Effective resource allocation to combat invasions of the spotted lanternfly ( Lycorma delicatula ) and similar pests
Daniel Strömbom, Julianna Hoitt, Jinrong Hu, Swati Pandey, Elizabeth Batchelar · 2025
Read Effective resource allocation to combat invasions of the spotted lanternfly ( Lycorma delicatula ) and similar pests by Daniel Strömbom, Julianna Hoitt, Jinrong Hu, Swati Pandey, Elizabeth Batchelar (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-01117.txt.
Introduction
Strömbom and co-authors worked out how to deploy pest controls in the best order against the spotted lanternfly, an invasive insect spreading fast with serious costs. Earlier modeling gave a formula for the share of a population that must be treated to force decline, but not how to arrange treatments over time. The team extended that model to settings where control effort can be applied stage by stage, against eggs, juveniles, or adults.
When a control's effect grows in proportion to effort, the best plan is to exhaust one stage-specific control before moving to the next, ordered by effectiveness. When returns diminish, they derive a rule for when to switch. Fixed-budget plans from numerical optimization also beat random deployment, which can fail badly. The authors note that no such strategy appears in the lanternfly literature yet, despite tight control budgets.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Daniel Strömbom, Julianna Hoitt, Jinrong Hu, Swati Pandey, Elizabeth Batchelar |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 31 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-01117
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Effective resource allocation to combat invasions of the spotted lanternfly ( Lycorma delicatula ) and similar pests Daniel Strömbom, Julianna Hoitt, Jinrong Hu, Swati Pandey, Elizabeth Batchelar Abstract The spotted lanternfly is rapidly establishing itself as a major insect pest with global implications. Despite significant management efforts, its spread continues in invaded regions, and refined management strategies are required. A recent study introduced a model that generalized the results of empirical control efficacy studies by incorporating population dynamics and incomplete delivery. In particular, a generalized population growth formula was derived, providing the minimum proportion of a population that must be treated with a given control to induce population decline. However, this model could not address the more relevant question of how best to deploy a given control to minimize population growth. Here, we extend this model and formula to address this question in a variety of settings. When the effect of control is proportional to effort, we show that exhaustive sequential deployment of stage‑specific controls, ordered by efficacy, is the optimal strategy. When control effects exhibit diminishing returns with effort, we derive a formula for when to switch controls, providing an effective strategy in situations where management resources may vary or be cut at any time. We also use numerical global optimization methods to obtain strategies when resources are fixed a priori. Both strategies outperform random deployment, which we show can result in disastrous outcomes. Our results demonstrate that adopting an effective strategy for deploying stage‑specific controls is essential for managing the spotted lanternfly. However, we found no papers or reports addressing this topic in the lanternfly literature, nor information on whether such strategies are used in practice. Given the limited resources available to combat the lanternfly, it is critical that they are used effectively. The approach introduced here, along with other optimization methods commonly employed in related fields, can contribute to this goal. Introduction The spotted lanternfly (Lycorma delicatula) is an invasive insect pest that has spread beyond its native range in recent years, establishing a presence in South Korea, Japan, and the United States [ 1 , 2 ] . Several modeling studies based on climate and other factors also suggest that the spotted lanternfly may emerge as a global invasive pest, with predicted regions of infestation on all continents except Antarctica [ 3 , 4 ] . In infested regions, it is causing damage to both economically important farmed plants and naturally occurring vegetation, making it a management priority both where it is established [ 5 ] and in preventing its establishment in new regions [ 6 ] . Unfortunately, in many of the recently invaded areas, it lacks effective natural enemies to help control the population [ 7 , 8 ] , making human intervention necessary [ 9 ] . In the U.S., quarantine zones have been established, and a variety of control measures have been implemented, including insecticides [ 10 , 11 ] , entomopathogens [ 12 ] , egg parasites [ 13 , 14 ] , traps [ 15 ] , egg scraping [ 16 ] , removal of its preferred host plant [ 5 ] , and even instructing the public to kill lanternflies on sight [ 17 ] . Despite these efforts, the lanternfly has continued to spread from Berks County, Pennsylvania, where it was first observed in 2014, to numerous counties across 18 states, and the spread shows no signs of slowing down [ 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 ] , suggesting that current management efforts are insufficient. Recently, a comparative modeling study of the efficacy of several proposed, and used, control measures when population dynamics and incomplete delivery are taken into account provided a plausible partial explanation for the observed lack of effect on the growth and spread of the US lanternfly population [ 22 ] . Previous empirical studies of control measure effectiveness suggested that several of the control measures may be effective in combating the lanternfly due to the significant mortality rates observed in the studies [ 12 , 16 , 23 ] . However, when population dynamics and the possibility of incomplete delivery of the control are introduced, the expected effectiveness of all controls was reduced. More specifically, they introduce the generalized population growth formula (Equation 4 in [ 22 ] ) \lambda^{x}(p)=[ps_{PO}^{x}+(1-p)s_{PO}][ps_{NP}^{x}+(1-p)s_{NP}][ps_{AN}^{x}+(1-p)s_{AN}][pF^{x}+(1-p)F], (1) where \displaystyle s_{PO} , \displaystyle s_{NP} , \displaystyle s_{AN} , and \displaystyle F are the natural survival and reproduction parameters and \displaystyle s^{x}_{PO} , \displaystyle s^{x}_{NP} , \displaystyle s^{x}_{AN} , and \displaystyle F^{x} the corresponding survival and reproduction parameters when a control \displaystyle x is applied, and \displaystyle p is the proportion of lanternfly treated. By parameterizing this formula using data from the literature, they found that when population dynamics and incomplete delivery are accounted for, even a perfect control that kills all treated SLF (e.g. some insecticides) requires at least 35% of all lanternfly in each stage to be treated to turn population growth into decline. For less-than-perfect controls (e.g. entomopathogens [ 12 ] and egg parasites [ 13 ] ), an even higher treated proportion is required for population decline, if possible at all (see Figure 2 in [ 22 ] ). However, while [ 22 ] established an estimate of the annual population growth rate, the expected effectiveness of a number of control measures and combinations of them, and an absolute lower bound on the proportion that needs to be treated in each stage (0.35) numerically, their work provides no information about how to deploy a set of controls effectively. For example, if a number of control measures with specified efficacies are available, how should they be deployed for maximal effect? Should the available resources be allocated equally across all life stages, should we concentrate the efforts on one life stage, or use some other resource allocation scheme? To address questions of this type, a more sophisticated approach is required. In particular, one that distinguishes the proportion treated in the different life-stages, rather than having a common proportion treated for all, given that the available controls have different stage-specific efficacies. For example, some controls only affect one stage, e.g. egg parasites [ 13 ] , mid-winter chipping [ 16 ] , insecticide Chlorpyrifos [ 11 , 10 ] , whereas others affect multiple stages but may have different efficacy depending on the exact stage, e.g. entomopathogen B. bassiana [ 12 ] and insecticide Bifenthrin [ 10 ] . Furthermore, in addition to differences in efficacy of a control once delivered to the insect, the process of delivering the control to the population may exhibit diminishing returns with effort [ 24 , 25 , 26 , 27 ] and possibly other non-linear relationships between stage-specific proportion treated/effort expended and reduction in population growth. We note that the framework introduced in [ 22 ] is based on the assumption that the effect of applying a control grows linearly with proportion treated/effort expended, i.e. effect is proportional to effort applied, and it will therefore have to be modified to accommodate any non-linear response such as diminishing returns. The development and use of optimization and effectivization tools to address questions of how to deploy or allocate resources are ubiquitous across science and