𝝍 ⁑ ( 𝟐 ​ 𝑺 ) \psi(2S) production in jets using NRQCD

Marston Copeland, Lin Dai, Yu Fu, Jyotirmoy Roy Β· 2025

Read 𝝍 ⁑ ( 𝟐 ​ 𝑺 ) \psi(2S) production in jets using NRQCD by Marston Copeland, Lin Dai, Yu Fu, Jyotirmoy Roy (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-00814.txt.

Introduction

Marston Copeland, Lin Dai, Yu Fu and Jyotirmoy Roy wrote a 2025 paper modeling how a certain excited particle, the psi(2S), appears inside jets at a collider. Fresh data from the LHCb experiment anchor the work. Two refined frameworks replace the default simulation pairing. Both describe the data far better, the team finds.

The two frameworks' forecasts are compared side by side. Jet patterns of this particle sharply separate rival values for key theory inputs. Three research groups' inputs give widely split predictions. The authors argue a more precise extraction of those inputs is needed. Such particles probe how quarks bind into matter.

Catalog record

CREATORMarston Copeland, Lin Dai, Yu Fu, Jyotirmoy Roy
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE42 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-00814

Browse the full library Β· About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

𝝍 ⁑ ( 𝟐 ​ 𝑺 ) \psi(2S) production in jets using NRQCD Marston Copeland, Lin Dai, Yu Fu, Jyotirmoy Roy Abstract Based on recent data from LHCb, we study ψ ⁑ ( 2 ​ S ) \psi(2S) production in jets using non-relativistic QCD (NRQCD) in conjunction with the Fragmenting Jet Function (FJF) and Gluon Fragmentation Improved Pythia (GFIP) formalisms. Similar to previous studies of J / ψ J/\psi production in jets, our results show that these formalisms offer a much better description of data than the default Pythia +NRQCD prediction. We compare and contrast between the predictions from the FJF formalism and the GFIP approach. In addition, our results show that the distribution of ψ ⁑ ( 2 ​ S ) \psi(2S) in jets is an excellent discriminator to test different predictions for the ψ ⁑ ( 2 ​ S ) \psi(2S) LDMEs from various extractions. We find a large disparity between the predictions from three different collaborations showing that a more precise extraction of the ψ ⁑ ( 2 ​ S ) \psi(2S) LDMEs may be necessary. 1 Introduction Quarkonia, bound states of heavy quarks, are rich systems that provide insight into both the perturbative and non-perturbative dynamics of QCD. This is facilitated by the fact that quarkonium dynamics encompass a wide range of disparate scales – the mass of the heavy quark/anti-quark, the relative momentum of the heavy quark–anti-quark pair, the binding energy of the pair, and the hadronization scale. This scale separation warrants the application of effective field theory methods. Non-relativistic QCD (NRQCD) is one such effective field theory that disentangles the dynamics at different scales using a systematic expansion in v , the relative velocity of the heavy quark–anti-quark pair (see ref. Hoang:2002ae ; Brambilla:2010cs for a review). NRQCD has been quite successful in describing quarkonium production for many processes, Fleming:1997fq ; Yuan:2000cn ; Beneke:1998re ; Chu:2024fpo ; Maxia:2024cjh ; Bodwin:2010fi ; Braaten:2002fi ; Hagiwara:2003cw ; Bodwin:2008nf ; Braaten:1994xb ; Braaten:1994vv ; Copeland:2023wbu ; Copeland:2023qed ; Blask:2025jua ; Echevarria:2024idp ; Echevarria:2023dme ; Yang:2024ejk . In particular, it has allowed one to calculate quarkonium production cross-sections by factorizing them into short distance partonic cross-sections that describe the production of the heavy quark–anti-quark pair at the hard scale, 2m_{Q} , and long distance matrix elements (LDME) for the pair to hadronize to the final state quarkonium. While the short distance cross-section is perturbatively calculable, the LDMEs are non-perturbative and must be extracted from experiments. Thus a major effort in understanding quarkonium production has been directed towards constraining the LDMEs. Most of the LDME extractions come from inclusive production of quarkonium Butenschoen:2011yh ; Ma:2010yw ; Brambilla:2022rjd ; Brambilla:2024iqg and thus a broader class of observables are wanted for better constraining of the LDMEs. In Baumgart:2014upa ; Bain:2016clc , it was realized that studying J/\psi production in jets offered a new avenue to constrain the LDMEs used for J/\psi production. This was achieved by combining the Fragmenting Jet function (FJF) Formalism, developed in ref. Procura:2009vm to study light hadron production in jets, with NRQCD to study J/\psi mesons produced within a jet. This work cumulated in a successful phenomenological description of in-jet J/\psi production data from the LHCb collaboration Bain:2017wvk and polarization studies of quarkonia Kang:2017yde ; Dai:2017cjq , showing that this approach has considerable merit. The vast majority of NRQCD applications to charmonium production have focused on the lowest lying state, the J/\psi meson. This is in large part due to its extremely clean decay signal to lepton pairs, which makes it appealing to measure experimentally. Many attempts have been made to constrain the long-distance matrix elements for the J/\psi Butenschoen:2011yh ; Butenschoen:2012qr ; Chao:2012iv ; Bodwin:2014gia . The first excited state of the J/\psi , the \psi(2S) meson, played a critical role in the development of NRQCD however, when the unexpected surplus of \psi(2S) mesons at the Tevatron lead to the understanding that fragmentation and so-called β€œcolor-octet" production mechanisms can contribute huge amounts to the overall production cross sections in NRQCD Braaten:1994vv ; Braaten:1994xb . Over time though, studies of the \psi(2S) meson have become less popular, and as a result, its long-distance matrix elements are poorly constrained. The \psi(2S) ’s most common decay is to a J/\psi and a \pi^{+}\pi^{-} pair, so recently several studies have recognized the importance of \psi(2S) decay contributions in constraining J/\psi production physics Bodwin:2015iua . Several authors have begun to study the \psi(2S) LDMEs with the same vigor as was applied to the J/\psi , Bodwin:2015iua ; Brambilla:2022ayc ; Butenschoen:2022qka , but further work is still necessary to constrain the LDMEs for the \psi(2S) . In the present work, we will study \psi(2S) production in jets based on the FJF framework and Gluon Fragmentation Improved Pythia (GFIP). This is motivated by the recent LHCb measurements of \psi(2S) meson production in jets LHCb:2024ybz . In their analysis, the \psi(2S) is reconstructed via its decay to the J/\psi(\rightarrow\mu^{+}\mu^{-})\pi^{+}\pi^{-} final state in the forward region, using proton-proton collision data collected by the LHCb experiment at a center-of-mass energy of 13 TeV in 2016. They measured the transverse momentum distribution of \psi(2S) inside jets, defined as the ratio of the transverse momentum of the \psi(2S) candidate to that of the full jet in differentially in both p_{T}(\mathrm{jet}) and p_{T}(\psi(2S)) bins. They also provided a comparison with theoretical predictions from a combined NRQCD and Pythia model, which showed that a naive combination of NRQCD with Pythia fails catastrophically. Similar issues were also faced in the case of J/\psi LHCb:2017llq . Monte Carlo ( Pythia ) was initially used to interpret the data for J/\psi distribution in jets at LHCb and was not able to explain the the data. In order to mend the insufficient part of Pythia , and motivated by FJF framework, GFIP was introduced in Ref. Bain:2016clc ; Bain:2017wvk that still used Pythia to do the parton shower part, but then the hadronization part was manually implemented. Theoretically, the FJF and GFIP approaches should be equivalent, since renormalization group (RG) evolution in FJF is equivalent to parton shower in GFIP. The structure of the paper is as follows. Sec. 2 as a whole reviews the various formalisms used in this work with Secs. 2.1 , 2.2 , 2.3 discussing NRQCD factorization, FJF and GFIP formalisms respectively. In Sec. 3 we show the results of FJF and GFIP for different LDMEs and compare it to LHCb data. Finally we summarize our work in Sec. 4 . 2 Formalism Review 2.1 NRQCD Factorization Formalism One of the major tools that allows for NRQCD to have predictive power in quarkonium production processes is the NRQCD factorization conjecture. This states that for the collision process of particles A and B , the production of a quarkonium particle, H and other final states, X , can be factorized as follows, {\rm{d}}\sigma_{A+B\to H+X}\ =\sum_{n}{\rm{d}}\sigma_{A+B\to Q\bar{Q}(n)+X}\braket{\mathcal{O}^{H}(n)}\,. (1) Here, d\sigma_{A+B\to Q\bar{Q}(n)+X} is a partonic cross section that describes the production of a Q\bar{Q} pair in the quantum number configuration denoted by n={}^{2S+1}L_{J}^{[c]} for definite spin S , orbital angular momentum L , total angular momentum J , and color state c , where c=1 for color-singlet and c=8 for color-octet. These partonic cross sections are perturbatively calculable at the scale 2m_{Q} in

Read the complete text