Entropy-Based Methods to Address Sampling Bias in Archaeological Predictive Modeling

Mehmet Sıddık Çadırcı 1 , Golnaz Shahtahmassebi 2 · 2025

Read Entropy-Based Methods to Address Sampling Bias in Archaeological Predictive Modeling by Mehmet Sıddık Çadırcı 1 , Golnaz Shahtahmassebi 2 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-02272.txt.

Introduction

Çadırcı and Shahtahmassebi correct for uneven survey effort in models that predict where archaeological sites lie, in a 2025 paper. Heritage models mislead when some areas were searched hard and others barely at all. Working with open data from a Utah national monument, the authors use Shannon entropy to score survey coverage and weight the model's background points accordingly.

They combined the weighting with four model types, from Bayesian spatial regression to random forests. The entropy-aware models proved more accurate and robust, especially in under-surveyed regions. The framework is offered as a transparent, scalable strategy for handling bias in archaeological data.

Catalog record

CREATORMehmet Sıddık Çadırcı 1 , Golnaz Shahtahmassebi 2
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE40 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-02272

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Entropy-Based Methods to Address Sampling Bias in Archaeological Predictive Modeling Mehmet Sıddık Çadırcı 1 , Golnaz Shahtahmassebi 2 Abstract Predictive modeling in archaeology is essential for the understanding of people’s behavior in the past and for guiding heritage conservation. However, spatial sampling bias caused by uneven research effort can severely limit model reliability. This research describes a novel new framework that integrates entropy-based corrections to measure and minimize such biases in archaeological modeling of foresight. Leveraging the open access data of the Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument, we employ Shannon entropy to determine survey coverage and assign appropriate weights to pseudo-absence points. We combine these weights with predictive models such as Bayesian Spatial Logistic Regression (via R-INLA), Generalized Additive Models, Maximum Entropy and Random Forests. Our findings prove that entropy-aware models exhibit improved accuracy and robustness, especially for under-surveyed regions. This approach not only advances methodological transparency, but also improves the interpretation of archaeological prediction under conditions of data uncertainty. The proposed framework offers a scalable, theoretically grounded strategy for addressing spatial bias in archaeological datasets. 1 INTRODUCTION Predictive modeling to predict where archaeological sites may be depending on environmental and spatial variables has become an increasingly indispensable tool in archaeological research and cultural heritage management. It supports the prioritization of research activities, provides guidance for identifying mitigation strategies, and illustrates comprehensive patterns of past human activity across large and various landscapes. Planning at a regional scale or academic research are activities in which today’s archaeologists employ predictive modeling of the location of sites in an increasingly predictive approach. Today, these models essentially become tools for balancing heritage conservation and economic development, given increasing development threats and limited resources for fieldwork. This unpredictability in archaeological predictive models arises from spatial sampling bias. However, unlike ecological or remote sensing surveys, which rely on a defined sampling design, archaeological surveys are normally determined by practical considerations - accessibility of land, subdivision of the landscape into plots, construction of infrastructure, etc. This creates the result of uneven coverage: Some sites are fully explored, while others are virtually undisturbed. Operating on biased observations for model training means that models tend to sell on over-explored areas and underestimate the presence of sites in remote or under-studied areas. Bias, in another form, tends to create a more damaging feedback cycle: According to the model, certain researched fields may be represented as high-probability sites (because they have yielded the most known sites), resulting in more research in the same areas, while neglecting hard-to-access areas. Although researchers have been recognizing these problems for decades, addressing survey bias has largely been done in a haphazard ways (through spatial filtering of data, weighting of background samples and the like) and without integrating such methods into the traditional practice, suggesting that a more principled approach is needed. Compounding these issues, many archaeological predictive models rely on presence/pseudo-absence data rather than true absence data. In practice, genuine absence points are rarely available in archaeology [ 17 ] , so researchers generate pseudo-absence points by assuming no sites exist in unsurveyed locations. These pseudo-absences can inadvertently mirror survey gaps rather than actual site absences, further skewing model outcomes by essentially marking poorly surveyed areas as “site-free.” For example, an algorithm may erroneously conclude that an uninvestigated valley contains no archaeological sites simply because none have been recorded there, engendering a false sense of certainty about an area never properly examined. The persistent combination of sampling bias and uncertain absences has prompted calls for predictive frameworks that explicitly account for survey effort and spatial uncertainty, ensuring that model predictions are not simply reproducing survey imbalances. In this paper, we introduce a novel methodology in the field of archaeological predictive modeling that combines random sampling concepts with statistical entropy [ 15 ] and is applied as a diagnostic and correction tools for sampling bias. The entropy measure is based on information theory and provides a quantitative uncertainty about the spatial distribution of the research effort. By examining the entropy of research on the study area, we can determine our under-sampled regions and characterize where our knowledge of site distribution is most precarious. Alternatively, these entropy values are included in the model-training process by weighting the pseudo-absence data according to their estimated reliability - training points in low-entropy (well-surveyed) regions are implicitly favored, while those in high-entropy (poorly-surveyed) locations receive no preference. This mechanism of weighting is a proper way to decrease the weighting of data coming from high uncertainty areas, thus compensating for the uneven research effort during the modeling. There is no doubt that the entropy approach works effectively on this large public dataset from the Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument in Utah. It is a particularly abundant dataset previously used for testing between competing Varietal models [ 17 ] , enabling us to assess how taking survey bias accounting can improve forecasting performance. For analysis, we consider several popular forecasting models, including Bayesian spatial logistic regression, generalized additive models (GAMs), maximum entropy (MaxEnt), and random forests (RF), and we weight the training data with an entropy measure in some versions and leave the data unweighted in others. These experiments will provide insights into the extent to which more accurate predictions and robustness resulting from deploying entropy-based weights may be available, especially in unexplored or under-explored areas and thus a source of complications for traditional modeling. This study aims to improve the interpret-ability, generalisability and fairness of archaeological site predictions by combining entropy analysis with state-of-the-art predictive modeling techniques. The proposed framework therefore strengthens the methodological rigour of spatial modeling in archaeology, providing a replicable approach to solving sampling bias issues in other disciplines that depend on incomplete or opportunistic data collection, such as ecology and paleontology. The structure of the paper is as follows: Section 2 discusses relevant contributions to archaeological predictive modelling, with a particular focus on presence-only modelling, entropy-based approaches and spatial statistics. Section 3 presents the methodology, including data pre-processing steps, the construction of entropy-based weights, and the application of four modelling frameworks: Bayesian spatial logistic regression, generalised additive models (GAMs), MaxEnt and Random Forests. The results and analyses from the comparative experiments are presented in Section 4 with particular attention paid to the effect of entropy correction on predictive accuracy, generalisation and overall model behaviour. The wider methodological and practical implications of entropic bias correction in archaeological modelling workflows are then reflected on in Section 5 . 2 LITERATURE REVIEW The application of Maximum Entropy (MaxEnt) modeling and statistical entropy has become prominent in archaeology and ecology over recent years. The literature review synthesizes the contemporary uses of MaxEnt and statistical entropy, stressing their strengths and weaknesses, including sampling bias and data non-representability. MaxEnt has been the go-to solution for predictive models in archaeology and ecology, mainly because of its ability to process presence-only data. Thus, Rafuse showed the use of MaxEnt to predict hunter-gatherer sites in Southern Pampas, Argentina, despite problems related to non-representative sampling and environmental conditions (Rafuse, 2021) [ 14 ] . In the same vein, Wang et al. showed that MaxEnt provides good predictions for archaeological sites in Japan and China, adding to the idea that these sites are not randomly distributed but instead somehow related to

Read the complete text