Electrostatic Depletion Force in Complex Coacervates

Zongpei Wu, Shensheng Chen · 2025

Read Electrostatic Depletion Force in Complex Coacervates by Zongpei Wu, Shensheng Chen (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-01328.txt.

Introduction

Zongpei Wu and Shensheng Chen uncover a force that makes guest molecules clump inside droplets of charged polymers, in a 2025 paper. These droplets, called complex coacervates, form when oppositely charged chains separate from water, and they host chemistry for drug delivery and artificial cells. Guests inside them bunch together even when nothing seems to attract them.

Simulations pin the pull on the electric structure of the host network itself, an effect the authors name electrostatic depletion. Neutral chains, weakly charged chains, and floppy proteins all felt the attraction, unlike in plain solution. Unlike the classic crowding effect, this one works when guest and host are similar sizes. The finding reshapes how such droplets should be designed.

Catalog record

CREATORZongpei Wu, Shensheng Chen
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE27 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-01328

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Electrostatic Depletion Force in Complex Coacervates Zongpei Wu, Shensheng Chen Abstract The functionalities and applications of complex coacervates — liquid condensates resulting from liquid-liquid phase separation of charged polymers — are significantly influenced by the dispersion and aggregation states of guest macromolecules. Intriguingly, guest macromolecules exhibit a strong tendency to aggregate within coacervates even in the absence of apparent chemical incompatibility, indicating a universal aggregation mechanism at play in these environments. Using extensive MD simulations, we identify electrostatic depletion — a strong force arising from electrostatic correlations within the host polyelectrolyte network that drives guest aggregations. Due to electrostatic depletion, neutral polymers, low-charge-density polyelectrolytes, and intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) exhibit effective attractions in coacervates, in stark contrast to their behavior in dilute solutions. Unlike traditional depletion effect that requires mismatched length scale and morphology, electrostatic depletion is relevant in fluid systems where solute and solvent are both polymers with comparable size. Our discovery bridges a critical knowledge gap in the molecular physics of densely charged, crowded liquids and holds significant implications for the design of synthetic protocells and advanced drug delivery systems. INTRODUCTION Life relies on the intricate functions of biomacromolecules operating within the crowded environments of living cells. Complex coacervates — macromolecular condensates resulting from electrostatic associations of oppositely charged polymers such as proteins and RNAs — are increasingly recognized as crucial mediums for intracellular activities 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 . These charge-rich, liquid-like coacervates create microenvironments that selectively partition biomacromolecules and biochemical reactions, thereby regulating cellular organization and biochemistry. Inspired by their unique ability to encapsulate functional polymers, proteins, and enzymes in aqueous environments, researchers are exploring coacervate-based systems for innovative applications in artificial cells 5 , 6 , 7 , biomedicine 8 , 9 , and functional nanoreactors 10 , 11 . Central to coacervates’ functionality, both in natural and synthetic contexts, is the aggregation/dispersion behavior of the encapsulated guest polymers, which governs intermolecular interactions, guest stability, and encapsulation efficiency. However, despite significant advances in characterizing coacervates themselves 12 , 13 , the fundamental principles underlying guest polymer behavior — particularly the mechanisms driving their aggregation and dispersion within the densely charged, crowded coacervate matrix — remain poorly understood. Coacervates are multi-component polymer solutions, where polymer mixing/demixing behavior is long-predicted by the famous Flory-Huggins theory 14 , 15 . The Flory-Huggins parameter \chi , arising from the differences in the short-range interactions among different species (chemical incompatibility), determines the degree of demixing. In the absence of any chemical incompatibility, ie., \chi=0 among all species, all polymer species are expected to be well-mixed with each other due to gained entropy upon mixing. This polymer physics paradigm has led to the predictions that for concentrated systems such as polymer blends 16 and coacervates 17 , relatively large \chi between species is needed to induce demixing/aggregation due to the heavy screening of interactions in dense systems. As such, for vanishingly small \chi , guest polymers are expected to disperse as random coils within the coacervate phase, since the coacervate is essentially a good/theta solvent for the guests from the classical polymer physics 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 . However, many experiments reveal a surprisingly different reality: Many guest polymers — including neutral polymers and charged polyelectrolytes/proteins — experience strong exclusion from the coacervates, even when sharing similar chemical compatibility with the host polymers 22 , 23 , 24 , 25 . The strong guest exclusion means, the guest polymers are effectively attractive to each other within the coacervates phase, and they will from aggregates within the coacervates if no supernatant phase is at present. To counteract the repulsion from the coacervates (effective guest-guest attraction in coacervates) for better encapsulation efficiency, additional charge residues are often required on guest macromolecules 8 , 26 . Such a strong tendency for guest aggregations seems to be unique in coacervate systems, since it is not observed in either neutral polymer solutions or in simple polyelectrolyte solutions 27 , 28 . Given that guest polymers often have comparable size with the coacervate polymers, the mechanism underlying this seemly universal guest aggregations is apparently different from the well-known hydrophobic effect 29 or the classical depletion effect 30 , 31 , as both require huge mismatches in length scales between solute and solvent. These observations suggest the existence of a previously unrecognized, strong driving force for guest aggregation within coacervates. In this study, using extensive molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, we identify a universal mechanism driving this paradoxical aggregation: electrostatic depletion, a strong force arising from electrostatic correlations within the host polyelectrolyte network. Our results demonstrate that, in the absence of chemical incompatibility ( \chi=0 across all species), neutral guest polymers spontaneously aggregate within coacervates when their chain length exceeds a few “electrostatic blobs”. Furthermore, the strong electrostatic depletion can drive aggregations of guest polyelectrolytes with low to intermediate charge densities, and fully-charged intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs), even when these guests energetically favor associations with host polymers. Our findings underscore the significance of electrostatic depletion as a powerful mechanism for controlling macromolecular aggregation and encapsulation in coacervates, with profound implications for the design of synthetic protocells and drug delivery systems. RESULTS Universal polymer aggregation within complex coacervates The complex coacervates in our simulations result from liquid-liquid phase separation of oppositely charged polyelectrolyte solutions (see Fig. S1 in Supplementary Materials), which represent generalized electrostatically-driven coacervate systems in both synthetic and biological contexts (Fig. 1A). We then introduce approximately 1\% guest polymers (w/w) to the coacervate matrix to monitor their behavior. To highlight the universality of the electrostatic depletion effect, we set the excluded volume interactions to be the same among all species (polycations, polyanions, water, counterions, and guest polymers), ensuring no chemical incompatibility ( \chi=0 ) between guest and host. Fig. 1 : Universal aggregation of neutral polymers, polyelectrolytes, and IDPs within the coacervate phase (without the coexisted supernatant), where \chi=0 across all species . A , The composition of a typical coacervate system (left: schematic; right: simulation snapshot). B , Aggregation/dispersion states of 1\% guest neutral polymer with chain length at N_{g}=10,50,100 . C , Guest polyelectrolytes of different charge densities ( f=5\%,33\%,50\% ) within the coacervate matrix. D , The behavior of fully-charged IDPs with different charge sequences ( \kappa=0.0009,0.014,1.0 ) in the coacervate matrix. Green, orange, and blue (transparent) beads in Figure A represent polycation monomers, polyanion monomers, and water beads, respectively. In Figure B-D, gray beads represent monomers of the background coacervate matrix; magenta, blue, and purple represent the neutral, negatively charged, and positively charged monomers of the guests, respectively. Water and counterions are not shown for clarity. The excluded volume interactions are the same across all species. Contrary to the classical prediction of mixed chains, we find guest polymers show universal aggregations within the coacervate matrix, particularly pronounced for neutral polymers. When guest chain length exceeds a critical value ( N_{g}\geq 30 ), all neutral chains will immediately aggregate into a globule within the coacervates (Fig. 1B), while only very short chains (e.g., N_{g}=10 ) remain dispersed (left panel in Fig. 1B). The aggregation trend of guest polymers seems to be independent of the chain length ( N_{h} ) of host polyions, as the guest polymers ( N_{g}=50 )

Read the complete text