Why Do Decision Makers (Not) Use AI? A Cross-Domain Analysis of Factors Impacting AI Adoption
Rebecca Yu, Valerie Chen, Ameet Talwalkar, Hoda Heidari · 2025
Read Why Do Decision Makers (Not) Use AI? A Cross-Domain Analysis of Factors Impacting AI Adoption by Rebecca Yu, Valerie Chen, Ameet Talwalkar, Hoda Heidari (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-00723.txt.
Introduction
Rebecca Yu, Valerie Chen, Ameet Talwalkar, and Hoda Heidari ask why decision makers do or do not reach for AI tools, in a 2025 study. Adoption, in their sense, is the voluntary choice to consult a system at all. The team interviewed experts in medicine, law, journalism, and the public sector about how AI is used and viewed in their fields.
Four forces shaped adoption: the decision maker's own background, how the tool is perceived, what using it means for the user personally, and what it implies for others affected. The authors turn these into an adoption worksheet and test it on cross-domain cases. Their aim is advice for deploying AI that respects the user's seat.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Rebecca Yu, Valerie Chen, Ameet Talwalkar, Hoda Heidari |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 74 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-00723
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Why Do Decision Makers (Not) Use AI? A Cross-Domain Analysis of Factors Impacting AI Adoption Rebecca Yu, Valerie Chen, Ameet Talwalkar, Hoda Heidari Abstract . Growing excitement around deploying AI across various domains calls for a careful assessment of how human decision-makers interact with AI-powered systems. In particular, it is essential to understand when decision-makers voluntarily choose to consult AI tools, which we term decision-maker adoption . We interviewed experts across four domains—medicine, law, journalism, and the public sector—to explore current AI use cases and perceptions of adoption. From these interviews, we identify key factors that shape decision-maker adoption of AI tools: the decision-maker’s background, perceptions of the AI, consequences for the decision-maker, and perceived implications for other stakeholders. We translate these factors into an AI adoption sheet to analyze how decision-makers approach adoption choices through comparative, cross-domain case studies, highlighting how our factors help explain inter-domain differences in adoption. Our findings offer practical guidance for supporting the responsible and context-aware deployment of AI by better accounting for the decision-maker’s perspective. 1. Introduction Increased interest in deploying practical AI tools for decision-makers has spurred growing research into how human decision-makers interact with these tools, particularly regarding decision-maker reliance on AI ( Lee et al. 2020 ; Bansal et al. 2021 ; Chen et al. 2023 ) —that is, the rate at which a human decision-maker replaces their initial judgments with AI recommendations. Such studies typically involve controlled evaluations of AI prototypes in lab settings ( Cai et al. 2019 ; Silva et al. 2024 ) or pilot deployments of AI tools in real-world environments ( Jo et al. 2023 ; Kawakami et al. 2022 ) , where decision-makers are presented with an AI tool and researchers measure the extent to which they defer to AI guidance. However, AI reliance presupposes decision-maker adoption; in practice, decision-makers may opt not to use these tools at all ( e.g. , a doctor may not use a model without peer endorsement ( Henry et al. 2022 ) ). AI Adoption Sheet • Decision-maker background. – How does a decision-maker’s professional experience inform their adoption behaviors? – Does the decision-maker have any personal biases that may impact their adoption choices? • Perceptions of the AI model. – What flaws does the decision-maker perceive the model they are deciding to consult to have? – Do they have any doubts about model trustworthiness or capabilities? – What do they believe the capabilities of the model and the benefits of AI adoption are? • Consequences for the decision-maker. – What liabilities may the decision-maker face ( e.g., legal, professional, political)? – Are there uncertainties regarding consequences? – How does the decision-maker’s workload change? • Perceived implications for other stakeholders. – How do decision-makers believe organizations are impacted by AI adoption? – How do decision-makers believe decision-subjects are impacted by AI adoption? Figure 1 . We introduce an AI adoption sheet to highlight factors influencing decision-maker adoption. Figure 2 . Key definitions to distinguish between organizational adoption, decision-maker adoption, and decision-maker reliance. Adoption refers to an organization or decision-maker’s choice to procure or consult an AI tool. In contrast, decision-maker reliance is the rate at which decision-makers replace their initial decision with AI output, which presupposes adoption. As such, we emphasize the importance of studying decision-maker adoption of AI—the voluntary and consistent use of an AI tool within a decision-maker’s workflow. Prior work on AI adoption has primarily focused on the perspective of organizational adoption choices ( Sun and Medaglia 2019 ; Chatterjee et al. 2021 ; Wu et al. 2024 ; Neumann et al. 2024 ) , namely, why an organization may choose to adopt an AI product or service. For example, such work may involve surveys to investigate why a hospital might choose to procure and deploy an AI tool ( Poon et al. 2025 ) , potentially irrespective of whether it is used by clinicians down the line. We build on this line of research, but shift the focus to the perspective of decision-makers within organizations that have already made AI available to their members. While a few prior studies have taken a more decision-maker-centric approach in specific domains—primarily medicine ( Hameed et al. 2023 ; Fang et al. 2023 ; Başar and Erkul 2024 ) , our goal is to identify cross-cutting factors that affect such decision-makers’ adoption of AI tools. In this work, we conduct a cross-domain analysis to identify inter-domain trends of decision-maker AI adoption choices. We select four representative domains (journalism ( Verma 2024 ) , law ( Contini 2024 ) , medicine ( Park et al. 2019 ) , and the public sector ( Amiri and Karahanna 2022 ) ) to cover a variety of predictive and generative AI applications across different sectors of the economy, with varying stakes, and include decision-makers from diverse backgrounds. In total, we conducted 16 semi-structured interviews with decision-makers on their familiarity with AI tools and their considerations for adoption. Through our interviews, we identify four common key factors that impact decision-maker adoption across domains: (1) the decision-maker’s background, (2) their perceptions of the AI model, (3) consequences for the decision-maker, and (4) the perceived implication of AI adoption for other stakeholders. Through the lens of these four factors, we examine why decision-maker adoption choices for similar AI use cases vary across domains. In particular, we provide two case studies of AI use cases surfaced by participants. First, we discuss why AI is often adopted as an e-discovery tool to help gather, organize, and analyze relevant digital data in journalism, law, and the public sector, but not necessarily in medical contexts. Then, we explore why decision-makers in law choose not to use AI for tailoring communications , while decision-makers in other domains do. These case studies highlight inter-domain differences in adoption behavior and demonstrate how our proposed four-factor framework can explain when decision-makers will (not) adopt AI. We envision our framework to serve as a guide to facilitate the proactive assessment of AI proposals for uptake in practice. To provide a structured guide to help researchers, model developers, and model designers think more critically about the key adoption considerations of decision-makers, we turn our factors into an AI adoption sheet to help facilitate the integration of decision-maker perspectives into the model development process (Figure 1 ). This sheet can serve as a starting point for organizations and policymakers to develop a comprehensive understanding of how decision-makers’ AI adoption choices may manifest in practice. We leave the empirical assessment of the efficacy and usability of the proposed sheet as a critical direction for future work. 2. Related Work As AI-powered systems are increasingly considered for real-world workflows, research on how decision-makers interact with AI has grown rapidly. We begin by reviewing prior work on decision-maker reliance , as it is the most frequently studied aspect of these interactions. However, for decision-makers to rely on AI, they must first choose to consult an AI tool regularly—which we refer to as their adoption choice . As such, we then discuss work on AI adoption, highlighting the difference between organizational and decision-maker adoption choices (Figure 2 ). Domain Alias Domain Experience AI AI Interaction Primary Area (Years) Familiarity Frequency of