Extended thermodynamical topology of black hole
Shan-Ping Wu, Si-Jiang Yang, Shao-Wen Wei · 2025
Read Extended thermodynamical topology of black hole by Shan-Ping Wu, Si-Jiang Yang, Shao-Wen Wei (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-01614.txt.
Introduction
Shan-Ping Wu, Si-Jiang Yang, and Shao-Wen Wei unify three topology tools for black hole heat behavior in 2025. Thermodynamic topology sorts black hole phases, spinodal curves, and critical points by counting special points in a vector field. Three separate invariants had grown up side by side with little connection.
Their extended framework merges the three views and gives each a clear physical reading. Tests cover standard Einstein gravity holes and seven-dimensional Lovelock holes, where fresh phase effects appear. A match emerges between field zeros of each order and the classic critical exponents. The unified view offers a finer sort of phase change types.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Shan-Ping Wu, Si-Jiang Yang, Shao-Wen Wei |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 82 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-01614
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Extended thermodynamical topology of black hole Shan-Ping Wu, Si-Jiang Yang, Shao-Wen Wei Abstract Thermodynamical topology has emerged as a powerful framework for classifying the thermodynamical behavior of black holes. Three distinct yet complementary topological invariants have been employed to characterize black hole phases, spinodal curves, and critical points in black hole thermodynamics. In this work, we develop a unified framework that integrates these three topological approaches and introduce the concept of extended thermodynamical topology, providing a clear physical interpretation. As a first step, we apply this framework to black holes in Einstein gravity, systematically elucidating their phase structure in terms of topological invariants. We then extend our analysis to black holes in 7-dimensional Lovelock gravity, where novel thermodynamic phenomena naturally emerge from the topological perspective. Moreover, we explore the connection between critical exponents and the extended thermodynamical topology, uncovering a correspondence between the zeros of the k k -th order vector field and the associated critical exponents. Our study demonstrates that extended thermodynamical topology offers a robust and fine-grained framework for analyzing and classifying black hole phase transitions. pacs 04.70.Dy, 04.70.Bw, 05.70.Ce I Introduction Since the introduction of Bekenstein-Hawking entropy and Hawking radiation Bekenstein:1973entropy ; Hawking:1975Particle , black hole thermodynamics has been central to our understanding of black holes, offering profound insights into the pursuit of a quantum theory of gravity. Early studies, both via quantum field theory in curved spacetime Hawking:1975Particle ; Birrell:1982QFTCurvedSpace and through the on-shell gravitational path integral Hartle:1976Path ; Gibbons:1976ActionIntegral , established that black holes exhibit thermodynamic behavior. It was later discovered that black holes, similar to ordinary matter, admit a rich thermodynamic phase structure and can undergo phase transitions. In particular, Schwarzschild black holes in anti-de Sitter (AdS) spacetime exhibit two distinct phases (small black holes and large black holes), along with the Hawking-Page phase transition between the thermal AdS and large black hole phases Hawking:1982HP . Similarly, Reissner-Nordström AdS (RN-AdS) black holes display small, intermediate, and large black hole phases, with a coexistence curve and a critical point that closely resemble the liquid-gas phase transition in van der Waals fluid Chamblin:1999ChargeAdS ; Chamblin:1999ChargeAdS2 ; Kubiznak:2012PV . Moreover, the fact that black hole entropy scales with the horizon area reveals the presence of novel microscopic degrees of freedom intrinsic to gravitational systems, imposing stringent constraints on any consistent theory of quantum gravity, which must recover the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy in the semi-classical limit Strominger:1996Microscopic ; Rovelli:1996Loop . The universality of this area law has also played a central role in the development of gauge/gravity duality tHooft:1973 ; tHooft:1993 ; Susskind:1994 ; Maldacena:1997LargeN ; Witten:1998AdSholo , and the Hawking-Page transition corresponds to the confinement/deconfinement transition of quark-antiquark pairs in the dual gauge theory Witten:1998Confine . Recently, inspired by the holographic principle, black hole thermodynamics has been reformulated within a holographic context, including the first laws and their relation to conformal field theories, leading to renewed interest and active investigation Kubiznak:2016 ; Visser:2021 ; Cong:2021 ; Ahmed:2023 ; Yang:2024krx . With the development of various gravitational theories, a wide range of black hole solutions beyond the Kerr-Newman (KN) family has been discovered, and their thermodynamic properties have been extensively studied. Notable examples include black holes in Lovelock gravity Boulware:1985String ; Wheeler:1985LoveLock ; Cai:2003LoveLock and quasi-topological gravity Myers:2010BH ; Oliva:2010cubic ; Hennigar:2017 ; Bueno:2019QTG1 ; Bueno:2019QTG2 ; Bueno:2022QTG , among others. Given that many of these black hole solutions display qualitatively similar thermodynamic behavior, it is both natural and necessary to develop a systematic framework for classifying black hole thermodynamics. To this end, the concept of thermodynamical topology was introduced Wei:2022Top1 . Within this framework, at a fixed ensemble temperature, each black hole solution is treated as a topological defect in the space of thermodynamic parameters. The sign of its associated winding number encodes information on thermodynamic stability: a positive winding number indicates a locally stable branch, while a negative winding number signals local instability. The sum of all winding numbers defines a thermodynamical topological number, an invariant that classifies black hole thermodynamics into three categories, with numbers of +1 , 0 , and -1 . For instance, Schwarzschild black holes carry a topological number of -1 , RN black holes have 0 , and RN-AdS black holes exhibit +1 . This classification scheme has been successfully applied to a broad class of black hole solutions, including rotating and rotating AdS black holes Wu:2022rotating ; Wu:2023rotatingAdS . Further developments have refined thermodynamical topology into four distinct classes by incorporating the stability of the innermost small black hole branch Wei:2024UniverTop . When the total topological number is zero, the innermost state may be either stable or unstable, denoted as W^{0+} or W^{0-} , respectively. For nonzero topological numbers of 1 or -1 , the innermost branch is necessarily stable or unstable, and is denoted by W^{1+} or W^{1-} , respectively. This refined classification enables a more detailed analysis of both high- and low-temperature regimes and discriminates between solutions with the same zero topological number, such as Schwarzschild AdS and RN black holes, which still exhibit qualitatively different thermodynamic behaviors. Nonetheless, this scheme does not encompass all black hole solutions. In particular, some systems undergo topological number transitions, triggered by changes in the boundary behavior of the parameter space. Examples include multiply charged black holes in gauged supergravity Duff:1999SuperGravity ; Behrndt:1998SuperGravity ; Wu:2024Rcharge and four-dimensional dyonic AdS black holes in quasi-topological electrodynamics Liu:2019QuasiTopologicalEM ; Chen:2024dyonic . To account for these cases, a novel class W^{0-\leftrightarrow 1+} has been introduced, along with two additional sub-classes, \bar{W}^{1+} and \hat{W}^{1+} Wu:2024NovelTop . These refinements further broaden and deepen the thermodynamical topology framework, offering a more complete classification of black hole thermodynamics. The preceding discussion outlined the thermodynamical topology used to characterize black hole phases. In black hole thermodynamics, critical points play a central role in the phase diagram, marking the termination of coexistence curves and encoding the character of phase transitions. To capture these features, a topological description of critical points has been introduced Wei:2021Top2 . In this framework, each critical point is assigned a winding number, leading to two distinct classes: conventional and novel ones. For instance, RN-AdS black holes exhibit only conventional critical points, while Born-Infeld black holes possess both conventional and novel types. In addition to the classification of critical points, topological techniques have also been employed to study the Davies-type phase transition Bhattacharya:2024TopDavies , which is characterized by the divergence in the heat capacity and corresponds to the spinodal curve in the temperature-entropy ( T_{H}-S ) plane Davies:1977 ; Davies:1989 ; Lousto:1993 ; Lousto:1994jd ; Muniain:1995ih . The three topological numbers introduced above respectively characterize black hole phases, Davies-type transition points, and critical points, capturing complementary aspects of black hole thermodynamics. Although both Schwarzschild AdS and RN-AdS black holes share the same topological number (the first topological number) of +1 , only the RN-AdS black hole exhibits a phase transition from a small black hole to a large black hole. This distinction is reflected in their respective topological numbers associated with critical points. These results suggest that a complete thermodynamic classification should incorporate all three topological numbers and may require the inclusion of additional invariants. To address this issue, we construct a unified formalism that integrates the three established topological