On indecomposable involutive solutions to the Yang-Baxter equation whose squaring map is a p p -cycle

Marco Castelli, Arpan Kanrar · 2025

Read On indecomposable involutive solutions to the Yang-Baxter equation whose squaring map is a p p -cycle by Marco Castelli, Arpan Kanrar (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-01613.txt.

Introduction

Marco Castelli and Arpan Kanrar answer two open questions about solutions to the Yang-Baxter equation by studying one map attached to each solution. The equation sits behind knot theory and quantum groups, and its set-sized solutions carry a squaring map whose cycle structure shapes what can be built. Two researchers had asked whether unsplittable solutions exist whose squaring map is a swap, or a three-cycle. Their 2025 paper widens the question to cycles of any prime length.

Under two common conditions, a permutation group that is nilpotent, or a solution whose size is a prime power, the answer is no: such solutions must split apart. The paper also gives splitting criteria in this setting. Latin solutions, the most rigid kind, behave even more stiffly. The authors frame the result as a map of where indecomposable examples can and cannot hide.

Catalog record

CREATORMarco Castelli, Arpan Kanrar
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE36 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-01613

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On indecomposable involutive solutions to the Yang-Baxter equation whose squaring map is a p p -cycle Marco Castelli, Arpan Kanrar Abstract . The pioneering work of Rump, which proved Gateva-Ivanova’s conjecture concerning the decomposability of square-free solutions to the Yang-Baxter equation, significantly motivated further research into the associated squaring map T T . This line of inquiry has yielded numerous decomposability theorems based on the underlying structure of T T . Two seminal questions, posed by Ramírez and Vendramin, ask about the existence of certain indecomposable involutive solutions whose squaring maps are transpositions or 3 3 -cycles. In this paper, we explore this problem in a more general setting by examining the case where T T is a p p -cycle, for an arbitrary prime number p p . Our results provide negative answers to the aforementioned questions under the assumption that the solution is latin or that its size is a prime-power. As a further application, we also present some decomposability theorems for solutions whose permutation groups are nilpotent. 2010 Mathematics Subject Classification 16T25, 81R50 Introduction The quantum Yang–Baxter equation first emerged in theoretical physics, in a paper by C.N. Yang [ 31 ] , and in statistical mechanics, in the work of R.J. Baxter [ 2 ] . Later, it was also investigated from a mathematical perspective. In 1992, Drinfel’d [ 16 ] proposed the study of set-theoretical solutions, namely, solutions that act on a basis of the underlying vector space. Specifically, a set-theoretic solution of the Yang-Baxter equation on a non-empty set X is a pair \left(X,r\right) , where r:X\times X\to X\times X is a map such that the relation (r\times id_{X})(id_{X}\times r)(r\times id_{X})=(id_{X}\times r)(r\times id_{X})(id_{X}\times r) is satisfied. Set-theoretic solutions yield solutions to the Yang–Baxter equation via linearization. Writing a solution (X,r) as r\left(x,y\right)=\left(\lambda_{x}\left(y\right)\rho_{y}\left(x\right)\right) , with \lambda_{x},\rho_{x} maps from X into itself, for every x\in X , we say that (X,r) is non-degenerate if \lambda_{x},\rho_{x}\in Sym_{X} , for every x\in X , and involutive if r^{2}=id_{X\times X} . The seminal papers by Gateva-Ivanova and Van Den Bergh [ 19 ] and Etingov, Schedler, and Soloviev [ 17 ] inspired many researchers to study involutive, non-degenerate set-theoretic solutions (which we simply refer to as involutive solutions ). To understand and analyze an involutive solution, a successful approach is based on the notion of decomposable solution. Recall that an involutive solution (X,r) is said to be decomposable if X can be expressed as a disjoint union of two non-empty subsets Y_{1} and Y_{2} (that form a decomposition \{Y_{1},Y_{2}\} of X ) such that r(Y_{i}\times Y_{i})\subseteq Y_{i}\times Y_{i} for all i\in\{1,2\} , and (X,r) is called indecomposable , otherwise. In some sense, indecomposable solutions are the fundamental building blocks of this theory (see [ 17 , Section 3 ] ). Indecomposability of solutions has been extensively studied in the last few years, and several results have been obtained by various techniques. According to [ 17 , Proposition 2.12] an involutive solution is indecomposable if and only if the associated permutation group , i.e. the subgroup of Sym(X) generated by the maps \lambda_{x} , acts transitively on X . This fact is of crucial importance for several papers, in which indecomposable solutions whose associated permutation group belongs to a specific class have been extensively studied (see for example [ 11 , 20 , 21 , 23 ] ). In [ 7 , Theorem 7] , the indecomposability of solutions obtained by dynamical extensions was completely characterized, while in [ 6 ] and in [ 22 ] some sufficient conditions, involving the permutation group \mathcal{G}(X) , that guarantee the decomposability of an involutive solution were exhibited. Several mathematicians have focused on the so-called squaring map T , which is the permutation of Sym(X) given by T(x):=\lambda_{x}^{-1}(x) , for all x\in X . The success of this approach is due to the fact that this single permutation contains information about the decomposability of a solution. In this direction, the first paper was authored by Rump [ 26 ] , who showed that if the squaring map is the identity map, then the solution must be decomposable. In 2021, Ramírez and Vendramin provided several (in)decomposability theorems based on the cycle structure of T [ 25 ] . In particular, they showed the following results: 1) if T is an n -cycle, where n=|X| , then (X,r) is indecomposable; 2) if T is an (n-1) -cycle, where n=|X| , then (X,r) is decomposable; 3) if T is an (n-2) -cycle, where n=|X| and is odd, then (X,r) is decomposable; 4) if T is an (n-3) -cycle, where n=|X| and is coprime with 3 , then (X,r) is decomposable. A striking result, due to C. Mora and Sastriques [ 5 ] , provides an extension of the previous decomposability criteria and of Rump’s result. Indeed, in [ 5 , Theorem A] it was shown that if the size of X and the order of the map T are coprime, then the solution must be decomposable. Further generalizations to non-involutive solutions are contained in [ 13 ] . However, the map T does not seem to be merely a tool for identifying the decomposability of a solution. In this regard, in a recent paper [ 14 ] Dietzel proved that involutive solutions of order p^{k} whose squaring maps are full cycles (and therefore these solutions are indecomposable) belong to the class of involutive solutions of finite multipermutation level if p>2 , and he showed that involutive solutions of order 2^{k} that are not of finite multipermutation level have an iterated-retraction of size 4 . Despite these interesting results, the relation between the structure of an indecomposable solution and its squaring map remains poorly understood. To partially fill this gap, in [ 25 ] Ramírez and Vendramin computed indecomposable solutions of size \leq 10 and the cycle decompositions of their squaring maps. As noted in [ 25 , Section 3 ] , among small involutive solutions, there is only one indecomposable solution with a 3 -cycle as squaring map and two indecomposable solutions with a transposition as squaring map. Motivated by these pieces evidence, they asked if there are further indecomposable involutive solutions of this type (see Questions 3.18 and 3.19 of [ 25 ] ). Moreover, they pointed out that, among the solutions of small order, the squaring maps of the indecomposable ones have “few” fixed points (see Question 3.17 of [ 25 ] and the comment below). Motivated by this background, in this paper we explore the class of indecomposable solutions whose squaring map is a p -cycle, where p is an arbitrary prime number. Our strategy can be summarized as follows. First, we develop a theory of indecomposable solutions with a nilpotent permutation group, and then we use the combinatorial structure of these solutions to provide our classification results. As a consequence, our main theorems provide a negative answer to Questions 3.18 and 3.19 of [ 25 ] when we restrict to solutions with prime-power order or to latin ones. As a further application, we provide some decomposability theorems that allow us to detect decomposable solutions that are different from the ones considered in [ 5 , 6 , 22 ] . 1. Basics

Read the complete text