Θ \Theta -Categories and Tannakian duality
Joost NUITEN, Bertrand TOEN · 2025
Read Θ \Theta -Categories and Tannakian duality by Joost NUITEN, Bertrand TOEN (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-03145.txt.
Introduction
Joost Nuiten and Bertrand Toen introduce a refined notion of categories, called Theta-categories, and prove a duality result with it, in a 2025 paper. The notion sharpens the idea of symmetric monoidal infinity-categories, a setting for higher algebra. Using the new notion, they relate these categories with stacks by means of a stack of fiber functors. The result holds over a base ring of any characteristic. It provides a strong link between Tannakian categories of this kind and schematic homotopy types, tying algebra to geometry.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Joost NUITEN, Bertrand TOEN |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 83 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-03145
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Θ \Theta -Categories and Tannakian duality Joost NUITEN, Bertrand TOEN Abstract We introduce a notion of Θ \Theta -categories, which is a refinement of the notion of symmetric monoidal ∞ \infty -categories. We use this notion to prove a Tannakian duality statement, relating Θ \Theta -categories with fpqc-stacks by means of a certain stack of fiber functors in the context of Θ \Theta -categories. This provides, over a base ring of arbitrary characteristic, a strong link between Tannakian Θ \Theta -categories and the schematic homotopy types of [ Toe06 ] . Introduction The idea that homotopy theory can be approached from a Galois or Tannakian point of view goes back to Grothendieck. This perspective was first incarnated in his theory of the fundamental group, both pro-finite and pro-algebraic (see for instance [ Ray71 ] , [ Del89 ] ). To the best of our knowledge, the fact that this point of view on the fundamental group can be fruitfully extended to more general homotopy invariants appears in two letters of Grothendieck: to Serre, dated 18.07.1959 for the pro-finite case (see [ CS01 , p. 75] ), and to Breen, dated 19.07.1975, for the pro-algebraic case (see [ Gro , cote 134-2, p. 75] ). In [ Toe00 ] , the second author suggested an approach to Tannakian duality for \infty -categories based on the notion of symmetric monoidal \infty -categories defined as functors out of \Gamma , the category of pointed finite sets. In [ Toe06 ] certain stacks, called schematic homotopy types , have been identified as the expected duals to Tannakian \infty -categories and have been used notably in the setting of non-abelian Hodge theory (see [ KPT08 ] ). Thanks to the foundational work of Lurie, actual Tannaka duality statements have been proven by several authors, see for instance [ Lur11 ] , [ Wal12 ] and [ Iwa18 ] . However, except in the specific case of characteristic zero, these results are obtained in the setting of E_{\infty} -algebras, which do not relate well to the theory of schematic homotopy types of [ Toe06 ] , and therefore do not provide the expected Tannakian interpretations for schematic homotopy types. The starting point of this work is the simple observation that any notion of Tannakian \infty -category solely based on symmetric monoidal \infty -categories will fail to relate nicely to schematic homotopy types, or to stacks in algebraic geometry in general. Indeed, for any stack F on the fpqc-site of affine schemes, the symmetric monoidal \infty -category \mathsf{QCoh}(F) of quasi-coherent sheaves comes equipped with natural extra operations, namely the derived symmetric power operations. These cannot be reconstructed purely from the symmetric monoidal structure, and their existence is a theoretical obstruction for any Tannakian-type reconstruction result in algebraic geometry. A second incarnation of this discrepancy can be seen at the level of commutative algebras. The theory of schematic homotopy types from [ Toe06 ] uses co-simplicial commutative rings, a sub-class of the \mathrm{LSym} -algebras (see e.g. [ BCN21 , Rak20 ] ) typically used in derived, as opposed to spectral, algebraic geometry. In characteristic zero, these \mathrm{LSym} -algebras coincide with the E_{\infty} -algebras that exist naturally in any symmetric monoidal \infty -category, but have an additional algebraic structure in general. The purpose of this short note is to introduce a rudimentary notion of \Theta -categories , which is a refinement of the notion of symmetric monoidal \infty -categories suited for a Tannakian interpretation of schematic homotopy types and similar stacks. The point of view adopted here will be somewhat minimalist and takes the second discrepancy mentioned above as its starting point. It is based on the principle that \Theta -categories should morally be symmetric monoidal \infty -categories in which an internal notion of \mathrm{LSym} -algebras exists. We implement this idea by defining \Theta -categories simply as pairs (T,M) , consisting of a symmetric monoidal \infty -category and a monad M over T equipped with a map from the E_{\infty} -monad and satisfying some conditions (see Definition 1.5 ). The typical example to keep in mind is the case where F is a stack, T=\mathsf{QCoh}(F) is its \infty -category of quasi-coherent complexes and M is the \mathrm{LSym} -monad, given by the direct sum of derived symmetric powers E\mapsto\bigoplus_{n}\mathrm{LSym}^{n}(E) . The main content of our work is that this definition gives rise to a well-behaved (2,\infty) -category of \Theta -categories, from which a Tannakian duality theorem can be proven (see Theorem 2.9 ). In particular, we show that any Tannakian \Theta -category T is equivalent, as a symmetric monoidal \infty -category, to \widehat{\mathsf{Perf}}(Fib^{\mathrm{LSym}}(T)) , the \infty -category of ind-perfect complexes on a certain stack of \mathrm{LSym} -fiber functors. The stacks obtained as stacks of \mathrm{LSym} -fiber functors are moreover essentially the schematic homotopy types of [ Toe06 ] . To finish this introduction, we would like to mention that the present approach to \Theta -categories is not optimal. The reader will for instance observe some limitations and unnatural conditions in our main result, Theorem 2.9 . This is the price to pay for our minimalist approach, but we mention some possible modifications and improvements in a final comment (see Remark 2.15 ). We also want to mention that a more systematic theory of \Theta -categories as symmetric monoidal \infty -categories with additional symmetric powers is presently under investigation by the first author. We believe that the outcome of this work will allow for stronger and more natural results in a near future. Nevertheless, Theorem 2.9 can be applied in several important situations to construct interesting Tannakian duals, such as the theory of Nori’s motives (from which we can extract a motivic homotopy type defined as a stack over \mathbf{Spec}\,\mathbb{Z} ), or the theory of exponential complexes appearing in [ KKP08 ] (from which we can extract the exponential homotopy type associated to an algebraic variety). These specific schematic homotopy theories will be studied elsewhere. 1 \Theta -Categories 1.1 \mu -Categories We let \infty\text{-}\mathbf{Cat}_{pr}^{R} be the (2,\infty) -category of presentable (1,\infty) -categories and right adjoints (i.e. limit preserving accessible \infty -functors). We have the corresponding (2,\infty) -category \mathsf{Fun}(\Delta^{1},\infty\text{-}\mathbf{Cat}^{R}_{pr}) , of morphisms in \infty\text{-}\mathbf{Cat}_{pr}^{R} . For any object f\colon T^{\prime}\to T in \mathsf{Fun}(\Delta^{1},\infty\text{-}\mathbf{Cat}^{R}_{pr}) , we will denote by f^{*}\colon T\to T^{\prime} the left adjoint to f , and sometimes write f_{*} instead of f . Definition 1.1 . An object f_{*}\colon T^{\prime}\to T in \mathsf{Fun}(\Delta^{1},\infty\text{-}\mathbf{Cat}^{R}_{pr}) is a \mu -category if f_{*} is conservative and preserves sifted colimits. Note that, by the Barr–Beck theorem [ Lur22 , Thm. 4.7.0.3] the condition of being a \mu -category implies that the canonical factorization of f_{*} T^{\prime}\to\mathsf{LMod}_{M}(T)\to T, induces an equivalence T^{\prime}\simeq\mathsf{LMod}_{M}(T) . Here M=f_{*}f^{*} is the monad on T associated with the adjunction (f^{*},f_{*}) , and \mathsf{LMod}_{M}(T) is the \infty -category of M -modules in T . Definition 1.2 . Let f_{*}\colon T_{1}^{\prime}\to T_{1} and g_{*}\colon T_{2}^{\prime}\to T_{2} be two \mu -categories in the sense of Definition 1.1 . A \mu -morphism from T_{1}^{\prime}\to T_{1} to T_{2}^{\prime}\to T_{2} consists of a commutative square in \infty\text{-}\mathbf{Cat} \textstyle{T_{1}^{\prime}\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \scriptstyle{u} \scriptstyle{f_{*}} \textstyle{T_{2}^{\prime}\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \scriptstyle{g_{*}} \textstyle{T_{1}\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \scriptstyle{v} \textstyle{T_{2},} with u and v colimit preserving \infty -functors, and such that the induced natural transformation g^{*}\circ v\Rightarrow u\circ f^{*} is an equivalence.