Quantum entanglement of Hawking-Partner modes in expanding cavities

José Manuel Montes-Armenteros, Javier Olmedo · 2025

Read Quantum entanglement of Hawking-Partner modes in expanding cavities by José Manuel Montes-Armenteros, Javier Olmedo (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-00423.txt.

Introduction

José Manuel Montes-Armenteros and Javier Olmedo study entanglement born in an expanding cavity in a 2025 paper. One wall of a one-dimensional cavity accelerates as prescribed, mimicking Hawking radiation from black holes. The team measured quantum links between one chosen mode and the rest of the field. A partner-mode reconstruction formula gave the same answers at lower cost.

Partner modes do not commute, so pairwise thinking cannot capture the whole web. The cavity acts like a squeezing device, and Hawking pairs behave much like two-mode squeezed states. Purification turned out to be a low-energy affair; high-energy particles barely joined partner modes. Entanglement faded toward the ultraviolet in both gentle and fierce acceleration. Starting from squeezed or warm states, the team tested whether entanglement could be boosted, and how it survives noise. Lab prospects close the paper.

Catalog record

CREATORJosé Manuel Montes-Armenteros, Javier Olmedo
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE97 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-00423

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Quantum entanglement of Hawking-Partner modes in expanding cavities José Manuel Montes-Armenteros, Javier Olmedo Abstract This article investigates quantum entanglement generated within a one-dimensional cavity where one boundary undergoes prescribed acceleration, a setup designed to mimic aspects of Hawking radiation. We quantify quantum correlations using logarithmic negativity for bipartitions where subsystem A A is a given mode and subsystem B B the rest of the system. For initial pure states, we also consider a given mode and reconstruct its partner using the Hotta-Schützhold-Unruh formula, obtaining identical results. Besides the initial vacuum state, we also consider one-mode squeezed and two-mode squeezed states, in order to confirm if quantum entanglement can be stimulated. Moreover, we analyze its robustness against initial thermal noise. Our analysis is based on numerical simulations and does not assume any approximation beyond the validity of our numerical algorithms. Our findings reveal that the expanding cavity effectively acts as a squeezing device, with Hawking-partner pairs largely behaving as two-mode squeezed states. A significant conclusion is that, in our setting, purification of Hawking modes is predominantly a low-energy process, with high-energetic particles contributing negligibly to the partner modes. Indeed, in both small and large acceleration regimes of the boundaries, quantum entanglement decreases towards the ultraviolet modes, indicating that higher-energy particles are more challenging to entangle and hence less probable to contribute in the purification process. While the Hotta-Schützhold-Unruh formula offers notable computational efficiency, partner modes do not commute, due to the non-trivial multimode entanglement structure of the system. Hence, this pairwise description is not suitable for describing the full system. I Introduction The phenomenon of Hawking radiation, originally predicted in the context of black hole physics, has profound implications for our understanding of quantum fields in curved spacetimes and the interplay between general relativity and quantum mechanics. Hawking’s seminal work demonstrated that black holes emit thermal radiation, leading to gradual loss of mass and, ultimately, evaporating, perhaps leaving a final remnant. Despite its fundamental importance, direct experimental observation of Hawking radiation from astrophysical black holes remains elusive because of its extremely low intensity and temperature for typical black hole masses. Besides, the emitted radiation depends only on the black hole mass, charge, and angular momentum, meaning that any detailed information about the matter that formed the black hole would be lost, leaving behind a mixed state of radiation. This outcome contradicts the fundamental principle of unitarity in quantum mechanics, namely, that information must be preserved under time evolution. Instead, if a pure quantum state evolves into a mixed state, unitarity will not be satisfied. This problem has spurred decades of research Refs. Unruh and Wald 2017 ; Marolf 2017 ; Modak et al. 2015 ; Almheiri et al. 2021 ; Ashtekar 2025 , with the precise mechanism by which this occurs remaining a subject of debate within the community. To circumvent these conceptual challenges, researchers have developed analogue systems that simulate the essential features of Hawking radiation in controlled laboratory settings. One of the first analogue systems suggested by Fulling and Davies considered an accelerating mirror Davies and Fulling 1977 . They showed that particular trajectories of the mirror are able to excite the field vacuum state into a thermal one. Later on it was shown that there exist a plethora of trajectories able to produce thermal particles Good et al. 2013 ; Akal et al. 2022 . Other examples of promising analogue systems where spontaneous Hawking radiation is expected are those based on Bose-Einstein condensates Garay et al. 2000 ; Garay et al. 2001 ; Barcelo et al. 2003 ; Steinhauer 2016 ; Muñoz de Nova et al. 2019 ; Kolobov et al. 2021 ; Ribeiro and Fischer 2023 , quantum fluids of light Carusotto and Ciuti 2004 ; Nguyen et al. 2015 , electromagnetic waveguides Schutzhold and Unruh 2005 , and optical fibers Philbin et al. 2008 ; Belgiorno et al. 2010 ; Rubino et al. 2011 ; Drori et al. 2019 ; Agullo et al. 2022 ; Brady et al. 2022 . See also Ref. Barcelo et al. 2005 for a detailed review. Moving mirrors provide an excellent theoretical setting for the study of Hawking radiation and the information loss problem. There have been attempts to explain how information is restored via entanglement of the early time Hawking radiation with vacuum fluctuations in the far future, when the mirror returns to inertial motion Hotta et al. 2015 . However, as stated in Ref. Wald 2019 , this scenario also suffers from similar limitations as the usual last-burst models, where Hawking radiation is purified by a final, very high energetic burst: There appears to be an indirect energy cost for purification. See also Osawa et al. 2024 for a more recent discussion of this issue. It seems that the heart of all these problems lies in the requirement that information loss must be solved within the weak-field approximation, where semiclassical physics remains valid. Actually, in the context of more realistic, evaporating black holes, it was recently shown in Ref. Agullo et al. 2024 that partner modes explore spacetime regions where general relativity ceases to be valid, making unprovable that semiclassical physics is enough to explain the information loss problem. A very close approach recently considered within this context is a quantum field confined within one-dimensional cavity, where the motion of one or the two boundaries can mimic the effect of a gravitational horizon Refs. García Martín-Caro et al. 2023 ; García Martín-Caro et al. 2024 ; García Martín-Caro et al. 2025 . Here, the acceleration of a boundary induces a change in the vacuum state of the field, leading to particle creation and the emergence of a nearly thermal spectrum, closely resembling the Hawking effect. One of the advantages of this setting is their experimental feasibility using coplanar wave guides ended in superconducting quantum interference devices (SQUIDS) Wilson et al. 2011 ; Johansson et al. 2009 ; Johansson et al. 2010 ; Doukas and Louko 2015 ; Lähteenmäki et al. 2013 . In fact, they have been considered in other configurations in order to simulate black hole-like geometries Terrones and Sabín 2021 ; Maceda and Sabín 2025 . In this work, following that framework, we investigate quantum correlations by computing the logarithmic negativity —a well-established measure of entanglement— using both general expressions for a system of N interacting modes, taking a bipartition with a given mode as subsystem A and the rest of the modes as subsystem B , and alternatively by tracing out all modes except one, corresponding to a Hawking mode, and explicitly constructing its partner, inspired by Hotta-Schützhold-Unruh in Ref. Hotta et al. 2015 . Besides, we study initial states different from the vacuum to understand if it is possible to stimulate quantum entanglement between pairs of particles, and also discuss the robustness of quantum entanglement against initial thermal noise, following the ideas of Refs. Agullo et al. 2022 ; Brady et al. 2022 , which are also based on Gaussian state theory Weedbrook et al. 2012 ; Adesso et al. 2014 . This approach and the operational advantages of the methods we adopt here allow us to quantify the entanglement structure of the resulting state and to clarify the role and properties of the Hawking

Read the complete text