Reframing Pattern : A Comprehensive Approach to a Composite Visual Variable
\authororcid Tingying He0000-0002-9670-5587, \authororcid Jason Dykes0000-0002-8096-5763, \authororcid Petra Isenberg0000-0002-2948-6417, \authororcid Tobias Isenberg0000-0001-7953-8644 · 2025
Read Reframing Pattern : A Comprehensive Approach to a Composite Visual Variable by \authororcid Tingying He0000-0002-9670-5587, \authororcid Jason Dykes0000-0002-8096-5763, \authororcid Petra Isenberg0000-0002-2948-6417, \authororcid Tobias Isenberg0000-0001-7953-8644 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-02639.txt.
Introduction
Tingying He and co-authors set out a full theory of pattern as a tool for showing data in work from 2025. Charts often fill areas with dots, lines, or shapes to stand for values. Past writing used the words pattern and texture in mixed, unclear ways.
The authors reviewed work across many fields to settle the terms. They treat pattern as built from small graphic parts placed in a planned layout. Three sets of choices define any pattern, covering layout, links among parts, and the look of each part. The scheme opens a wide design space for chart makers. It also gives researchers shared words for testing what works.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | \authororcid Tingying He0000-0002-9670-5587, \authororcid Jason Dykes0000-0002-8096-5763, \authororcid Petra Isenberg0000-0002-2948-6417, \authororcid Tobias Isenberg0000-0001-7953-8644 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 106 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-02639
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Reframing Pattern : A Comprehensive Approach to a Composite Visual Variable \authororcid Tingying He0000-0002-9670-5587, \authororcid Jason Dykes0000-0002-8096-5763, \authororcid Petra Isenberg0000-0002-2948-6417, \authororcid Tobias Isenberg0000-0001-7953-8644 Abstract We present a new comprehensive theory for explaining, exploring, and using pattern as a visual variable in visualization. Although patterns have long been used for data encoding and continue to be valuable today, their conceptual foundations are precarious: the concepts and terminology used across the research literature and in practice are inconsistent, making it challenging to use patterns effectively and to conduct research to inform their use. To address this problem, we conduct a comprehensive cross-disciplinary literature review that clarifies ambiguities around the use of “pattern” and “texture”. As a result, we offer a new consistent treatment of pattern as a composite visual variable composed of structured groups of graphic primitives that can serve as marks for encoding data individually and collectively. This new and widely applicable formulation opens a sizable design space for the visual variable pattern , which we formalize as a new system comprising three sets of variables: the spatial arrangement of primitives, the appearance relationships among primitives, and the retinal visual variables that characterize individual primitives. We show how our pattern system relates to existing visualization theory and highlight opportunities for visualization design. We further explore patterns based on complex spatial arrangements, demonstrating explanatory power and connecting our conceptualization to broader theory on maps and cartography. An author version and additional materials are available on OSF: osf.io/z7ae2 . \onlineid 0 \vgtccategory Research \vgtcpapertype please specify \authorfooter T. He ( ) is with Université Paris-Saclay, CNRS, Inria, LISN, France, and the University of Utah, USA. E-mail: [email protected]. J. Dykes is with City, University of London, UK. E-mail: [email protected]. P. and T. Isenberg are with Université Paris-Saclay, CNRS, Inria, LISN, France. E-mail: [email protected]. Introduction keywords Pattern, texture, visual variables, retinal variables, data visualization, Jacques Bertin. Visualization design at its very core relies on the mapping of data values to visual variables. Visual variables, also referred to as visual channels, are attributes of graphical elements—referred to as “marks” or “symbols”—whose appearance can be manipulated to encode data [ 72 ] . The visual variables that we draw upon are much studied and include position , hue , and size [ 5 , 6 ] . Their effectiveness ranking has been the subject of much research and discussion in our field [ 26 , 64 , 69 , 61 , 31 ] with scope for encoding nominal, ordered, and numeric data [ 80 ] . Among the available visual variables is one that researchers have called pattern [ 59 ] , typically featuring repetitive dots or lines . Visualization designers often use these patterns when color is either limited or already encodes other data dimensions (e. g., [ 6 , 5 , 11 , 12 , 87 , 78 , 91 , 22 , 82 , 55 , 28 , 43 ] ). When patterns are described as visual variables, researchers also refer to them as texture . This interchangeability of the terms “pattern” and “texture” may arise from the blended use of both terms in everyday language and the use of “texture” as a translation of Bertin’s visual variable “grain” in the English translation of his seminal and highly influential work [ 5 , 6 ] . To add to the confusion, however, the term texture has a diverse set of meanings in visualization research that goes beyond an understanding of texture as pattern . Researchers working on 3D representations, for example, often use texture for surface or volume characteristics of 3D objects, represented as realistic images [ 50 , 57 ] . These textures typically have different visual characteristics and encoding goals from the more structured repeating patterns that are used as a visual variable in abstract data representations . Even in the specific context of visual variables used for abstract data representations, researchers may interpret the term texture as a variation of a specific dimension of a pattern , such as “granularity” (Bertin’s “grain” in French) , the spacing between the repeated elements , or the elements’ shape . This méli-mélo de terminologie, we argue, prevents the research community from investigating pattern as a visual variable or using its encoding effectively. Research on patterns and their practice of use is difficult to compare and situate in the absence of a consistent terminology. We consider this situation to be a theoretical irritant with practical implications—a persistent blind spot that we aim to address with our work. Our re-reading of the literature [ 20 , 59 , 72 , 92 ] leads us to a consistent terminology, in which we use the term “pattern” to describe a composite visual variable that consists of graphical primitives that can also serve as marks for data encoding. Our first contribution is an in-depth discussion and clarification of the terms texture and pattern in light of existing interpretations around both terms, to address the inconsistent terminology problem. As our second contribution , we introduce a new pattern system that extends the conceptualization of pattern and its potential variations. This system builds upon our terminology to describe a design space in ways that can be used for encoding, exploration, and experiments. We identify three sets of attributes of a pattern: the spatial arrangement of primitives, the appearance relationships among primitives, and the individual appearance characteristics of primitives. Furthermore, we examine more complex spatial arrangements of primitives, using the concept of pattern as a theoretical lens to compare, explain, and connect different types of visualizations and to uncover new design opportunities. 1 Texture and pattern Researchers often use the terms pattern (e. g., [ 53 , 59 , 88 ] ) or texture (e. g., [ 44 , 91 , 94 ] ) to describe a visual variable characterized by repeated elements . Although both terms can make sense and are understandable, Carpendale [ 20 ] , in her discussion of visual variables, suggests to use the term texture for “apparent surface quality of the material like wood or marble” and to use pattern for ‘‘repetitive use of shape variations.’’ We consider Carpendale’s recommendation reasonable and useful 1 1 1 We agree that texture may primarily be used for materials, but argue that the pattern concept extends beyond the repetitive use of shape variations ( subsection 2.3 ). due to two main issues associated with the term texture : (1) compared to pattern , the term texture has a broader meaning in visualization and related fields, can refer to different concepts (as we show in Figure 1 and Figure 2 ), making it less precise; and (2), even when texture specifically refers to a visual variable, it is subject to different interpretations, even post-Carpendale [ 20 ] , as can be observed by comparing various publications that use the term [ 52 , 53 , 83 , 88 ] . Below we discuss the first of these issues and clarify the use of texture and pattern in the visualization literature, and explain why pattern is a more suitable term for this type of visual variable. We address the second issue in section 2 . 1.1 Texture: Surface characteristics The term texture