Unlocking Excellence: The Impact of Voucher Incentives on Cybersecurity Education
Jianhua Li, Shang Gao, Michelle Harvey, and Trina Myers · 2025
Read Unlocking Excellence: The Impact of Voucher Incentives on Cybersecurity Education by Jianhua Li, Shang Gao, Michelle Harvey, and Trina Myers (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-01520.txt.
Introduction
Jianhua Li and co-authors studied in 2025 whether voucher incentives can lift results in cybersecurity education. Vouchers are common in schools but rare at university level. In the course studied, grading was fully portfolio-based and students chose their target grade. One top-grade task was earning an industry certificate. Students who finished a set of tasks by mid-course received vouchers covering training materials and the exam fee.
Passing the certificate exam then counted toward the highest grade band. Surveys and interviews showed the incentives strongly shaped career aspirations. Students treated the certificate as a real asset for employment, not just a grade hurdle. The authors draw lessons for institutions weighing similar schemes. They recommend vouchers as a bridge between classroom work and industry credentials, in computing education and beyond.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jianhua Li, Shang Gao, Michelle Harvey, and Trina Myers |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 43 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-01520
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Unlocking Excellence: The Impact of Voucher Incentives on Cybersecurity Education Jianhua Li, Shang Gao, Michelle Harvey, and Trina Myers Abstract While voucher incentives have been popular for primary and secondary schools, they are less used in higher education. In this study, we leverage industry voucher incentives to inspire students in cybersecurity education (CSE). We adopt a 100% portfolio-based assessment strategy, where students can freely select their target grades in the investigated unit. We purposely design one of the high distinction (HD) tasks to be obtaining an industry certificate and provide vouchers to those who can accomplish a predefined set of tasks before a midpoint. The voucher recipients will use the voucher to access the industry certificate training materials and sit the certificate exam for free. Passing the certificate exam is one of the conditions for gaining an HD grade. Our survey and interviews reveal a substantial influence of voucher incentives on students’ career aspirations. In light of the findings, recommendations on adopting voucher incentives in CSE or broader ICT education are offered for institutions and researchers. 1 Introduction In the ever-evolving landscape, the demand for cybersecurity professionals has surged to unprecedented heights. According to the Australian Cyber Security Growth Network, there will be at least 17,000 additional cybersecurity workers needed by 2026. 1 1 1 https://www.austcyber.com/resources/sector-competitiveness-plan-2019/chapter3 As cyber threats continue to grow in complexity and frequency li2021too , educational institutions face the crucial task of preparing a new generation of cybersecurity experts capable of defending against an array of digital adversaries. To meet this demand and equip students with the skills and knowledge necessary to safeguard digital environments, educational programs in cybersecurity have become increasingly vital aldaajeh2022role ; newhouse2017national . Rooted in computer science, students may perceive cybersecurity as a complex and technical subject that requires advanced knowledge of computer systems and programming languages. The perceived difficulty of the subject matter can deter students from pursuing cybersecurity programs ajzen1986prediction . If the enrolled students cannot relate curricula to career or academic goals, they may not dedicate themselves to their studies. Under these circumstances, motivating students and facilitating appropriate learning environments are critical for fostering their interests and learning outcomes. Although numerous motivation strategies for learning have been developed and elaborated in general programs schiefele1991interest , motivating students to learn cybersecurity is less explored. In higher education, universities and colleges are exploring innovative strategies to motivate and engage students averill2020motivates ; li2023current . One such strategy is the integration of industry certifications as an integral component of academic curricula shim2021integration . These certifications, often administered by industry-recognized organizations, enable students to validate their skills and competencies in real-world scenarios paterson2022motivation . While integrating industry certifications into educational programs is not a novel concept fenton2019integrating , the methodological aspect of their impact on students’ goal achievement remains less examined. Industry voucher incentives refer to benefits provided to students in the form of vouchers. This incentive is designed to motivate students, recognize their achievements, and boost their career development. In this study, we employ industry voucher incentives as one of the motivation strategies in cybersecurity education (CSE) vsvabensky2020cybersecurity and evaluate the methodological aspect of their impact on students’ goal achievement. Our contributions are threefold. 1. Uncover the multifaceted influence of the industry voucher incentives on students’ academic aspirations, engagement, and overall performance within the context of portfolio-based assessments. Specifically, we seek to understand how the availability of voucher incentives influences students’ academic motivation and career aspirations in cybersecurity education. 2. Contribute to a deeper understanding of how such incentives can enhance students’ educational experiences and outcomes. Our research could provide valuable insights for educators and institutions seeking innovative approaches to motivate and engage students in CSE and broader ICT education. 3. Clarify the potential impact of voucher incentives on developing students’ essential skills and competencies demanded by the cybersecurity industry. Figure 1: Motivation methods The remainder of this paper is organised as follows: Section 2 presents the literature review on challenges in CSE and existing motivation methods, followed by an elaboration of our research questions and methodology in Section 3 . Section 4 outlines the findings of employing voucher incentives in CSE. Section 5 offers a comprehensive discussion of the results, our recommendations, and limitations. Finally, Section 6 concludes this paper. 2 Literature Review 2.1 Challenges in CSE The growing importance of CSE in the digital age has been widely recognized in our work and daily life rahman2020importance ; aldaajeh2022role . Despite the high demand for cybersecurity professionals, CSE faces challenges in motivation. Rooted in computer science, students may consider cybersecurity as a complicated and technical subject requiring advanced mathematical and programming skills. Fear of not being able to master cybersecurity skills can prevent students from choosing this program giel2020fear . On the other hand, some students may perceive a degree program as offering limited industry connections and outdated curricula raj2019cybersecurity . Such negative perceptions can hinder students from completing their programs giannakos2017understanding . 2.2 Motivation methods It is of paramount importance to motivate students to learn especially to those who show little interest schutte2015discover . Previous studies have investigated a myriad of ways to motivate students to learn science and technology. For instance, Palmer comprehensively explored motivational strategies including success, novelty, choice, relevance, variety, collaboration, teacher enthusiasm, and encouragement palmer2007best . The author discussed how to implement the above strategies in classrooms to seek the best way of motivating students in science. The conclusion is that all should be used as often as possible regularly. Butler leveraged the gamification technique to engage and motivate students in computer science, where 85% of the students believed that they were strongly engaged butler2016gamification . It was observed that converting complicated concepts into games could increase motivation. In CSE, professors usually incorporate hands-on activities, labs, and simulations to enable students to apply theoretical concepts in practical settings. Vykopal et al. argued that scalable hands-on training could improve learning experience motivation vykopal2021scalable . OConnor et al. designed a cybersecurity course for undergraduates in which students enjoyed attacking themselves oconnor2021teaching . Theory and hands-on balanced courses motivate students with an authentic experience, while challenges are noticeable. Challenge-based activities may require students to have a large amount of knowledge and skills, which can be impractical for average students. Other significant challenges include maintaining standardised classroom lab settings and technical failures during rehearsals. Table 1: Role of voucher incentives in education Aspect General Voucher Industry Voucher Focus Broad range of educational programs and services Specific to industry-related certifications and training Purpose Support diverse educational needs and goals Enhance employability and skills in targeted industries Eligibility Available to students across various disciplines Targeted towards students pursuing careers in specific industries Coverage May include a variety of educational expenses Typically covers costs related to certification exams, training, and materials Certifications Offered Varied, may include academic, vocational, etc. Industry-recognized certifications in specific fields (e.g., IT, healthcare) Industry Alignment Not necessarily aligned with specific industries Aligned with industry standards and requirements Cost Reduction Helps reduce financial barriers to education Reduces the financial burden of obtaining industry certifications Employability Enhancement Enhances general employability across sectors Increases job prospects and advancement opportunities in targeted industries Skill Enhancement Provides general knowledge and skills development Offers specialized training