Construction and Tuning of CALPHAD Models Using Machine-Learned Interatomic Potentials and Experimental Data: A Case Study of the Pt–W System
Courtney Kunselman, Siya Zhu, Doğuhan Sarıtürk, Raymundo Arróyave · 2025
Read Construction and Tuning of CALPHAD Models Using Machine-Learned Interatomic Potentials and Experimental Data: A Case Study of the Pt–W System by Courtney Kunselman, Siya Zhu, Doğuhan Sarıtürk, Raymundo Arróyave (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-01028.txt.
Introduction
Courtney Kunselman, Siya Zhu, Doğuhan Sarıtürk, and Raymundo Arróyave present a software flow for building heat-and-phase models of metal mixes, in work from 2025. Their test case is a mix of platinum and tungsten. The flow joins machine-learned models of atom forces with a standard toolkit for alloy work.
The learned models yield energy accounts that rest on real physics and need only slight tuning. That tuning is done with a slope-based method matched to lab data, which makes the fit fast and stable. The result is a phase chart that matches what is known of the mix. The whole flow is shared in the open, so other teams can build models for other metal pairs the same way.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Courtney Kunselman, Siya Zhu, Doğuhan Sarıtürk, Raymundo Arróyave |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 18 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-01028
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Construction and Tuning of CALPHAD Models Using Machine-Learned Interatomic Potentials and Experimental Data: A Case Study of the Pt–W System Courtney Kunselman, Siya Zhu, Doğuhan Sarıtürk, Raymundo Arróyave Abstract This work introduces PhaseForgePlus – a computationally efficient, fully open-source workflow for physically-informed CALPHAD model generation and parameter fitting. Using the Pt-W system as an example, we show that the integration of Machine Learning Potentials into the Alloy Theoretic Automated Toolkit can produce physically grounded Gibbs energy descriptions requiring only slight adjustments to produce accurate phase diagrams. Employing the Jansson derivative method in the context of experimental observations, such adjustments can be efficiently and robustly determined through gradient-informed optimization procedures. 1 Introduction Alloy phase diagrams are foundational to understanding thermodynamic stability and guiding alloy design. The CALPHAD ( CALculation of PHAse Diagrams ) method remains the standard approach for constructing these diagrams by parameterizing the Gibbs free energy of each phase—typically through polynomial expansions in composition and temperature. Model parameters are calibrated against experimental measurements and/or high-fidelity computational data to achieve the desired level of accuracy. The study of phase diagrams through experiments is a traditional and reliable approach. However, experimental investigations are often costly and time-consuming, as only a limited subset of compositions and temperatures can be explored, and reaching thermodynamic equilibrium may require prolonged annealing. Existing thermodynamic databases, such as those developed by the Scientific Group Thermodata Europe (SGTE) or the Thermo-Calc High Entropy Alloy database (TCHEA)—are typically constructed based on experimental data and can be directly used for phase diagram calculations. However, these databases have important limitations: they may lack coverage of all relevant phases or element combinations, and many are commercial products developed through proprietary closed- source methodologies. This restricts transparency and makes the modeling process somewhat of a black box. Moreover, access to commercial CALPHAD tools and databases may be limited for some academic or industrial groups due to licensing and cost constraints. On the other hand, CALPHAD models can be constructed purely from theoretical computations, using ab initio methods or machine learning-based interatomic potentials (MLIPs), with the aid of software packages such as the Alloy Theoretic Automated Toolkit (ATAT) [ 1 , 2 ] . In our previous work [ 3 , 4 ] , we introduced PhaseForge [ 5 ] , a newly developed package that integrates MLIPs into the ATAT framework and enables the automated construction of CALPHAD-type thermodynamic models. Although such approaches rely on physically grounded estimates of energy and entropy, their accuracy may still be constrained by trade-offs in computational efficiency as well as modeling assumptions and approximations. To address these accuracy concerns, the parameters of the thermodynamic models generated from the ab initio approaches—such as those employed by PhaseForge —can be refined using experimental data collected from the literature. In recent work, we demonstrated that the recently formalized Jansson derivative method [ 6 ] enables gradient-based optimization of CALPHAD model parameters [ 7 ] within the openly available PyCalphad [ 8 ] and ESPEI [ 9 ] toolchain. Across four alloy systems studied, conjugate gradient optimization yielded computational efficiency improvements ranging from one to three orders of magnitude over ESPEI ’s default black-box optimizer, which uses ensemble Bayesian inference through Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC). In this work, we present a workflow for constructing CALPHAD models using theoretically derived thermodynamic data, followed by gradient-informed refinement using experimental data from the literature. As a case study, we apply this workflow to the Pt–W binary system. The initial model is generated using MLIP-based thermodynamic data within the ATAT and PhaseForge frameworks, and subsequently optimized using PyCalphad and ESPEI to improve agreement with reported experimental observations. 2 Methods 2.1 Computation with PhaseForge To construct the CALPHAD model, we utilize our newly developed package, PhaseForge , which integrates the MLIPs into the ATAT framework. Special Quasirandom Structures (SQS) [ 10 ] representing BCC and FCC phases, up to level 2, are adapted from the ATAT database. Structural relaxations and total-energy calculations of the SQS are performed using Grace [ 11 ] with the GRACE-2L-OMAT foundation model. Thermodynamic properties of unary end members, including energies and vibrational entropies, are obtained from the PhaseForge database, which is based on density functional theory (DFT) calculations conducted with VASP. For mechanically unstable phases—specifically FCC W and BCC Pt—inflection detection is applied, and the corresponding SGTE data are excluded from the CALPHAD assessment. Liquid-phase energies are calculated using a ternary-search method implemented in PhaseForge , with a temperature offset of 50\text{\,}\mathrm{K} . In the CALPHAD-model fitting, binary interactions up to level 2 are considered, along with short-range order corrections for solid phases. The resulting TDB file, generated with PhaseForge , is subsequently imported into PyCalphad for Gibbs free energy calculations and phase diagram construction. 2.2 Gradient-Based CALPHAD Model Parameter Optimization As detailed in [ 9 , 7 ] , ESPEI employs a Maximum Likelihood Estimation (MLE) approach for CALPHAD model parameter optimization. In MLE, each data point used for the fitting of the model is treated as an observed value drawn from the distribution of a random variable associated with the conditions of the experiment or calculation that produced it. The likelihood function L(\bm{\theta}) is defined as the probability of drawing the entire dataset given the vector of model parameters \bm{\theta} . The goal is then to determine the set of parameters which maximizes L(\bm{\theta}) , or equivalently, which makes the observed dataset most probable. To avoid floating point errors and facilitate easier differentiation, the log-likelihood l(\bm{\theta})=\ln{[L(\bm{\theta})]} is the objective to be maximized. Under the assumptions that 1) all of the n data points are independent and 2) the distributions of residuals for all data points can be modeled with a normal distribution with mean zero (because we want zero error to be most probable), the log-likelihood function takes the following form: l(\bm{\theta})=\sum_{i=1}^{n}\left[\ln{\left(\frac{w_{i}}{\sigma_{i}\sqrt{2\pi}}\right)}-\frac{1}{2}\left(\frac{w_{i}X_{i}}{\sigma_{i}}\right)^{2}\right], (1) where X_{i} is the residual of the data point i , \sigma_{i} is a data-specific standard deviation that captures the uncertainty of X_{i} , and w_{i} is a user-assigned weight factor that provides modelers with a knob to adjust the relative importance of each data point to the final solution. The gradient of Equation 1 with respect to model parameters can thus be written as \frac{\partial l(\bm{\theta})}{\partial\bm{\theta}}=-\sum_{i=1}^{n}\left[\frac{w_{i}^{2}X_{i}}{\sigma_{i}^{2}}\frac{\partial X_{i}}{\partial\bm{\theta}}\right], (2) where derivatives of the predicted portions of the model that require energy minimization of each X_{i} are calculated using the Jansson derivative method in which the model parameters are treated as external conditions of the corresponding equilibrium calculations. In this work, we use phase equilibria data extracted from the Pt-W phase diagram with number 101202 in the ASM Alloy Phase Diagram Database [ 12 ] (see Fig. 1 ) to build the log-likelihood function. The residuals for the phase equilibria data (referred to as zero phase fraction (ZPF) data in ESPEI ) follow the residual driving force construction presented in [ 7 , 6 , 13 ] : X^{zpf}_{i,\alpha}=\sum_{A}\bar{\mu}_{A}x^{\alpha}_{A}-G^{\alpha} (3) where X^{zpf}_{i,\alpha} is the residual driving force of phase \alpha for the data point i , \bar{\mu}_{A} is the chemical potential of component A corresponding to the target hyperplane, x^{\alpha}_{A} is the reported vertex composition of component A for phase \alpha , and G^{\alpha} is the minimum Gibbs energy of phase \alpha conditioned on the reported