Disks no more: the morphology of low-mass simulated galaxies in FIREbox 2022 Disks no more: the morphology of low-mass simulated galaxies in FIREbox – References
José A. Benavides, Laura V. Sales, Andrew Wetzel, Jorge Moreno, Robert Feldmann, Francisco J. Mercado, James S. Bullock, Philip F. Hopkins, Claude-André Faucher-Guigère, Jonathan Stern, Coral Wheeler, Dušan Kereš · 2025
Read Disks no more: the morphology of low-mass simulated galaxies in FIREbox 2022 Disks no more: the morphology of low-mass simulated galaxies in FIREbox – References by José A. Benavides, Laura V. Sales, Andrew Wetzel, Jorge Moreno, Robert Feldmann, Francisco J. Mercado, James S. Bullock, Philip F. Hopkins, Claude-André Faucher-Guigère, Jonathan Stern, Coral Wheeler, Dušan Kereš (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-00991.txt.
Introduction
José Benavides and co-authors find that simulated dwarf galaxies refuse to grow disks. Inside the FIREbox cosmological volume, hundreds of central galaxies show every shape from spinning disks to pressure-held spheroids. But shape tracks mass: Milky Way-sized systems are often disk-dominated, while below a billion solar masses stellar disks mostly vanish.
Between a billion and ten billion solar masses lies a transition where disks grow common. In the simulations, calm recent star formation and deeper gravitational wells mark the disk hosts. Real dwarfs complicate the story: observations show some small galaxies with orderly rotating gas disks the simulation misses. The authors hold up dwarf shape as a sharp benchmark the next generation of galaxy models must meet.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | José A. Benavides, Laura V. Sales, Andrew Wetzel, Jorge Moreno, Robert Feldmann, Francisco J. Mercado, James S. Bullock, Philip F. Hopkins, Claude-André Faucher-Guigère, Jonathan Stern, Coral Wheeler, Dušan Kereš |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 69 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-00991
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Disks no more: the morphology of low-mass simulated galaxies in FIREbox 2022 Disks no more: the morphology of low-mass simulated galaxies in FIREbox – References José A. Benavides, Laura V. Sales, Andrew Wetzel, Jorge Moreno, Robert Feldmann, Francisco J. Mercado, James S. Bullock, Philip F. Hopkins, Claude-André Faucher-Guigère, Jonathan Stern, Coral Wheeler, Dušan Kereš Abstract We study the morphology of hundreds of simulated central galaxies in the stellar mass range M ⋆ = 10 7.5 − 10 11 M_{\star}=10^{7.5}\rm-10^{11}~ M ⊙ \rm M_{\odot} from the FIREbox cosmological volume. We demonstrate that FIREbox is able to predict a wide variety of morphologies, spanning from disk-dominated objects to spheroidal galaxies supported by stellar velocity dispersion. However, the simulations predict a strong relation between morphology (degree of rotational support) and stellar mass: galaxies comparable to the Milky Way are often disk-dominated while the presence of stellar disks mostly vanishes for dwarfs with M ⋆ < 10 9 M_{\star}<10^{9}~ M ⊙ \rm M_{\odot} . This defines a “morphology transition” regime for galaxies with 10 9 < M ⋆ / M ⊙ < 10 10 10^{9}<M_{\star}/\rm{M_{\odot}}<10^{10} in which disks become increasingly common, but below which disks are rare. We show that burstiness in the star formation history and the deepening of the gravitational potential strongly correlate in our simulations with this transition regime, with disks forming in objects with lower levels of burstiness in the last ∼ 6 \sim 6 Gyr and halos with mass ∼ 10 11 M ⊙ \sim 10^{11}~\rm{M_{\odot}} and above. While observations support a transition towards thicker disks in the regime of dwarfs, our results are in partial disagreement with observations of at least some largely rotationally supported gas disks in dwarfs with M ⋆ < 10 9 M_{\star}<10^{9} M ⊙ \rm M_{\odot} . This study highlights dwarf morphology as a fundamental benchmark for testing future galaxy formation models. 1 Introduction Successful formation of disks in cosmological numerical simulations of galaxies required striking a balance between strong stellar feedback and suppressed star formation efficiencies, particularly to prevent overproduction of stars at high redshifts ( Agertz et al. 2011 ; Guedes et al. 2011 ; Marinacci et al. 2014 ) . Several studies have highlighted that besides a quiet accretion history, where most stars are born in-situ, additional fundamental factors to the development of disky structures include avoiding the formation of stars from low angular-momentum gas ( Brook et al. 2011 ; Übler et al. 2014 ) and coherence in the alignment of the angular momentum of the accreted gas ( Scannapieco et al. 2009 ; Sales et al. 2012 ; Garrison-Kimmel et al. 2018 ; Hafen et al. 2022 ) . Almost unanimously, numerical codes have achieved these attributes by generating (or implementing) winds that help remove some of the gas that would otherwise inevitably cool from the halos into the galaxies. As numerical treatments to model the physics of the interstellar medium grew more complex and better resolved, predictions suggest that, in low mass halos, star formation tends to be “bursty”, showing relatively large variations in the amount of stars formed in short periods of time ( Hopkins et al. 2014 ; Faucher-Giguère 2018 ; Bose et al. 2019 ) . This feature, while present in most simulations in the dwarfs regime, seems particularly prominent in those subgrid models that attempt to follow the multi-phase nature of the gas (e.g., cooling below a temperature T\leq 10^{4} K), as opposed to adopting an equation-of-state model to describe a hot/cold phase into a single fluid ( Springel & Hernquist 2003 , e.g., ) . Efficient coupling of the feedback energy resulting from such bursty star formation may trigger vigorous outflows and galactic fountains ( Suarez et al. 2016 ; Martizzi 2020 ; Orr et al. 2022 ; Barbani et al. 2023 ) , the formation of bubbles ( Dalla Vecchia & Schaye 2008 ; Keller et al. 2014 ; Kim et al. 2017 ; Li et al. 2024 ) and outflow/inflow cycles –or breathing mode– ( El-Badry et al. 2016 ) which overall are disruptive to the coherence of angular momentum in the gas. In the case of cosmological simulations of Milky Way-like (MW-like) galaxies, what ultimately enables the settling and formation of disks is the halo mass . As dark matter halos grow, star formation shifts to less episodic and more continuous along with a deepening of the gravitational potential that ultimately confines the gas from outflows and facilitates the accretion of gas with coherent angular momentum cooling from the hot circum-galactic medium ( Sales et al. 2012 ; Clauwens et al. 2018 ; Hopkins et al. 2023 ; Stern et al. 2024 , CGM, e.g., ) . In the regime of dwarf galaxies ( M_{\star}<10^{9}~\rm{M_{\odot}} ), levels of star-formation, temperature of the CGM gas and halo masses may substantially differ from that in MW-like galaxies. This poses an interesting question for modern baryonic treatments that successfully reproduce disk formation in MW-like galaxies: what is the predicted morphology for galaxies of lower mass? The FIRE project aims at capturing in detail the physics of galaxy formation in sub-kpc scales ( Hopkins et al. 2018b ) which has successfully formed disks in MW-like halos ( Garrison-Kimmel et al. 2018 ) along with a realistic population of satellite galaxies ( Wetzel et al. 2016 ; Garrison-Kimmel et al. 2019 ) . While the model was initially developed for zoom-in cosmological simulations, morphology as a function of mass is a question better suited for full-volume cosmological simulations, which allow for the necessary sampling of environmental effects, halo mass function and diversity of assembly histories. FIREbox, which samples a \sim 22 Mpc on-a-side cosmological volume using the FIRE baryonic treatment ( Feldmann et al. 2023 ) constitutes therefore a valuable tool to tackle galaxy structure in low mass galaxies in simulations that resolve the multi-phase nature of the interstellar gas. Using galaxies from the IllustrisTNG model, Tacchella et al. 2019 found that dwarfs formed with a numerical model that correctly predict disk fractions for MW-mass galaxies ends up with less disk-dominated structure than their MW-mass counterparts. Moreover, a comparison with data from the Galaxy And Mass Assembly (GAMA) survey ( Baldry et al. 2010 ; Kelvin et al. 2012 ; Lange et al. 2016 ) suggests that the trend closely follows the morphological distribution of real galaxies in the M_{\star}\sim 10^{9.5}\rm-10^{11.5}~M_{\odot} range if one assumes that dwarf irregulars in the GAMA survey are dispersion-dominated. Limitations in the resolution of the simulations prevented to further explore the regime of even less massive dwarfs. More recently, Celiz et al. 2025 identified a clear stellar mass - morphology relation where low mass dwarfs are increasingly more dispersion-dominated using the higher-resolution TNG50 run ( Zeng et al. 2024 , see also ) . In this paper, we use the FIREbox simulation to study the morphology of galaxies predicted as a function of mass for a volume-complete sample simulated with a detailed ISM model that follows the multi-phase nature of the gas. Previous studies have hinted at the possibility that the FIRE-2 model results in dwarf galaxies that are kinematically more dispersion-dominated than observed, for example, regarding the kinematics of HI gas ( El-Badry et al. 2018b ) .