Visualising relativistic effects in redshift space distortions of large scale structure

Pritha Paul, Chris Clarkson · 2025

Read Visualising relativistic effects in redshift space distortions of large scale structure by Pritha Paul, Chris Clarkson (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-03249.txt.

Introduction

Pritha Paul and Chris Clarkson draw pictures of how relativity bends the apparent shapes of cosmic structures, in this 2025 paper. Astronomers map galaxies by redshift, and motion along the line of sight squashes round clusters into ellipsoids, a famous distortion. On the largest scales, subtler effects from the Doppler shift and from gravity's own redshift join in.

Those higher order effects break the symmetry of the squashing, turning spheres into egg or bean like forms. The authors work out how over dense regions, clusters and superclusters with matter falling in, and under dense voids with matter flowing out, should look once the full relativistic treatment is applied. The pictures matter practically: stacking voids to measure them assumes they stay radially symmetric, and they do not.

Catalog record

CREATORPritha Paul, Chris Clarkson
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE44 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-03249

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Visualising relativistic effects in redshift space distortions of large scale structure Pritha Paul, Chris Clarkson Abstract Observing large scale structure in redshift space gives rise to the well known redshift space distortions whereby a spherical distribution of galaxies is distorted into an ellipsoid along the line of sight of the observer. This effect is important on linear scales and so can be thought of as a Newtonian correction to the density perturbation even though their physical origin is in the Doppler effect. On larger scales subtler aspects of the Doppler and gravitational redshift effects give rise to further distortions in redshift space. These further contort objects beyond an ellipsoidal compression, into shapes with broken line-of-sight symmetry such as an egg- or bean-like shapes. In this paper, we aim to qualitatively picture how large over-dense regions, including clusters or superclusters, and under-dense regions, such as voids, undergoing infall or outflow respectively, become distorted in redshift space when higher-order relativistic effects are taken into account. This will contribute when analysing structure in real space such as stacking voids which are no longer radially symmetric when these effects are included. 1 Introduction In redshift space, peculiar velocities along the line of sight distort the apparent positions of galaxies, leading to redshift space distortions (RSD), or the Kaiser effect [ 1 ] . On linear scales, this causes spherical over- or under-densities to appear squashed or stretched in ellipse-like shapes (for a comprehensive review see [ 2 ] ). However, on very large scales, additional distortions become relevant. These include asymmetric distortions along the line of sight, which go beyond the symmetric squashing described by the Kaiser effect. These relativistic contributions, mainly originating from the Doppler and gravitational redshift, are suppressed at least by a factor of \mathcal{H}/k relative to the leading RSD terms ( here, \mathcal{H} is the conformal Hubble rate and k is the comoving wavenumber ). Although these effects are subdominant on small to intermediate scales, they become increasingly important on large scales and cannot be neglected [ 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 ] . These projection effects were also extended to second order [ 7 , 8 , 9 ] and more recently to third order [ 10 , 11 ] . The relativistic corrections to the observed galaxy number density become particularly important in the case of a multi-tracer analysis of the 2 point correlation function. Several groups have studied these corrections and shown that they give rise to odd multipoles in the cross-correlation between two galaxy populations [ 3 , 12 , 5 , 6 ] . In particular, [ 13 ] studied the correlation function between a bright and faint galaxy population, highlighting the asymmetry when exchanging their positions along the line of sight. This work provided a schematic representation of the physical effects involved, distinguishing between those that contribute symmetric and asymmetric terms. The Doppler effect and gravitational redshift in particular leave distinct imprints in the dipole of the observed signal. For higher-order statistics such as the bispectrum [ 14 , 15 ] and the trispectrum [ 16 ] , relativistic effects become relevant even within a single galaxy survey, particularly on large scales. To develop a more intuitive understanding of the nature of these effects beyond the simple linear Newtonian approximation, it is crucial to recognise that we observe galaxies in redshift space, not real space. This distortion is not an intrinsic feature of the real-space distribution, but rather a projection effect. While such distortions complicate the interpretation of galaxy clustering, they also encode valuable information about both Newtonian and relativistic contributions. The Newtonian approximation is sensitive to galaxy bias, whereas in the relativistic case, additional dependencies are introduced because of the evolution bias and magnification bias (and derivatives thereof). Importantly, the resulting odd multipoles are able to isolate these relativistic effects in large scale structure [ 17 , 18 , 19 ] . While the physical origin of these relativistic contributions has been studied at linear order, the resulting visual distortion of idealised objects in redshift space has not been considered in any detail. An exception is the work of [ 20 ] , who derived an expression for the observed redshift including relativistic corrections up to second order in velocity and applied it to the cluster-galaxy cross-correlation using N-body simulations. Their work showed that the relativistic second order terms introduce asymmetries and are sensitive to the non-spherical structure of halos. In this paper, we take a complementary approach to systematically investigate how these effects modify the over- and under-densities in redshift space up to second order in perturbation theory. Specifically, rather than consider a distribution of galaxies and systematically perturb each one to its redshift-adapted position, we look at the density field directly as derived in perturbation theory. This allows us to consider the variety of non-linear terms which appear and consider how structures get distorted from each of them in turn. We consider two idealised cases: a spherical cluster, modeled as an isothermal sphere, and a spherical void, described using a standard void density profile. We explicitly separate Newtonian and relativistic contributions in the observed galaxy number counts to investigate their effects in the above cases. We expect the Newtonian contributions to preserve symmetry along the line of sight, while relativistic terms introduce distinct asymmetries at the perturbative orders we consider. The outline of the paper is as follows: In Section 2 , we provide a brief overview of the galaxy number counts at first and second order and introduce the general formalism for relativistic RSD. Section 3 describes the setup for the line of sight vector and the derivation of the peculiar velocity component along it. We also present numerical results for the two profiles mentioned above: the isothermal sphere and the spherical void. 2 The number count fluctuation in redshift space The fluctuations in the galaxy number counts \Delta can be expressed as a function of the observable redshift z and the observed direction \bm{n} , \displaystyle\Delta(z,\bm{n})=\frac{N(z,\bm{n})-\langle N\rangle(z)}{\langle N\rangle(z)}\,, (2.1) where \langle..\rangle is the average over observed direction \bm{n} at fixed observed redshift z and N(z,\bm{n}) is the number of galaxies. We expand ( 2.1 ) perturbatively up to order \mathcal{H}/k and we then we will proceed to investigate the visualisation of the different terms which originate from ( 2.1 ). 2.1 First Order The redshift space distortions, including the relativistic corrections, to the galaxy number counts have been calculated by several groups [ 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 ] . The dominant local terms are \displaystyle\Delta(z,\bm{{n}}) \displaystyle=b\delta-\frac{1}{\mathcal{H}}\partial_{\chi}v_{||}+\frac{1}{\mathcal{H}}v^{\prime}_{||}+\left(1-\frac{\mathcal{H}^{\prime}}{\mathcal{H}^{2}}-\frac{2}{\chi\mathcal{H}}\right)v_{||}+\frac{1}{\mathcal{H}}\partial_{\chi}\psi\,. (2.2) The dash denotes a partial derivative with respect to conformal time. Here, v_{||}=\bm{v}\cdot\bm{n} , where \bm{v} is the peculiar velocity of the galaxy. Consistently with our approximation we have ignored integrated effects and subdominant potential terms. It is also important to note that the relativistic contribution in ( 2.2 ) includes not only terms proportional to v_{\parallel} but also contribution from the gradient of the gravitational potential, \partial_{\chi}\psi . While this gravitational potential term might initially seem separate from the velocity contributions, it is connected to them via the Euler equation. As a result, the gravitational redshift contribution is effectively of the same order as the velocity

Read the complete text