On the contact type conjecture for exact magnetic systems

Lina Deschamps, Levin Maier, Tom Stalljohann · 2025

Read On the contact type conjecture for exact magnetic systems by Lina Deschamps, Levin Maier, Tom Stalljohann (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-01113.txt.

Introduction

Deschamps, Maier, and Stalljohann wrote a 2025 paper settling a conjecture about magnetic motion on energy surfaces. The systems pair geodesic flow with a magnetic field. The question, dating to 1998, asks when energy surfaces fail to be of contact type. The authors build, on any closed space, a huge family of systems of strong geodesic type. Each carries a closed magnetic orbit, trivial in homology, on every energy level, with negative action below a named threshold. Critical values come out in closed form, proving the conjecture for this class.

Catalog record

CREATORLina Deschamps, Levin Maier, Tom Stalljohann
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE91 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-01113

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On the contact type conjecture for exact magnetic systems Lina Deschamps, Levin Maier, Tom Stalljohann Abstract . In this article, we answer—for a broad class of magnetic systems—a question posed by Contreras, Iturriaga, Paternain, and Paternain [ 21 ] in 1998, now known as the contact type conjecture . To this end, we explicitly construct, on any closed manifold , an infinite-dimensional space of exact magnetic systems, which we introduce here as magnetic systems of strong geodesic type . For each such system, there exists at least one null-homologous embedded periodic orbit on every energy level , with negative action for energies below the strict Mañé critical value . As a consequence, the corresponding energy surfaces are not of contact type below this threshold. Thus, for this class of systems, the contact type conjecture holds true. Moreover, for these systems, both the strict and the lowest Mañé critical values can be computed explicitly —and they coincide whenever the aforementioned periodic magnetic geodesic is contractible , without requiring any additional assumptions on the manifold. For this class of magnetic systems, several remarkable multiplicity results also hold, guaranteeing arbitrarily large numbers of embedded null-homologous periodic magnetic geodesics on every energy level . We illustrate the richness of this class of magnetic systems through the following examples. On any non-aspherical manifold , there exists a dense subset of the space of Riemannian metrics such that, for each such metric, one can construct an infinite-dimensional space of exact magnetic fields yielding magnetic systems of strong geodesic type . Similarly, on any closed contact manifold for which the strong Weinstein conjecture holds, one can construct an infinite-dimensional space of Riemannian metrics such that, for each such metric, the magnetic system induced by the fixed contact form is of strong geodesic type . 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification 37J45, 37J55, 53D25 1. Introduction Following V. Arnold’s pioneering work [ 9 ] in the 1960s, which placed the motion of a charged particle in a magnetic field into the context of modern dynamical systems, magnetic systems have received considerable attention over the past three decades, particularly with regard to the existence of periodic orbits. To name just a few contributions: [ 3 , 4 , 6 , 11 , 10 , 13 , 21 , 26 , 46 , 48 , 47 , 50 , 55 , 59 , 60 , 61 ] . The motion is described mathematically using the language of symplectic geometry [ 32 ] as follows. Let (M,g) be a closed, connected Riemannian manifold, and let \sigma\in\Omega^{2}(M) be a closed two-form, called the magnetic field . The triple (M,g,\sigma) is called a magnetic system . The magnetic geodesic flow \varPhi_{g,\sigma}^{t} is defined on the tangent bundle TM as the Hamiltonian flow determined by the kinetic energy E(x,v)=\frac{1}{2}g_{x}(v,v) and the twisted symplectic form (1.1) \omega_{\sigma}:=\mathrm{d}\lambda-\pi^{*}_{TM}\sigma, where \lambda is the metric pullback of the canonical Liouville 1-form from T^{*}M to TM via the metric g , and \pi_{TM}\colon TM\to M is the canonical projection. The projection of a flow line of the magnetic geodesic flow \varPhi_{g,\sigma}^{t} on TM onto M is called a magnetic geodesic . When \sigma=0 in ( 1.1 ), the magnetic geodesic flow coincides with the usual geodesic flow corresponding to the metric g . We note that, unlike standard geodesics, magnetic geodesics cannot, in general, be reparametrized to have unit speed; see Section 2 . Therefore, one of the main points of interest is to work out the similarities and differences between standard and magnetic geodesics. Furthermore, by its Hamiltonian nature, the level sets of the kinetic Hamiltonian are invariant under the magnetic geodesic flow \varPhi^{t}_{g,\sigma} . More precisely: For a general magnetic system, the zero section corresponds to the set of rest points of the flow. For all energy levels \kappa\in(0,\infty) , all of which are regular values of the kinetic Hamiltonian E , the corresponding hypersurfaces \Sigma_{\kappa}:=E^{-1}(\kappa), called the energy surfaces , are invariant under the magnetic geodesic flow. Thus, the dynamics of \varPhi^{t}_{g,\sigma} restrict to each energy surface \Sigma_{\kappa} . In particular, it is interesting to ask whether the energy surface \Sigma_{\kappa} is of contact type, which in case of the geodesic flow is always true. A hypersurface \Sigma_{\kappa} is said to be of contact type if there exists a one-form \eta on \Sigma_{\kappa} that is a primitive of \omega_{\sigma}|_{\Sigma_{\kappa}} , and such that \eta does not vanish on the line bundle \ker\left(\left.\omega_{\sigma}\right|_{\Sigma_{\kappa}}\right). \Sigma_{\kappa} is of restricted contact type if \eta extends to a one-form on TM . Hypersurfaces of contact type in symplectic manifolds have been widely studied over the last four decades, beginning with the work of Weinstein [ 64 ] and Rabinowitz [ 53 ] , due to their connection with the existence of closed orbits. We provide a brief overview in Section 1.4 . 1.1. The contact type conjecture and Mañé’s critical values This article focuses on determining the range of energy values for which the energy hypersurface \Sigma_{\kappa} is of contact type in the case of exact magnetic systems (i.e. \sigma=\mathrm{d}\alpha with \alpha\in\Omega^{1}(M) ). To achieve this, the so-called Mañé critical values [ 46 ] play a fundamental role. Among these, the two most significant are the strict Mañé critical value c_{0}(M,g,\mathrm{d}\alpha)\in\mathbb{R} and the lowest Mañé critical value c_{u}(M,g,\mathrm{d}\alpha)\in\mathbb{R} ; see ( 2.3 ) and ( 2.4 ) for definitions. These values serve as energy thresholds that indicate major dynamical and geometric transitions in the magnetic geodesic flow. If \alpha is not a closed one form, then the following chain of inequalities holds (see, for example, [ 2 ] ): (1.2) 0<c_{u}(M,g,\mathrm{d}\alpha)\leq c_{0}(M,g,\mathrm{d}\alpha). Before proceeding we note that the values c_{u} and c_{0} differ in general. This happens, only when the fundamental group of M is sufficiently non-abelian; see [ 27 ] . It is well known that for energy levels \kappa>c_{0}(M,g,\mathrm{d}\alpha) , the corresponding energy surfaces \Sigma_{\kappa} are of restricted contact type (see [ 21 , Cor. 2] ). This naturally raises the question of whether \Sigma_{\kappa} is also of contact type for energy levels below the strict Mañé critical value. According to [ 20 , Prop. B.1] , if M is not a torus, then \Sigma_{\kappa} is not of contact type for any \kappa\in[c_{u}(L),c_{0}(L)) . A long-standing open question—originally posed by G. Contreras, R. Iturriaga, G.P. Paternain, and M. Paternain in their landmark paper [ 21 ] , later revisited in [ 20 ] , and discussed further in the commentary following [ 2 , Thm. 4.1] —asks whether the hypersurface \Sigma_{\kappa} can be of contact type in the intermediate energy range 0<\kappa<c_{u}(L) : Conjecture I ( [ 20 ] , [ 21 ] ) . \Sigma_{\kappa} is not of contact type for 0<\kappa<c_{u}(L) . This has been completely resolved in the case where M is a surface [ 22 ] , and for certain higher-dimensional homogeneous examples [ 18 , Thm. 1.6] . Beyond these cases, as far as the authors know, the I remains entirely open for general exact magnetic systems in dimension at least three. In contrast, for symplectic magnetic fields on the two-sphere, there exist examples where \Sigma_{\kappa} is of contact type for all energy levels (see [ 12 ] ). We close this subsection by noting that,

Read the complete text