Challenges to the Two-Infall Scenario by Large Stellar Age Catalogs Journal: The Astrophysical Journal VICE ( Johnson & Weinberg 2020 ) , Astropy ( Astropy Collaboration et al. 2013 ; Astropy Collaboration et al. 2018 ; Astropy Collaboration et al. 2022 ) , scikit-learn ( Pedregosa et al. 2011 ) , S

Liam O. Dubay, Jennifer A. Johnson, James W. Johnson, John D. Roberts · 2025

Read Challenges to the Two-Infall Scenario by Large Stellar Age Catalogs Journal: The Astrophysical Journal VICE ( Johnson & Weinberg 2020 ) , Astropy ( Astropy Collaboration et al. 2013 ; Astropy Collaboration et al. 2018 ; Astropy Collaboration et al. 2022 ) , scikit-learn ( Pedregosa et al. 2011 ) , S by Liam O. Dubay, Jennifer A. Johnson, James W. Johnson, John D. Roberts (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-00988.txt.

Introduction

Liam Dubay, Jennifer Johnson, James Johnson, and John Roberts put a favorite story of our galaxy's past to a hard test. The Milky Way's disk stars fall into two chemical families, and the two-infall story explains them by two great waves of gas falling in. New catalogs of stellar ages now let the team check that story against the disk's actual timeline.

Their chemical evolution models, fed with the two-wave history, missed several marks. The models demand a huge, long dilution of the disk's metals, yet real stars show strikingly steady metal levels across most of the disk's life. The models also place metal-rich local stars at very young or very old ages, while the data put them in between. Pre-loading the infalling gas with some metals softens the clash but does not end it, and mergers face the same limits.

Catalog record

CREATORLiam O. Dubay, Jennifer A. Johnson, James W. Johnson, John D. Roberts
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE93 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-00988

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Challenges to the Two-Infall Scenario by Large Stellar Age Catalogs Journal: The Astrophysical Journal VICE ( Johnson & Weinberg 2020 ) , Astropy ( Astropy Collaboration et al. 2013 ; Astropy Collaboration et al. 2018 ; Astropy Collaboration et al. 2022 ) , scikit-learn ( Pedregosa et al. 2011 ) , SciPy ( Virtanen et al. 2020 ) , Matplotlib ( Hunter 2007 ) , NumPy ( Harris et al. 2020 ) , pandas ( Reback et al. 2021 ; The pandas development team 2025 ) . Liam O. Dubay, Jennifer A. Johnson, James W. Johnson, John D. Roberts Abstract Stars in the Milky Way disk exhibit a clear separation into two chemically distinct populations based on their [ α \alpha /Fe] ratios. This α \alpha -bimodality is not a universal feature of simulated disk galaxies and may point to a unique evolutionary history. A popular explanation is the two-infall scenario, which postulates that two periods of substantial accretion rates dominate the assembly history of the Galaxy. Thanks to recent advances in stellar age measurements, we can now compare this model to more direct measurements of the Galaxy’s evolutionary timescales across the disk. We run multi-zone galactic chemical evolution models with a two-infall-driven star formation history and compare the results against abundance patterns from APOGEE DR17, supplemented with stellar ages estimated through multiple methods. Although the two-infall scenario offers a natural explanation for the α \alpha -bimodality, it struggles to explain several features of the age–abundance structure in the disk. First, our models generically predict a massive and long-lasting dilution event, but the data show that stellar metallicity is remarkably constant across much of the lifetime of the disk. This apparent age-independence places considerable restrictions upon the two-infall parameter space. Second, most local metal-rich stars in APOGEE have intermediate ages, yet our models predict these stars should either be very old or very young. Some of these issues can be mitigated, but not completely resolved, by pre-enriching the accreted gas to low metallicity. These restrictions also place limits on the role of merger events in shaping the chemical evolution of the thin disk. I Introduction G alactic chemical evolution (GCE) aims to explain the metal abundance patterns observed in the Milky Way (MW) by modeling the star formation history and evolution of the Galaxy. A long-standing paradigm of GCE is that the metallicity of the interstellar medium (ISM) increases over time due to supernova enrichment from successive generations of stars ( Tinsley 1979 ; Matteucci & Greggio 1986 , e.g.,) . In this view, one feature of the MW disk that is difficult to explain is the so-called “ \alpha -bimodality”: the presence of two populations of stars at similar metallicity but separated by their [ \alpha /Fe] ratio ( Bensby et al. 2014 , e.g.,) . The high- \alpha sequence consists of old stars ( Pinsonneault et al. 2025 , \gtrsim 9 Gyr; e.g.,) with super-Solar [ \alpha /Fe] and is associated with the kinematic thick disk ( Fuhrmann 1998 , e.g.,) , while the low- \alpha sequence is younger, has approximately Solar [ \alpha /Fe], and is associated with the kinematic thin disk. The \alpha -bimodality is present across the Galactic disk, but the relative strength of the high- and low- \alpha sequences varies by location ( Hayden et al. 2015 ) . An explanation for the MW \alpha -bimodality has yet to be broadly accepted in the GCE literature. An \alpha -bimodality is not a universal feature in simulated MW-mass galaxies ( Mackereth et al. 2018 ; Parul et al. 2025 , e.g.,) , and tentatively does not exist in M31 ( Nidever et al. 2024 ; but see also Kobayashi et al. 2023 ). Its presence and characteristics in our Galaxy could potentially have arisen due to a unique evolutionary history. GCE models that attempt to solve this problem generally fall into two camps. Some explain the \alpha -bimodality as a result of secular processes, such as the radial migration of stars and the inside-out growth of the disk ( Schönrich & Binney 2009 ; Kubryk et al. 2015 ; Sharma et al. 2021 ; Chen et al. 2023 ; Prantzos et al. 2023 , e.g.,) . Others argue for a bursty star formation history driven by multiple accretion events ( Chiappini et al. 1997 ; Mackereth et al. 2018 ; Spitoni et al. 2023 , e.g.,) . The two-infall scenario was first proposed by Chiappini et al. 1997 to explain the origin of the high- and low- \alpha disks. Though the model has since been refined, the basic premise remains the same: the rate of gas accretion onto the disk is described by two consecutive bursts that each decay with time. The relatively low infall rate between the two bursts causes star formation to slow down, allowing the gas abundance to evolve between the high- and low- \alpha sequences while producing few stars in between. The infall timescale for the low- \alpha disk can vary with radius to produce inside-out disk growth and a radial metallicity gradient ( Romano et al. 2000 ) . The initial model of Chiappini et al. 1997 successfully reproduced the available abundance data at the time, which were largely confined to the Solar neighborhood. Subsequent studies refined the two-infall scenario to reproduce abundance data across the disk ( Chiappini et al. 2001 ; Chiappini et al. 2003 , e.g.,) . Others have explored the SN Ia delay-time distribution ( Matteucci et al. 2009 ; Palicio et al. 2023 ) , galactic fountains ( Spitoni et al. 2009 ) , radial gas flows ( Spitoni & Matteucci 2011 ; Palla et al. 2020 ) , variations in the star formation efficiency ( Spitoni & Matteucci 2011 ; Palla et al. 2020 ) , radial stellar migration ( Spitoni et al. 2015 ; Palla et al. 2022 ) , azimuthal abundance variations ( Spitoni et al. 2019a ) , and pre-enriched gas infall ( Palla et al. 2020 ; Spitoni et al. 2024 ) . Spitoni et al. 2023 and Palla et al. 2024 proposed a third gas accretion event in the last \sim 3 Gyr to match the inferred star formation history from Gaia ( Ruiz-Lara et al. 2020 ) and to explain the recent abundance evolution (or lack thereof) in the Solar neighborhood. Most recently, Hegedűs et al. 2025 constrained the infall timescales using chemical abundances for \sim 400,000 stars from the 19th data release of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ( SDSS Collaboration et al. 2025 , SDSS;) . While previous studies have explored a large parameter space, most have assumed that the Galactic disk never ejected a substantial outflow. This decision is based on hydrodynamic simulations of Galactic fountains ejected by CC SNe, which predict that ejected material falls back onto the disk on relatively short timescales ( Spitoni et al. 2008 ; Spitoni et al. 2009 ) and close to their point of origin ( Melioli et al. 2008 ; Melioli et al. 2009 ) , suggesting that the effect on GCE should be minimal. However, the effects of feedback in simulations are sensitive to its implementation ( Li et al. 2020 ; Hu et al. 2023

Read the complete text