Tool-Assisted Conformance Checking to Reference Process Models
Bernhard Rumpe, Max Stachon, Sebastian Stüber, Valdes Voufo · 2025
Read Tool-Assisted Conformance Checking to Reference Process Models by Bernhard Rumpe, Max Stachon, Sebastian Stüber, Valdes Voufo (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-00738.txt.
Introduction
Bernhard Rumpe and co-authors tackle how to check if a real work plan matches a model plan that holds best practice. Their 2025 paper notes that most past checks look at logs of work as it ran. Those checks cannot judge the meaning of a plan itself. Shops are left to compare plans by hand, which is slow and prone to error.
The team adds a tool-based check that uses cause links between tasks and events in each plan. They place the check inside a wider frame for what match means, and test it on a case study. They close by weighing where the tool helps and where it still falls short.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Bernhard Rumpe, Max Stachon, Sebastian Stüber, Valdes Voufo |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 51 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-00738
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Tool-Assisted Conformance Checking to Reference Process Models Bernhard Rumpe, Max Stachon, Sebastian Stüber, Valdes Voufo Abstract Reference models convey best practices and standards. The reference frameworks necessitate conformance checks to ensure adherence to established guidelines and principles, which is crucial for maintaining quality and consistency in various processes. This paper explores automated conformance checks for concrete process models against reference models using causal dependency analysis of tasks and events. Existing notions of conformance checking for process models focus on verifying process execution traces and lack the expressiveness and automation needed for semantic model comparison, leaving this question unresolved. We integrate our approach into a broader semantic framework for defining reference model conformance. We outline an algorithm for reference process model conformance checking, evaluate it through a case study, and discuss its strengths and limitations. Our research provides a tool-assisted solution enhancing accuracy and flexibility in process model conformance verification. [orcid=0000-0002-2147-1966, [email protected], url=https://se-rwth.de, ] 1 [orcid=0000-0002-6328-3816, [email protected], ] 1 [orcid=0000-0002-6636-9375, [email protected], ] 1 [[email protected] ] 1 keywords Reference Models ,Process Models ,Semantic ,Conformance ,BPMN ,Model-Driven Engineering † † copyrightyear: 2022 † † copyright: Copyright for this paper by its authors. Use permitted under Creative Commons License Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0). † † venue: arxiv.com † † address: Software Engineering, RWTH Aachen University, Germany † † These authors contributed equally. 1 Introduction Process models play a pivotal role across various domains by providing structured representations of workflows and operations. They are instrumental in standardizing processes Ungan 2006 ; Allweyer 2016 , optimizing performance Kougka et al. 2018 , and ensuring compliance with industry standards Knuplesch et al. 2013 ; Lim et al. 2012 . As organizations increasingly rely on these models to guide their operational practices Fernandes et al. 2021 , the demand for robust mechanisms to verify the adherence of concrete implementations to reference models has become paramount. Reference models serve as authoritative benchmarks that encapsulate standardized processes and best practices ITU-T 1994 ; Gamma et al. 1997 . In the realm of process modeling, they provide a critical framework against which concrete process implementations can be rigorously evaluated. Despite their significance, there is a notable lack of formal conformance verification methods tailored to facilitate appropriate comparisons between specific process models and more general reference models. Current approaches to conformance checking in process modeling often fall short in addressing the nuanced causal dependencies inherent in both reference and concrete models. Instead, they predominantly focus on verifying execution logs Rozinat and van der Aalst 2006 ; Van der Aalst et al. 2012 ; Burattin et al. 2016 ; Dunzer et al. 2019 , thereby neglecting the essential aspect of model-to-model comparison. Conformance checks Konersmann et al. 2024 are essential for verifying that concrete process models align with their corresponding reference models, ensuring adherence to best practices and facilitating the timely identification of deviations. This alignment is vital for organizations seeking compliance with regulatory standards, optimizing operational efficiency, and maintaining quality assurance. However, conformance checking presents significant challenges due to the inherent complexity and variability of real-world processes. For instance, the dynamic nature of business operations can lead to frequent changes in process structures, complicating validation efforts. Existing methods of semantic model comparison often struggle with limited expressiveness and scalability, which can significantly hinder effective validation in diverse and complex environments Maoz et al. 2011a ; Maoz et al. 2011b ; Kautz and Rumpe 2018 ; Ringert et al. 2023 ; Rumpe et al. 2024 . This paper addresses these limitations by introducing an innovative algorithmic approach for tool-assisted conformance checking that leverages causal relations analysis to enhance the expressiveness and automation of the validation process. Our motivation arises from the pressing need for more accurate and reliable conformance checks, particularly in scenarios involving intricate process structures and dependencies. The objective of this study is to develop a novel method that systematically analyzes causal dependencies within reference process models and compares them against corresponding elements in concrete models. By doing so, we aim to provide a more flexible and comprehensive solution for conformance verification, thereby advancing the state of the art in process model validation. Contribution • Semantic concept for reference process models and conformance • Abstract description of a conformance checking algorithm • Publicly available Java implementation for conformance checking • Evaluation of tool on multiple examples and discussion of results Structure In Section 2 , we present a motivating example that is used to illustrate key concepts. Section 3 provides background information and discusses related work in the field. We then introduce an abstract description of our conformance checking algorithm in Section 4 and address its complexity, soundness, and completeness. Following this, Section 5 details the implementation aspects. The evaluation of our tool is presented in Section 6 . In Section 7 , we discuss precision and limitations of our approach, as well as potential threads to validity. Finally, we conclude with a summary of our findings and suggest directions for future work. 2 Motivating Example Figure 1: Reference process model for scientific writing. Figure 2: Concrete process model for writing a thesis; the fifth gateway is incorrect and leads to non-conformance. Consider the process model displayed in fig. 1 , it specifies a reference process for scientific writing. After starting the process, the first task is Research . After Research is completed, the next task is to write an initial Draft . Following that Introduction , Main , and Conclusion have to be completed. These three can be worked on in parallel. Next up is the task Review , after which the process either ends or the tasks Introduction , Main , and Conclusion are repeated. Based on this reference model, we want to develop a more refined version of the model for the concrete case of writing a scientific paper for a conference. This model is displayed in fig. 2 : The thesis starts with a Literature Review instead of Research , followed by writing an Exposé instead of a Draft . Afterwards, the tasks Implement and then Evaluation have to be completed. Both may have to be repeated. Following that Introduction , Main , Conclusion , as well as Related Work have to be written. After a Review of the work these tasks may have to be repeated, as well. Otherwise, the process ends. This is the intended specification of the process. However, on a closer look at the model displayed in fig. 2 one might discover a mistake made by the modeler: The fifth gateway is an XOR-merge instead of the intended AND-merge . As a consequence, the execution behavior of the model does not correspond to the reference model, i.e., its semantics was not properly preserved. A mistake such as this becomes harder to discover the larger the model grows, increasing chances that the model will be implemented and executed when the corresponding software system is deployed. The severity of the impact such a mistake has can vary, but if compliance to the reference model is legally required, it is best to avoid this situation in the first place. This mistake in particular does not cause a deadlock, and can therefore not be discovered by a deadlock-analysis of the model. It might potentially be