Generative AI in Higher Education: Evidence from an Elite College

Zara Contractor, Germán Reyes · 2025

Read Generative AI in Higher Education: Evidence from an Elite College by Zara Contractor, Germán Reyes (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-00717.txt.

Introduction

Zara Contractor and German Reyes surveyed students at a selective American college on their use of generative AI, in a 2025 paper. Use spread fast, passing eighty percent within two years of ChatGPT's release. Yet hard facts on how students use these tools, and what they think it does to their learning, were scarce.

Students said they use AI more to boost learning, through explanations and feedback, than to produce final work for them. Use varied a lot by subject, background, and grades. Most students saw AI as aiding their learning, and that belief tracked closely with uptake. College rules shaped use, but unevenly, since awareness and compliance differed by group. The authors urge rules that split helpful uses from swaps for real work.

Catalog record

CREATORZara Contractor, Germán Reyes
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE122 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-00717

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Generative AI in Higher Education: Evidence from an Elite College Thanks: Contractor: Middlebury College ( [email protected] ). Reyes (corresponding author): Middlebury College and IZA ( [email protected] ). We thank Jeff Carpenter, Amy Collier, Christa Deneault, Peter Matthews, Caitlin Myers, Andrea Robbett, and participants at the Cornell Behavioral Economics Group and LACBEE for helpful discussions and comments. Coco Kitai and Gavin Randolph provided excellent research assistance. Financial support from Middlebury College’s Office of the Provost is gratefully acknowledged. This study was approved by the Middlebury College Institutional Review Board. Zara Contractor, Germán Reyes Abstract Generative AI is transforming higher education, yet systematic evidence on student adoption remains limited. Using novel survey data from a selective U.S. college, we document over 80 percent of students using AI academically within two years of ChatGPT’s release. Adoption varies across disciplines, demographics, and achievement levels, highlighting AI’s potential to reshape educational inequalities. Students predominantly use AI for augmenting learning (e.g., explanations, feedback), but also to automate tasks (e.g., essay generation). Positive perceptions of AI’s educational benefits strongly predict adoption. Institutional policies can influence usage patterns but risk creating unintended disparate impacts across student groups due to uneven compliance. 1 Introduction The rapid advancement of generative artificial intelligence (AI) is transforming higher education at an unprecedented pace. The launch of ChatGPT and similar tools has introduced technologies capable of performing tasks central to academic assessment and learning—writing essays, solving complex problems, and explaining intricate concepts—instantly and at near-zero marginal cost. Yet systematic evidence on the nature and implications of this new technology remains scarce. How widespread is generative AI adoption among students, and what factors drive it? Do students primarily use AI to augment their learning or to automate coursework, potentially harming human capital development? Could disparities in access to premium AI resources amplify existing educational inequalities? These questions are at the heart of ongoing debates about the role of AI in education, which have relied heavily on anecdotal evidence and speculation rather than rigorous evidence. As a result, universities have implemented policies that vary dramatically, from outright bans to permissive adoption, often without clear evidence on their effectiveness or unintended consequences ( Nolan, 2023 ; Xiao et al., 2023 ; McDonald et al., 2025 ) . This paper addresses this gap by systematically examining generative AI adoption at Middlebury College, a highly selective liberal arts college in Vermont. With approximately 2,800 undergraduate students, Middlebury offers 49 majors across the arts, humanities, languages, social sciences, and natural sciences. Over the past decade, Middlebury has consistently ranked among the top 10 liberal arts colleges in U.S. News & World Report, with an average ranking of 8.5 between 2015 and 2025. The college’s selectivity is comparable to that of many elite research universities—Middlebury’s acceptance rate of approximately 10 percent is similar to that of Boston University (11 percent), Georgetown University (13 percent), and the University of Virginia (16 percent). Our analysis draws on survey data collected from the student population between December 2024 and February 2025. The survey collected detailed information about AI usage, including the frequency and purpose of use, perceived impacts, and responses to institutional policies. To minimize selection bias, we framed the survey broadly as examining technology use and provided incentives for participation, achieving a 22.9 percent response rate with 634 responses representing a broad cross-section of the student population. We document five main findings. First, generative AI is approaching near-universal adoption at an unprecedented speed. Over 80 percent of students use AI for academic purposes, up from less than 10 percent before Spring 2023. This represents one of the fastest technology adoption episodes ever documented, dramatically exceeding the 40 percent adoption rate among U.S. workers ( Bick et al., 2025 ) and the 23 percent among all U.S. adults ( McClain, 2024 ) . These levels are consistent with international findings of 50–70 percent adoption in university contexts ( Nam, 2023 ; Stöhr et al., 2024 ; Ravšelj et al., 2025 ) . Second, AI adoption is markedly unequal across academic disciplines and demographic groups. Field of study is the strongest predictor of adoption, likely reflecting how well AI capabilities align with the academic tasks required across fields. Adoption ranges from 91.1 percent in Natural Sciences majors (including mathematics and computer science) to significantly lower levels in Literature (48.6 percent) and Languages (57.4 percent). Additionally, demographic disparities exist. For example, males adopt AI at higher rates than females (88.7 versus 78.4 percent), a pattern that is consistent with documented AI gender gaps in other contexts ( Otis et al., 2024 ) . Most notably, lower-achieving students have a higher adoption rate than their higher-achieving peers (87.1 versus 80.3 percent). As a result, AI could serve as an equalizing force if it enhances student learning—helping struggling students catch up to their peers—but could also widen achievement gaps if AI undermines skill development. Third, generative AI transforms the students’ learning production function by both augmenting student capabilities and automating academic tasks. We classify academic tasks as augmentation when AI enhances human capabilities while maintaining student engagement (e.g., explaining concepts, proofreading) versus automation when AI directly produces outputs with minimal cognitive involvement (e.g., writing essays, creating images), and average usage rates across tasks within each category. We find that 61.2 percent of AI users employ these tool for augmentation purposes, while 41.9 percent use it for automation. Qualitative evidence reinforces these patterns: students describe AI as an “on-demand tutor” for augmentation purposes, particularly valuable when traditional resources like office hours are unavailable, while automation use centers on time savings during periods of overwhelming workload. These self-reported patterns align closely with actual usage data from Claude conversation logs ( Handa et al., 2025a ) . Fourth, institutional policies can significantly influence AI adoption, though their effectiveness can be undermined by informational frictions. We find that explicit prohibitions dramatically reduce self-reported intended use 39 percentage points (pp). Importantly, the effects of this policy vary substantially across student groups, with females showing larger reductions in usage under prohibition than males, suggesting that one-size-fits-all policies may inadvertently create disparate impacts across groups. Moreover, we also document substantial informational gaps about institutional AI policies. Many students (19.2 percent) do not understand AI policy rules, few know about institution-provided premium AI resources (10.1 percent) or proper AI citation practices (32.6 percent)—a skill that is necessary for academic integrity. Fifth, students believe that AI has a positive learning impact and these beliefs strongly predict their own AI usage. Most students believe that AI improves their understanding of course materials (70.2 percent) and learning ability (60.1 percent), though fewer believe it improves grades (41.1 percent). Perhaps unsurprisingly, students who believe that AI improves their academic outcomes are significantly more likely to use these tools. For example, a ten-percentage-point increase in the belief that AI improves learning corresponds to a 4.9 percentage-point increase in adoption, highlighting how perceptions can affect technology diffusion in educational settings. Taken together, our findings reveal that generative AI has already reshaped students’ college experience. The substantial information gaps that we document—regarding both permitted uses and available resources—suggest straightforward opportunities for policy intervention. Yet the observed heterogeneity across disciplines and student groups indicates that uniform policies risk unintended consequences: blanket prohibitions may

Read the complete text