Comment on ”Rogue waves on the double-periodic background in the focusing nonlinear Schrödinger equation”

Hans Werner Schürmann, Valery Serov · 2025

Read Comment on ”Rogue waves on the double-periodic background in the focusing nonlinear Schrödinger equation” by Hans Werner Schürmann, Valery Serov (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-01619.txt.

Introduction

Hans Werner Schürmann and Valery Serov dispute, in a short 2025 comment, a claim that certain rogue wave solutions exist for a focusing wave equation on a double-periodic background. An earlier paper had presented such solutions as exact. Checking them against the equation itself is the whole test an exact claim must pass. The comment reports that the proposed solutions do not, in fact, satisfy the equation, and on that basis the existence claim is judged faulty. The note is brief and purely corrective.

Catalog record

CREATORHans Werner Schürmann, Valery Serov
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE6 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-01619

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Comment on ”Rogue waves on the double-periodic background in the focusing nonlinear Schrödinger equation”
Hans Werner Schürmann, Valery Serov

Abstract
Some years ago, Chen, Pelinovsky, and White claimed existence of certain solutions of the nonlinear Schrödinger equation for modelling rogue waves [arXiv: 1909.08165v1 (2019)]. It is the aim of this Comment to outline that this claim is faulty. – The solutions presented do not satisfy the nonlinear Schrödinger equation.



In an article
ChPW
, Chen, Pelinovsky, and White presented solutions (Eqs.(1.2), (1.3) in
ChPW
) of the nonlinear Schrödinger equation (NLSE)

i\Psi_{t}(x,t)+\frac{1}{2}\Psi_{xx}(x,t)+\Psi(x,t)|\Psi(x,t)|^{2}=0

(1)

by using the ansatz ((3.8) in
ChPW
)

\Psi(x,t)=(Q(x,t)+i\delta(t))e^{i\theta(t)}.

(2)

Substituting (2) into (1) and separating real and imaginary parts they derived the system of partial differential equations – that must be valid necessarily if ansatz (2) is compatible with the NLSE (1) –

Q_{xx}(x,t)+2(Q^{2}(x,t)+\delta^{2}(t)-\theta_{t}(t))Q(x,t)-2\delta_{t}(t)=0

(3)

Q_{t}(x,t)+(Q^{2}(x,t)+\delta^{2}(t)-\theta_{t}(t))\delta(t)=0,

(4)

and evaluated (3),
to obtain solutions for
\delta(t)
and
Q(x,t)
(Eqs.(3.24),(3.28),(3.29),(3.32),(3.38) in
ChPW
). Finally they derived solutions (1.2) (from (3.23), (3.28)) and (1.3) (from (3.32), (3.38)).

In a recent article
SchSe
we considered the nonlinear Schrödinger equation and solution ansatz in the form

i\Psi_{z}(t,z)+\Psi_{tt}(t,z)+a\Psi(t,z)|\Psi(t,z)|^{2}=0

(5)

\Psi_{z}(t,z)=(f(t,z)+id(z))e^{i\Phi(z)}

(6)

with the assumptions
d_{z}(z)\neq 0,f_{t}(t,z)\neq 0
.

With
a=2,\frac{z}{2}\to z,
and apart from different notations of the variables and of the ansatz function, system
\{(5a),(5b)\}
in
SchSe
is identical with system
\{(3),(4)\}
. – Hence, results of
SchSe
can be applied to
\{(3),(4)\}
.

In
SchSe
, we transformed system
\{(5a),(5b)\}
to the dynamical system
\{(14a),(14b)\}
that, in the notations of
ChPW
reads

Q_{t}(x,t)=\sqrt{z(t)}(c_{1}-2(3z(t)+Q^{2}(x,t)))

(7)

(Q_{x}(x,t))^{2}=-Q^{4}(x,t)+(c_{1}-6z(t))Q^{2}(x,t)+\frac{z_{t}(t)}{\sqrt{z(t)}}Q(x,t)+2c_{2}+3z^{2}(t)-c_{1}z(t):=R_{2}(Q(x,t),t)

(8)

where
z(t)=\delta^{2}(t)
, and
c_{1},c_{2},c_{3}
are free integration constants (see Eqs.(8a)-(8c) in
SchSe
). Function
z(t)=\delta^{2}(t)
is uniquely determined by (see (5) in
SchSe
with
q=2
)

(z_{t}(t))^{2}=-64z^{4}(t)+32c_{1}z^{3}(t)-4(c_{1}^{2}+8c_{2})z^{2}(t)+4c_{3}z(t)=:R_{1}(z).

(9)

Function
Q(x,t)
is uniquely determined by Eq.(8). Explicit expressions for
z(t)
and
Q(x,t)
are given by Eqs.(7) and (8) (with
q=2
) in
SchSe-II
, respectively. Functions
z(t)
and
Q(x,t)
, as the solutions of Eq.(9) and Eq.(8), respectively, are valid for any parameters
c_{1},c_{2},c_{3},z_{0},Q_{0}
and variables
x,t
. We consider real parameters and appropriate
z_{0}
and
Q_{0}
and real
x
and
t
, so that the invariants of Weierstrass’ functions
\wp
are real and thus
z(t)
and
Q(x,t)
, since
\wp
is real for real arguments and real invariants. Evaluation of
z(t)
according to (7) in
SchSe-II
yields (with
z_{0}=0
)

z(t)=\frac{3c_{3}}{c_{1}^{2}+8c_{2}+\wp(t;g_{2z},g_{3z})},

(10)

where

g_{2z}=\frac{4(c_{1}^{2}+8c_{2})^{2}}{3}-32c_{1}c_{3},\quad g_{3z}\frac{8}{27}\left((c_{1}^{2}+8c_{2})^{3}-36c_{1}c_{3}(c_{1}^{2}+8c_{2})+216c_{3}^{2}\right).

Equation (8) in
SchSe-II
can be evaluated to (with
q=2
):

Q(x,t;Q_{0})=

\frac{-2\gamma_{2}\delta_{2}-(5\gamma_{2}^{2}-\alpha_{2}\epsilon_{2})Q_{0}+2\alpha_{2}\delta_{2}Q_{0})+4\wp(x)(\delta_{2}+2\gamma_{2}Q_{0}+\wp(x)Q_{0})+2\wp_{x}(x)\sqrt{R_{2}(Q_{0},t)}}{(2\wp(x)-\gamma_{2}-\alpha_{2}Q_{0}^{2})^{2}-\alpha_{2}R_{2}(Q_{0},t)}

(11)

with
\wp(x)=\wp(x;g_{2Q},g_{3Q}),\alpha_{2}=-1,\gamma_{2}=\frac{1}{6}(c_{1}-6z(t)),\delta_{2}=\frac{z_{t}(t)}{4\sqrt{z(t)}},\epsilon_{2}=\frac{z(t)}{2}(6z(t)-2c_{1})+2c_{2}
, and with

g_{2Q}=\frac{c_{1}^{2}}{12}-2c_{2},\quad g_{3Q}=-\frac{c_{1}^{3}}{216}-\frac{c_{1}c_{2}}{3}+\frac{c_{3}}{4}.

System
\{(7),(8)\}
is necessarily valid, if system
\{(3),(4)\}
((3.14) in
ChPW
) is assumed to be valid. Function
Q(x,t)
, according to (11), is the only possible solution of system
\{(7),(8)\}
, and hence of
\{(3),(4)\}
. Thus the validity of (3.14) in
ChPW
must be checked only with (11) substituted into Eqs.(8) and (7). Straightforward analytical evaluation shows that Eq.(8) is satisfied by (11). This does not hold for Eq.(7) with Eq.(11) substituted due to numerical evaluation (see Fig.1). Thus system (3.14) in
ChPW
is inconsistent.

We note, this result does not imply that solutions
z(t)
and
Q(x,t)
presented in
ChPW
are ”wrong” in a certain sense. As far as we can see, they are – consistent with (10) and (11) – correct solutions of the ”first-order quadratures” Eqs.(3.12) and (3.15), and hence are correct solutions only of the first equation, not of the second equation of (3.14). It would have been appropriate if the authors would have checked both equations with
z(t)
and
Q(x,t)
according to (3.23), (3.28) and (3.32), (3.38) in
ChPW
.

To conclude, we have presented arguments for the inconsistency (if
\delta_{t}(t)\neq 0,Q_{x}(x,t)\neq 0
) of system
\{(1),(2)\}
in
ChPW
. The claim in Section V ”This work opens up a number of new directions in the study of rogue waves modelled by the focusing NLS equation” is (at least) doubtful, though it has found more than 80 citations in the Web of Science.

Figure 1
:
P=Q_{t}(x,t)-\sqrt{z(t)}(c_{1}-6z(t))-2Q^{2}(x,t)
for
z_{0}=0

Q_{0}=\frac{1}{2},c_{1}=\frac{3}{4},c_{2}=-\frac{3}{128},c_{3}=\frac{1}{256},q=2
.

note:

The foregoing Comment has been submitted as a Comment on the PRE-version of
ChPW
(Phys.Rev.E 100, 052219 (2019)) to PRE and been rejected.

From our point of view, we have disproved the objections of the Referees in the review process. Unfortunately, it is not clear whether we have permissions to reproduce the details of the peer review process in the present Comment. What we can state is: None of the reviewers has refereed to our main claim that Eq.(7) is not satisfied by
z(t),Q(x,t,Q_{0})
according to (10), (11), respectively (connected to the doubts on the validity of (3.14) in
ChPW
).

Read the complete text