There is no ultrastrong coupling with photons

Diego Fernández de la Pradilla, Esteban Moreno, Johannes Feist · 2025

Read There is no ultrastrong coupling with photons by Diego Fernández de la Pradilla, Esteban Moreno, Johannes Feist (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-00702.txt.

Introduction

Diego Fernández de la Pradilla and co-authors present a theory paper from 2025 on light and matter at very strong coupling. They ask whether an emitter can reach the ultrastrong coupling regime through photons alone. Photons are treated here as waves of the transverse electromagnetic field in a supporting structure.

The authors argue from basic electromagnetic constraints that emitter-photon coupling has a firm upper limit. On that basis the ultrastrong regime cannot come from photons and must come from Coulomb interactions between charges. A related term for polarization self-energy is also shown to be unneeded. A worked model of an emitter near a metallic nanosphere supports the claim and prompts a fresh look at past work.

Catalog record

CREATORDiego Fernández de la Pradilla, Esteban Moreno, Johannes Feist
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE60 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-00702

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

There is no ultrastrong coupling with photons Diego Fernández de la Pradilla, Esteban Moreno, Johannes Feist Abstract Theoretical accounts of ultrastrongly coupled light-matter systems commonly assume that it arises from the interaction of an emitter with propagating photon modes supported by a structure, understanding photons as the excitations of the transverse electromagnetic field. This description discards the Coulomb interaction between the emitter and structure charges. Here, we show with a general argument based on electromagnetic constraints that the emitter-photon coupling strength is fundamentally limited. Accordingly, we conclude that the ultrastrong coupling regime cannot be reached with photons. Instead, it must originate from the Coulomb interactions between charges. A further corollary is that the so-called polarization self-energy term does not need to be included. We illustrate our claims by solving an analytical model of the paradigmatic case of an emitter next to a metallic nanosphere. These findings shed light on the fundamental processes underlying ultrastrong coupling, clarify the role of the polarization self-energy term and compel a reevaluation of previous literature. The smallness of the fine structure constant, \alpha\simeq\frac{1}{137} , implies that the interaction between quantum emitters and the electromagnetic (EM) field in free space is relatively weak. It has long been recognized that this limitation can be overcome by modifying the EM environment to reshape and enhance the field Purcell 1946 . In the extreme limit that the interaction strength \hbar g between a quantum emitter and an EM mode approaches the excitation energy of the emitter, \hbar\omega_{\mathrm{e}} , the system enters the so-called ultrastrong coupling (USC) regime Kockum et al. 2019 ; Forn-Díaz et al. 2019 , conventionally defined by \frac{g}{\omega_{\mathrm{e}}}\geq 10^{-1} . The accompanying hybridization of states with different excitation numbers has various fundamental consequences, such as dressing of the ground state by a cloud of virtual photons Ciuti et al. 2005 , leading to quantum-vacuum radiation when the system’s parameters are rapidly modulated Günter et al. 2009 ; Garziano et al. 2013 . USC has also been proposed for use in preparing non-classical states Ashhab and Nori 2010 or modifying ground-state material and chemical properties Schwartz et al. 2011 ; Wang et al. 2014 ; Garcia-Vidal et al. 2021 ; Lu et al. 2024 . Additionally, the USC regime distinctly affects the photon emission statistics from the system Liberato et al. 2007 ; Ridolfo et al. 2012 ; Ridolfo et al. 2013 ; Cirio et al. 2016 . Due to these effects, USC physics has the potential to become relevant for technological applications involving chemistry Martínez-Martínez et al. 2018 , materials science Scalari et al. 2012 , and quantum information Romero et al. 2012 ; Felicetti et al. 2014 ; Kyaw et al. 2015 ; Xiong et al. 2020 . Crucially, most predicted effects depend on the per-emitter coupling strength and do not benefit from collective enhancement—in other words, they require a single emitter to couple ultrastrongly to a cavity mode. In the following, we thus focus on the single-emitter USC regime. Figure 1: Sketch of a general QED setup with two sets of charges (emitter and nanophotonic structure) coupled to photons, with all three parts interacting with each other. Much of the literature on USC assumes that it arises from the coupling of an emitter to a photonic cavity mode. With “photon”, we refer to excitations of the true dynamical degrees of freedom of the EM field, described by the transverse (divergence-free) components \mathbf{E}^{\perp}(\mathbf{r}) and \mathbf{B}^{\perp}(\mathbf{r}) . Using the appropriate complete theory, non-relativistic QED Craig and Thirunamachandran 1984 ; Cohen-Tannoudji et al. 2007 , we show here that this assumption is fundamentally flawed, and that in fact USC cannot be reached by coupling between a single emitter and photons alone. This follows from a sum rule capturing the fact that the maximum density of states of photons is limited since the presence of a cavity can only rearrange these states, but not create new ones. Instead, single-emitter USC can only be reached through the Coulomb interaction between an emitter and the charges within the material structure that hosts the cavity mode (schematically depicted in Fig. 1 ). We show that the contribution of photons is negligible in all cases. In addition to the general argument, we illustrate our findings through an analytically solvable example where the separation between charge-charge and charge-photon interactions is transparent. The above statements have important implications for the description of USC. The common but flawed assumption of purely photonic cavity modes implies that the form of the coupling depends on the choice of gauge Cohen-Tannoudji et al. 2007 , and in particular that the light-matter coupling includes a term proportional to the square of either the EM vector potential, \propto g^{2}\mathbf{A}^{2} , or of the polarization density of the emitter, \propto g^{2}\mathbf{P}^{2} (which in the long-wavelength approximation turns into the so-called dipole self-energy, \propto g^{2}\mathbf{d}^{2} , with \mathbf{d} the emitter dipole operator). The presence of these terms can have important consequences, such as an effective decoupling of light and matter for large enough coupling De Liberato 2014 ; García-Ripoll et al. 2015 or significant modifications of the chemical structure of molecules Rokaj et al. 2018 ; Schäfer et al. 2020 ; Borges et al. 2024 ; Weight et al. 2024 ; Schnappinger and Kowalewski 2024 . In contrast, the charge-charge (Coulomb) interactions between the cavity structure and the emitter that we show to be responsible for USC can be described through the longitudinal (curl-free) component of the electric field, \mathbf{E}^{\parallel}(\mathbf{r}) , which is not a dynamical degree of freedom but rather fully determined by the instantaneous position of the charges. This interaction does not give rise to \mathbf{A}^{2} nor \mathbf{P}^{2} -terms, such that these cannot play an important role in physical setups. We note the that statements above are not necessarily surprising. For example, it is well-known that subwavelength field confinement is required to reach single-emitter USC Benz et al. 2016 ; Groß et al. 2018 ; Kuisma et al. 2022 , and that subwavelength field confinement implies that the longitudinal fields dominate over the transverse ones Khurgin 2015 ; Galego et al. 2019 . Still, we are not aware of any work that has explicitly demonstrated the bound on the emitter-photon coupling strength that we present here. In fact, much of the existing literature on USC overlooks this bound by assuming that USC is reached through the emitter-photon interaction. We thus believe that our findings are important to clarify the fundamental processes underlying USC, and to compel a reevaluation of previous literature. Theoretical framework In this section, we frame the problem of USC in terms of charges and photons within non-relativistic QED Cohen-Tannoudji et al. 2007 ; Craig and Thirunamachandran 1984 . We next apply this description to an emitter coupled to the EM modes supported by an arbitrary material structure, which we will call the “cavity” for convenience regardless of its physical nature (which can be a photonic crystal, a plasmonic structure, etc.). Then, we show that USC can only be reached when the dominant mechanism is the charge-charge interaction between the emitter and cavity. We start from the minimal coupling Hamiltonian in the Coulomb gauge ( \nabla\cdot\mathbf{A}=0 ), which describes the charges of both the emitter and the cavity

Read the complete text