Screw Symmetry, Chiral Hydrodynamics and Odd Instability in Active Cholesterics

Gareth P. Alexander, S. J. Kole, Ananyo Maitra, Sriram Ramaswamy · 2025

Read Screw Symmetry, Chiral Hydrodynamics and Odd Instability in Active Cholesterics by Gareth P. Alexander, S. J. Kole, Ananyo Maitra, Sriram Ramaswamy (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-00684.txt.

Introduction

Alexander, Kole, Maitra, and Ramaswamy study active cholesterics in a 2025 arXiv paper. These materials twist in a screw pattern and also push on themselves through active stresses. Both forms of twist give rise to curl forces in their flow.

The authors derive the flow rules from standard equations using a geometric approach. This clarifies how screw symmetry shapes the motion of the material's layers. They show that screw symmetry adds a new term to the activity of the layers. When the two forms of twist clash strongly enough, a fresh instability appears with its own threshold. They also comment on related materials with three-dimensional screw symmetry.

Catalog record

CREATORGareth P. Alexander, S. J. Kole, Ananyo Maitra, Sriram Ramaswamy
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE56 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-00684

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Screw Symmetry, Chiral Hydrodynamics and Odd Instability in Active Cholesterics Gareth P. Alexander, S. J. Kole, Ananyo Maitra, Sriram Ramaswamy Abstract Active cholesterics are chiral in both their structure, which has continuous screw symmetry, and their active stresses, which include contributions from torque dipoles. Both expressions of chirality give rise to curl forces in the hydrodynamics, which we derive from the active Ericksen-Leslie equations using a geometric approach. This clarifies the hydrodynamics of continuous screw symmetry and provides an example of generalised odd elastic forces that originate from an equilibrium free energy. We discuss also the nonlinear structure of the active hydrodynamics in terms of the Eulerian displacement field of the cholesteric pseudolayers. For the active instability, screw symmetry generates a contribution of chiral activity to the linearised pseudolayer hydrodynamics that is absent in materials with chiral activity but achiral structure. When the two forms are sufficiently antagonistic, this term produces a new active instability with threshold and characteristic wavevector distinct from those of the active Helfrich-Hurault instability in chiral active smectics. Finally, we comment on the isotropic chiral hydrodynamics of materials with three-dimensional screw symmetry. \longdate I Introduction Active matter theories describe the physics of non-equilibrium systems in which the scale of the drive is smaller than the minimal lengthscale at which the theoretical description is valid and the driving mechanism is not spatially correlated. That is, unlike traditional non-equilibrium systems in which the driving mechanism explicitly breaks rotation symmetry, here it only breaks time-reversal symmetry. The physics of spontaneous breaking of various spatial symmetries in these systems has therefore been a fruitful area of research over the last three decades TonTuRam ; SRrev ; RMP ; bowick2022 ; maitra2025 . Chiral forms of active driving have taken prominence in recent years; these include spinning particles, helical swimming, microscopic torque dipoles and non-reciprocally actuated robotic assemblages. They show a range of macroscopic phenomena including odd viscous and elastic moduli fruchart2023 ; Mietke ; kole2021 ; kole2024 , unidirectional edge flows li2024 , self-organised locomotion ishimoto2022 ; ishimoto2023 , stirring kole2025 , and adaptive locomotion veenstra2025 . The majority of this has considered materials that are chiral only through their activity so that the interplay between chiral activity and chiral structure remains relatively unexplored. Chiral forms of passive materials are extremely rich, displaying a huge range of metastable states, geometric frustration and proliferation of topological defects renn1988 ; wright1989 ; matsumoto2009 ; machon2017 ; pollard2019 ; wu2022 . Cholesteric liquid crystals provide a basic setting for the interplay between chiral activity and chiral structure, where active stresses of torque dipole form influence the helical director field. In terms of their spontaneous symmetry breaking, liquid crystals occupy a middle ground in that they remain invariant under some spatial transformations and not others, thus leading to spectacular symmetry-mandated mechanics and dynamics. In both cholesterics and smectics the ground states are periodic along one spatial direction and the large scale mechanics of both is therefore a compressional elasticity along that direction and a bending elasticity perpendicular to it lubensky1972 ; deGennesProst . A hallmark of this is that both cholesterics and smectics exhibit the same mechanical Helfrich-Hurault instability TranRMP . At the same time, the spontaneous symmetry breaking of the two phases is distinct: cholesteric states are formed by aligning chiral molecules that, due to microscopic geometric frustration, organise in a helical structure; smectics have a one-dimensional periodic density modulation. While both structures are periodic, an arbitrary translation of the former can be compensated by a rotation; there is no such invariance in the latter. This distinction leads to differences in flow phenomena helfrich1969 at subleading order in wavenumbers lubensky1972 . In an earlier article kole2021 , we showed that activity allows chirality to play an important role in the hydrodynamics maitra2025 , leading to an anti-ferromagnetically organised columnar vortex lattice array in response to a periodic undulation of the layer (or pseudolayer) structure. However, we argued that the structural difference between cholesteric and smectic phases do not affect the small-wavenumber, low-frequency physics, i.e., active smectic A* and cholesteric phases are hydrodynamically equivalent. In this article, we reexamine the hydrodynamics of active cholesteric phases using a geometric approach to the Ericksen-Leslie equations that we adapt from that used for the free energy by Radzihovsky & Lubensky radzihovsky2011 . The screw symmetry of cholesterics is manifested in a coupling of fluid vorticity to the pseudolayer dynamics and a corresponding antisymmetric contribution to the hydrodynamic stress lubensky1972 . We review the origin of this and show produces a curl force of generalised odd elastic form but, in contrast to two-dimensional odd elasticity fruchart2023 , here it originates from an equilibrium free energy. Crucially, the vorticity coupling term allows a chiral active force density to participate in the linear instability of the pseudolayered structure in the Stokesian regime, albeit at subleading order in wavenumbers. This changes the character of the instability with the threshold value of contractile activity for an active Helfrich-Hurault kole2021 ; whitfield2017 in systems confined along the pitch direction and the most unstable transverse wavevector, both depending explicitly on the chiral active force density. Further, for sufficiently strong chiral activity with opposite handedness to the cholesteric helix it produces a new active instability with characteristics distinct from those of Helfrich-Hurault and ultimately leading to a breakdown of the cholesteric structure at the level of the pitch. The remainder of this paper is organised as follows. In Section II we describe in less technical terms the chiral mechanics of active cholesterics and the nature of their generalised odd elasticity. In Section III we obtain the hydrodynamics of active cholesterics through a geometric analysis of the Ericksen-Leslie equations adapting the methodology of Ref. radzihovsky2011 . In Section IV we present the nonlinear hydrodynamic theory of active cholesterics in terms of the Eulerian displacement field. In Section V we analyse the linearised theory of cholesterics and identify their active instabilities, with focus on the rotation-translation coupling effects of screw symmetry. In Section VI we examine the linear isotropic hydrodynamics of a material with three-dimensional rotation-translation couplings. Finally, in Section VII we end with a discussion. II Chiral Mechanics and Screw Symmetry in Cholesterics Chiral mechanical forces have been identified in a range of continuum materials and mesophases fruchart2023 ; maitra2025 . A basic example is the odd elasticity of two-dimensional isotropic solids, which support a chiral force density K_{o}\,{\bf J}\cdot\nabla^{2}{\bf u} , where {\bf J} is the generator of (counterclockwise) rotations and {\bf u} is the Eulerian displacement field. In three-dimensional active layered mesophases kole2021 , the chiral mechanics is a curl force \zeta_{c}\nabla\times(\nabla^{2}u\,{\bf N}) , where here {\bf N} is the layer normal and u is again the Eulerian displacement field (along the layer normal). The same force is also present in active chiral membranes al-izzi2023 and in both cases it may be viewed as originating from the active stress of microscopic torque-dipoles furthauer2012 ; furthauer2013 . The chiral mechanics of active polar columnar phases contains forces analogous to both the curl force of active layered mesophases and the odd elasticity of two-dimensional solids kole2024 . In this case, the three-dimensionality of the columnar phase, together with the viscous part of its mechanics, leads to

Read the complete text