Time as a Cosmological Phenomenon

Andrea Palessandro · 2025

Read Time as a Cosmological Phenomenon by Andrea Palessandro (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-01803.txt.

Introduction

Andrea Palessandro argues that time's arrow is a property of the whole universe rather than of local physics, in this 2025 paper. The one-way flow of time shows up in every process we know. Palessandro ties that direction to the shape and connectedness of the cosmos itself, its geometry and topology taken as a whole. On this view, asking why time flows is a question for cosmology, not for any single system. The short paper states the claim plainly.

Catalog record

CREATORAndrea Palessandro
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE68 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-01803

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Time as a Cosmological Phenomenon Andrea Palessandro Abstract We show that the arrow of time is intimately related to the geometry and topology of the whole universe, and is therefore best understood as a cosmological phenomenon. Non è suo moto per altro distinto, ma li altri son mensurati da questo, sì come diece da mezzo e da quinto; e come il tempo tegna in cotal testo le sue radici e ne li altri le fronde, omai a te può esser manifesto. Paradiso, Canto XXVII 1 Introduction There are two opposing views in the philosophy of time, sometimes called the A theory and the B theory of time [ 1 ] . Roughly speaking, the A theory asserts that the flow of time is real, and, as a consequence, the future does not yet exist 1 1 1 Depending on whether the past is deemed to still exist or not, the A theory further divides into the growing block view and the presentist view, respectively. , while the B theory maintains that time is an illusion, and past, present and future are equally real 2 2 2 This is sometimes called eternalism , or the block universe theory, according to which temporal becoming is not an objective feature of reality, but a subjective illusion of human consciousness. [ 2 ] . The two views reflect an ancient philosophical debate that goes back at least to Heraclitus (advocate of the A theory) and Parmenides (advocate of the B theory). There are two ways to define time in physics that roughly correspond to the A and B theory ontologies. In classical physics 3 3 3 By classical physics I here mean non-quantum physics, so that includes the general theory of relativity. , time is essentially defined as a coordinate that identifies points in spacetime: in the theory of relativity, spacetime is a four-dimensional manifold parametrized by four numbers, one of which is time. On this manifold, all points are equally real, therefore it is impossible to define a passage of time, as in the B theory. The chief argument that supports this conclusion was developed independently by Rietdijk, Putnam and Penrose [ 3 , 4 , 5 ] . They argue that, according to (special) relativity, different observers moving at different velocities with respect to each other will have different planes of simultaneity, and hence different sets of events that constitute their present moment. If one takes the view that only the present exists (or at most the present and the past), the three-dimensional slice of the universe that is considered to exist at any given moment will vary depending on the observer, which violates a fundamental tenet of relativity theory. Even if it was somehow possible to define a universal “present moment”, as in Newtonian physics, it would still be impossible to define a direction, or arrow, of time. This is because all known fundamental laws of physics are time-reversible and cannot really distinguish between forward and backward time evolution. So while it might be possible in Newtonian physics to maintain that only the present moment exists, as its content is the same for all observers, it would still be impossible to determine in which direction it is evolving. While unambiguous, then, the B-theory definition of time in physics is unsatisfactory insofar as it does not conform with the human experience of time and memory. In General Relativity, time serves merely as a useful parametrization of events, and has no relation with what we commonly experience as ‘‘time’’ as a constant stream of changing events. The time of experience is instead captured much more closely by ‘‘thermodynamic’’ time, that evolves by definition in the direction of increasing entropy. This is the A-theory definition of time in physics 4 4 4 While thermodynamic time is compatible with the A-theory concept of time as “flow”, it is a matter of dispute whether this means that the future does not yet exist in a classical thermodynamic system. It has been argued that this can only be cogently said of quantum systems, in which there exist a fundamental difference between the certain past and the uncertain future via non-deterministic wave function collapse, see [ 6 , 7 , 8 ] . . Indeed, while there is no way to consistently define an arrow of time from microphysics alone (due to the relativity of simultaneity and the time-reversibility of the dynamical laws), its existence is certainly compatible with, albeit not mandated by, macrophysics, particularly thermodynamics. Whenever the spacetime manifold is entropically asymmetric, in the sense that it includes a relatively ordered low-entropy region 5 5 5 In our own universe, this corresponds to the Big Bang. together with a relatively disordered high-entropy region, it is always possible to define, at least locally, an arrow of time that connects the two, going from order to disorder [ 9 ] . The second law of thermodynamics gives a simple procedure to distinguish the past from the future [ 10 ] and is ultimately what gives rise to memory, and consequently to the psychological experience of the passage of time [ 11 ] . However, and crucially, General Relativity is not generally compatible with the second law of thermodynamics, meaning that there are solutions of Einstein’s equations for which no consistent formulation of the second law can be given. In other words, while the time of microphysics (the B-theory definition of time as coordinate of spacetime events) is always well-defined, the time of macrophysics (the A-theory definition of time as entropy increase), as we will see, is not. The fact that entropy can and does increase in our universe is not a fundamental law, and can only be understood as a cosmological fact, namely as the boundary conditions that gave rise to a time-orientable, synchronous, chronological, geodesically incomplete universe with vanishing Weyl tensor at the initial singularity. Were even one of the above assumptions false, for example in a universe that is not time-orientable [ 12 ] , a universe with closed timelike curves [ 13 ] , or a universe initially in gravitational equilibrium [ 14 ] , no coherent notion of time (and its passage) could be formulated. In light of these considerations, Earman [ 15 ] was the first to suggest that the arrow of time might be a geometrical feature of the universe. Rather than grounding temporal asymmetry in thermodynamic boundary conditions, he proposed that directionality could be encoded in global spacetime structure, causal ordering, and related topological properties. According to Earman’s time direction heresy , “temporal orientation is an intrinsic feature of space-time which does not need to be and cannot be reduced to nontemporal features”. This view was later expanded by Castagnino, Lombardi, and others in a series of papers [ 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 , 22 , 23 ] . Our view differs from Earman’s heresy (while being indebted to it) in that we maintain that nontemporal features, such as entropy, are indeed essential for defining a temporal orientation. However, these nontemporal features can themselves be meaningfully specified only when the underlying spacetime possesses the appropriate geometrical and topological properties. Accordingly, we assign primacy, but not

Read the complete text