the linearized collision integral, reducing the number of dynamical variables while maintaining causality and stability Denicol2012 . BRSSS is also a second-order relativistic hydrodynamics formulation that ensures causality and conformal invariance, particularly in strongly coupled systems like the quark-gluon plasma (QGP). Meanwhile, BDNK is a first-order approach that still offers causality and stability Pandya2022 ; Bemfica2022 . MIS theory, rooted in extended irreversible thermodynamics EIT , introduces relaxation times for dissipative currents, ensuring a causal and stable evolution under specific conditions Baier2008 and is one of the most widely used formulation of dissipative hydrodynamics in heavy-ion collisions. The importance of causality in relativistic hydrodynamics originates from the requirement that signal propagation must not exceed the speed of light. This condition is mathematically reflected in the hyperbolicity of the equations of motion, which is guaranteed when the eigenvalues of the characteristic determinant are real, positive and distinct RezzollaZanotti2013 . Although many previous studies SusskindCausality ; KrotscheckKundt1978 ; Gavassino2020 ; Gavassino:2025bxx ; Grossi2018 ; Pu2010 ; Biswas:2022hiv ; Biswas:2020rps ; Causality1 ; Sammet2023 ; Bhattacharyya:2024tfj ; Spalinski2023 ; Perna2021 ; Brito2022 ; BDN2019 ; Wang2024 ; Hiscock1985 have analyzed causality and stability mostly in the linear regime, including the effects of shear stress and net charge diffusion, there remains significant scope to explore the hyperbolicity of MIS theory in the context of heat conducting fluids, particularly in the non-linear regime. This issue is particularly relevant for systems exhibiting significant heat flux Gavassino2024 . As noted by Hiscock and Lindblom Hiscock1988 , the strict hyperbolicity of the equations of motion can break down when the heat flux becomes extremely large, with the ratio |q|/\varepsilon reaching some critical values. For instance, they reported that for |q|/\varepsilon\approx 0.08898 for a conformal fluid, the fluid equations cease to be hyperbolic, corresponding to a regime of extraordinarily large heat flux unlikely to be encountered in realistic physical systems. Additionally, they showed that varying transport coeffcients, such as adopting a ten times larger relaxation time through parameter \beta_{1} , can extend the hyperbolicity domain to |q|/\varepsilon\approx 1/3 . In ultrarelativistic heavy-ion collisions, where deviations from equilibrium can be substantial, it is important to explore whether the heat flux values and causality limits predicted by the MIS framework fall within physically realistic ranges. One of the aims of this work is to estimate the typical order of magnitude of heat flux in such systems and investigate the extent of the causality-constrained parameter space. We show that with the current estimate of coefficient of thermal conductivity the heat flow could reach extremely large values for central fireball temperatures as low as 150 MeV. It is well known that the choice of hydrodynamic frame for defining the fluid four-velocity in dissipative fluids can lead to specific cases such as the Landau frame, where heat flow does not contribute to the energy flux T^{0i} but reappears as a finite baryon current that is proportional to the thermal conductivity and the gradient of the ratio of chemical potential to temperature PhysRevD.31.53 . Conversely, one can choose a different frame, such as the Eckart frame, where the dissipative part of the baryon four-current vanishes and the energy flux becomes non-vanishing Eckart1940 ; KunihiroTsumura2008 ; Monnai2019 . In this work, we investigate the hyperbolicity of the MIS second-order theory for a heat-conducting fluid in Eckart frame. Our analysis focuses on the dependence of the causality space on the equation of state (EoS), which relates the thermodynamic variables of the fluid. Specifically, we examine the characteristic propagation speed for a one dimensional fluid flow as a function of the ratio of heat flux to fluid energy density, q/\varepsilon , to determine the parameter space where the theory remains causal. This exploration is crucial for understanding the applicability of the MIS framework to realistic physical scenarios involving significant heat fluxes. For the equation of state, we adopt both a constant-speed-of-sound EoS, p=c_{s}^{2}\varepsilon , and a realistic lattice QCD EoS, which provides a more accurate representation of strongly interacting matter at high temperatures. By comparing these two cases, we aim to elucidate the EoS dependence of the causality constraints. To keep things simple we disregard here the net baryon density dependence of the speed of sound. Our study mostly builds upon the formalism presented in Hiscock1988 , where the Eckart frame was used to analyze the stability and hyperbolicity of relativistic heat-conducting fluids. The results of this investigation provide insights into the conditions under which the MIS theory remains hyperbolic (an essential condition for well-posedness) and applicable to systems far from equilibrium, particularly for the early phase of hot and dense nuclear matter produced in high-energy heavy-ion collisions. The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. In Sec. II , we outline the theoretical framework and governing equations. Sec. III presents the results of our analysis of hyperbolicity and causality for various equations of state and relaxation times. We also discuss the implications of our findings for different equations of state, including a recent lattice QCD equation of state. Furthermore, we include a brief discussion of the