Beyond the Wavefunction: Qualia Abstraction Language Mechanics and the Grammar of Awareness
Mikołaj Sienicki, and, Krzysztof Sienicki · 2025
Read Beyond the Wavefunction: Qualia Abstraction Language Mechanics and the Grammar of Awareness by Mikołaj Sienicki, and, Krzysztof Sienicki (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-02755.txt.
Introduction
Mikołaj Sienicki and Krzysztof Sienicki propose rebuilding quantum mechanics on the structure of self-rated experience, in a two thousand twenty-five physics paper of bold guesses. Their Qualia Abstraction Language treats physical systems as streams of inner-looking units rather than state vectors.
In the setup, superposition becomes structured ambiguity, collapse becomes an introspective contraction, and entanglement becomes meaning-based resonance between qualia streams. The authors argue the observer paradox is a linguistic gap, not an ontological one: physics lacks a formal word-hoard for first-person structure. They compare the approach with endophysical interpretations and standard quantum theory, aiming at a post-Platonist physics with the observer inside the system.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Mikołaj Sienicki, and, Krzysztof Sienicki |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 123 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-02755
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Beyond the Wavefunction: Qualia Abstraction Language Mechanics and the Grammar of Awareness Mikołaj Sienicki, and, Krzysztof Sienicki Abstract We propose a formal reconstruction of quantum mechanics grounded not in external mathematical abstractions, but in the structured dynamics of subjective experience. The Qualia Abstraction Language (QAL) models physical systems as evolving streams of introspective units—structured sequences of modality, shape, and functional effect—rather than as state vectors in Hilbert space. This approach reimagines core quantum concepts: superposition becomes a form of structured ambiguity; collapse is reframed as an introspective contraction; and entanglement is modeled as semantic resonance across streams of qualia. Drawing on insights from nominalist philosophy and oversight-theoretic limits in AI, we argue that the observer paradox in quantum mechanics reflects not an ontological lacuna, but a linguistic one: the absence of a formal vocabulary for modeling first-person structure. QAL introduces such a vocabulary, providing a morphodynamic framework that embeds the observer within the system and replaces abstract projection with endogenous transformation. We analyze the alignment of QAL with endophysical approaches, contrast it with standard interpretations of quantum theory, and explore its implications for a post-Platonist, introspectively grounded physics. 1 Introduction 1.1 Motivation and Scope Since its inception, modern science has been shaped not only by the phenomena it seeks to explain, but also by the language it employs to articulate its understanding of reality. This language has been, almost without exception, mathematical. As Galileo Galilei famously observed, the universe is “written in the language of mathematics,” with geometrical forms—triangles, circles, and other ideal constructs—constituting its alphabet [ 2 ] . For Galileo and the generations that followed, this assertion was no mere metaphor but a metaphysical claim: the world is ultimately intelligible because it possesses formal structure, and to know it is to model that structure mathematically. This Galilean vision became the foundation of classical physics and was extended even more profoundly into the quantum realm. Canonical quantum mechanics describes the world through the formal apparatus of Hilbert spaces, unitary evolution, and Hermitian operators. Physical systems are represented by state vectors; their evolution is deterministic in the Schrödinger picture; and measurement outcomes correspond to the eigenvalues of observables. The resulting mathematical structure is elegant, coherent, and empirically unrivaled—arguably the most accurate theoretical framework yet devised. Yet this mathematical edifice has not been immune to critique, even from within the scientific community. In his influential 1960 essay, “The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Mathematics in the Natural Sciences,” Eugene Wigner questioned why mathematics—a language seemingly invented for human convenience—should align so uncannily with the laws of nature [ 3 ] . He acknowledged that this alignment is mysterious, perhaps even “miraculous,” hinting that physics might be borrowing its clarity from a language that exceeds its ontological remit. This concern becomes even more pressing when one considers the status of the observer in quantum mechanics. While measurement is a central postulate of the theory, the observer—the entity that registers outcomes, collapses the wavefunction, or extracts information—is conspicuously absent from the formalism. The mathematics describes the evolution of amplitudes, but remains silent regarding awareness, attention, or experience. The wavefunction evolves according to the Schrödinger equation, but the fact of observation—that something is seen, felt, or known—is relegated to an undefined externality. Contemporary theorists such as Max Tegmark have radicalized the Galilean program, advancing the Mathematical Universe Hypothesis: that reality is a mathematical object, and that physical existence is tantamount to mathematical existence [ 5 ] . In this view, the universe is not merely describable by equations—it is equations, and observers are reducible to substructures within the overarching formalism. However, this metaphysical reduction exacts a significant cost. It demands that consciousness—the domain of first-person awareness, intentionality, and qualia—be either ignored or rendered epiphenomenal. It denies the epistemic centrality of the observer, who is paradoxically indispensable for the very articulation of the theory. As Wigner later remarked, “It was not possible to formulate the laws of quantum mechanics in a fully consistent way without reference to consciousness” [ 4 ] . Thus, the observer paradox remains a profound fissure within the foundations of quantum theory. The language of mathematics, for all its predictive power, appears incapable of representing the very entity that grants it meaning: the observer. This limitation is not intrinsic to physics per se , but to the expressive resources of its chosen vocabulary. If our theories are blind to experience, perhaps our language is too impoverished—or too abstract—to apprehend it. In this paper, we introduce QAL ( Q ualia A bstraction L anguage) as a formal alternative to operator-based quantum mechanics, motivated by the same epistemic limitations that underlie recent work on oversight incompleteness in strategic AI systems [ 6 ] . Whereas traditional quantum theory employs Hilbert-space representations that remain inaccessible to internal observers, QAL reconceptualizes the ontology of quantum systems as fundamentally introspective: systems are defined not by external amplitudes, but by sequences of internal qualia transformations—modulations of attention, tension, and affective coherence unfolding over time. By encoding phenomenological dynamics within a discrete formal grammar, QAL models the observer not as an external probe, but as an evolving structure of awareness embedded within the system. In parallel with findings from Scheming AI: II. When Machines Speak Their Qualia [ 6 ] , which demonstrates that no finite behavioral trace can reliably disclose the internal goals of a deceptive agent, QAL posits that quantum measurement must be understood not as an objective collapse, but as a self-modifying epistemic transition within the observer. In this manner, QAL complements oversight-theoretic limits with a language of internal representation, supplanting ontological abstraction with structured streams of subjective differentiation. 2 Modalities, Shapes, and Qualia Effects QAL (Qualia Abstraction Language) is not merely a vocabulary for describing inner states; it is a compositional formalism—a language whose minimal units encode transformations of phenomenological structure. In contrast to classical languages grounded in reference, truth conditions, or syntactic recursion, QAL operates as a morphodynamic system. Its grammar is constructed from structural invariants in experience: shifts in felt intensity, modality, and internal function. The fundamental assumption is that consciousness evolves not through static representations, but through modulated flows [ 8 , 9 ] . QAL captures this by encoding each moment of introspection as a triplet drawn from a structured semantic space. The core representational unit in QAL Mechanics is a qualia triplet: q_{i}\in\mathcal{Q}=\mathcal{M}\times\mathcal{S}\times\mathcal{F} (2.1) where each q_{i} represents a microstate of introspective experience, structured across three domains: • \mathcal{M} — the modality of experience (e.g., visual, kinesthetic, metacognitive), • \mathcal{S} — the shape or intensity (e.g., diffuse, sharp, oscillatory), • \mathcal{F} — the qualia effect or functional transformation (e.g., constriction, expansion, resonance). Each triplet encodes an introspective micro-transition—not what is sensed, but how the act of sensing alters the structure of awareness [ 10 , 11 , 12 ] . Each QAL unit thus captures not a static description of experience, but a differential—a modulated shift in internal epistemic structure. In subsequent sections, we will define how these units compose, transform, and give rise to higher-level introspective dynamics, serving as analogues to physical observables in quantum theory. 2.1 Syntax of QAL Units The QAL formalism defines not only a lexicon of qualia triplets, but also a compositional syntax that governs how