Analysis of the hadronic molecules D K DK , D ∗ K D^{*}K , D K ∗ DK^{*} and their bottom analogs with QCD sum rules
Ze Zhou 1, Guo-Liang Yu 1,2, Zhi-Gang Wang 1,2, Jie Lu 3, Bin Wu 1 · 2025
Read Analysis of the hadronic molecules D K DK , D ∗ K D^{*}K , D K ∗ DK^{*} and their bottom analogs with QCD sum rules by Ze Zhou 1, Guo-Liang Yu 1,2, Zhi-Gang Wang 1,2, Jie Lu 3, Bin Wu 1 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-00402.txt.
Introduction
The authors compute the masses of exotic particles that may be loose unions of two known mesons. Using QCD sum rules, a method that ties particle properties to the vacuum's background fields, they built currents for charm-strange pairs and their heavier bottom cousins, keeping many correction terms.
The predicted masses land right on three known particles, supporting their reading as molecular states. Two bottom pairings come out above their breakup thresholds, so they likely cannot bind. A third bottom pairing falls below its threshold, marking it as a candidate bound molecule worth hunting in experiments.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ze Zhou 1, Guo-Liang Yu 1,2, Zhi-Gang Wang 1,2, Jie Lu 3, Bin Wu 1 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 44 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-00402
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Analysis of the hadronic molecules D K DK , D ∗ K D^{*}K , D K ∗ DK^{*} and their bottom analogs with QCD sum rules Ze Zhou 1, Guo-Liang Yu 1,2, Zhi-Gang Wang 1,2, Jie Lu 3, Bin Wu 1 Abstract In this work, we construct the color-singlet-color-singlet type currents to study the masses and pole residues of charm-strange tetraquark states and their bottom analogs with J P J^{P} = 0 + 0^{+} and 1 + 1^{+} by using two-point QCD sum rules, where the vacuum condensates are considered up to dimension 12. The predicted masses for D K DK , D ∗ K D^{*}K and D K ∗ DK^{*} molecular states are 2.322 − 0.072 + 0.066 2.322_{-0.072}^{+0.066} GeV, 2.457 − 0.068 + 0.064 2.457_{-0.068}^{+0.064} GeV and 2.538 − 0.062 + 0.059 2.538_{-0.062}^{+0.059} GeV. These results are consistent well with the experimental data of D s 0 ( 2317 ) D_{s0}(2317) , D s 1 ( 2460 ) D_{s1}(2460) and D s 1 ( 2536 ) {D}_{s1}(2536) , respectively. The theoretical results for B K BK and B ∗ K B^{*}K molecular states are 5.970 − 0.064 + 0.061 5.970_{-0.064}^{+0.061} GeV and 6.050 − 0.064 + 0.062 6.050_{-0.064}^{+0.062} GeV which are all higher than their own thresholds. Finally, the mass of hadronic molecule B K ∗ BK^{*} is predicted to be 6.158 − 0.063 + 0.061 6.158_{-0.063}^{+0.061} GeV. This value is lower than the threshold of B K ∗ BK^{*} , which implies that it may be a bound hadronic molecular state. I Introduction D_{s0}^{*}(2317) was discovered by BaBar collaboration BaBar:2003oey in the mass distribution of D_{s}^{+}{\pi^{0}} in the annihilation process of {e^{+}}{e^{-}} in 2003. In the same year, D_{s1}(2460) treated as the spin partner of D_{s0}^{*}(2317) in the heavy quark spin symmetry was observed by CLEO collaboration CLEO:2003ggt . Subsequently, several other experiments Belle:2003guh ; BaBar:2004yux ; BaBar:2006eep confirmed these discoveries. In addition, another charm-strange state {D}_{s1}(2536) was also measured earlier by Belle collaboration ARGUS:1989zue . Since the observation of D_{s0}^{*}(2317) , D_{s1}(2460) and {D}_{s1}(2536) , extensive experimental investigations about these states were conducted Belle:2003kup ; BaBar:2004gtd ; BaBar:2003cdx ; Akhmedov:2005np . The masses and decay widths of these charm-strange states are listed in Tab. 1 . Table 1: The experimental data for D_{s0}^{*}(2317) , D_{s1}(2460) and D_{s1}(2536) ParticleDataGroup:2024cfk . States J^{P} Mass (MeV) Full width (MeV) D_{s0}^{*}(2317) 0^{+} 2317.8 \pm 0.5 \Gamma < 3.8 D_{s1}(2460) 1^{+} 2459.5 \pm 0.6 \Gamma < 3.5 D_{s1}(2536) 1^{+} 2535.11 \pm 0.06 \Gamma = 0.92 \pm 0.05 At the same time, there were also a lot of intense theoretical analyses about the underlying structure of these states. In particularly, the masses of D_{s0}^{*}(2317) and D_{s1}(2460) are about one hundred MeV lower than the predictions of quark model Godfrey:1985xj ; Godfrey:1986wj ; DiPierro:2001dwf . Furthermore, this large deviation also appeared in the simulations of lattice QCD Moir:2013ub and greatly confused the theoretical and experimental physicists. This issue is commonly referred to as low-mass issue, and similar phenomenon was also observed in {\Lambda_{c}}(2940) Luo:2019qkm and X(3872) Kalashnikova:2005ui . Up to now, there have been many theoretical studies which were proposed to solve this problem and understand the inner structure of these states. For example, D_{s0}^{*}(2317) , D_{s1}(2460) were analyzed as compact tetraquark states Nielsen:2005ia ; Wang:2006uba ; Chen:2004dy ; Dmitrasinovic:2005gc ; Cheng:2003kg ; Terasaki:2003qa ; Dmitrasinovic:2004cu ; Kim:2005gt ; Zhang:2018mnm , or the conventional quark-antiquark states Bardeen:2003kt ; Deandrea:2003gb ; Dai:2003yg ; Sadzikowski:2003jy ; Cahn:2003cw ; Hwang:2004cd ; Simonov:2004ar ; Cheng:2014bca ; Song:2015nia ; Cheng:2017oqh ; Luo:2021dvj ; Zhou:2020moj ; Alhakami:2016zqx . In addition, there are also some papers advocating that these states can be explained as a mixture state of quark-antiquark plus four-quark components Vijande:2006hj ; Maiani:2004vq ; Dai:2006uz ; Browder:2003fk , or be interpreted as molecular states vanBeveren:2003kd ; Liu:2012zya ; Barnes:2003dj ; Roca:2025lij ; Kong:2021ohg ; Kolomeitsev:2003ac ; Szczepaniak:2003vy ; Hofmann:2003je ; Gamermann:2006nm ; Flynn:2007ki ; Faessler:2007gv ; Guo:2009ct ; Xie:2010zza ; Cleven:2010aw ; Wu:2011yb ; Guo:2015dha ; Albaladejo:2016hae ; Du:2017ttu ; Guo:2018tjx ; Albaladejo:2018mhb ; Wu:2019vsy ; Gregory:2021rgy ; Wang:2012bu ; Huang:2021fdt ; Chen:2016spr ; Liu:2019zoy . As for {D}_{s1}(2536) , there are also many articles that treat it as DK^{*} tetraquark molecular state Lin:2024hys ; Gamermann:2007fi ; Guo:2006fu ; Guo:2006rp , because it could be obtained from the interaction of coupling channel in the molecular picture. As the partner of open charm molecular states, bottom-strange states with I{(J^{P})} = 0{(0^{+})} and 0{(1^{+})} also attract our attention. Despite the lack of experimental data, theoretical physicists have conducted extensive researches on these states Guo:2006fu ; Guo:2006rp ; Faessler:2008vc . The results indicate that there may exist two bound states BK and B^{*}K whose energies are below their own thresholds, respectively. Recently, LHCb collaboration LHCb:2020pet observed two structures which can be treated as {B_{sJ}}(6064) and {B_{sJ}}(6114) if they decay directly to B^{+}K^{-} . These two bottom states can also be treated as {B_{sJ}}(6109) and {B_{sJ}}(6158) if decaying through {B^{*\pm}}{K^{\mp}} channel. The mass of {B_{sJ}}(6158) is measured to be 6158\pm 4\pm 5 MeV which is very close to the threshold of BK^{*} . Thus, the investigation of BK , B^{*}K and BK^{*} molecular state is an interesting work. That is to say, although there have been many studies on the inner structures of D_{s0}(2317) , D_{s1}(2460) , {D}_{s1}(2536) and their bottom analogs by using different methods, the conclusions were not consistent well with each other. Thus, it is still very essential for us to study these open charm/bottom states with QCD sum rules Shifman:1978by ; Shifman:1978bx . As a very powerful no-perturbative approach, the QCD sum rules have been widely used to study the mass spectrum, decay constant, form factor and coupling constant of hadrons Wei:2006wa ; Wang:2024ciy ; Wang:2015epa ; Wang:2013vex ; Aliev:2012tt ; Belyaev:1993wp ; Dai:1996xv . The purpose of the present work is to provide valuable information to understand the structures of D_{s0}(2317) , D_{s1}(2460) , {D}_{s1}(2536) and their bottom analogs by analyzing the hadronic molecular states DK , D^{*}K , DK^{*} , BK , B^{*}K and BK^{*} . This article is arranged as follows: After the introduction, we obtain the QCD sum rules of masses and pole residues of DK , D^{*}K , DK^{*} , BK , B^{*}K and BK^{*} molecular states in section II . The numerical results and discussions are given in section III , Section IV is reserved for a short conclusion. II The two-point QCD sum rule In order to obtain the masses and pole residues of charm-strange tetraquark molecular states DK , D^{*}K , DK^{*} and their bottom analogs, we write down the following two-point correlation functions, \displaystyle\Pi^{0}(p) \displaystyle=i\int{{d^{4}}x}{e^{ip\cdot x}}\left\langle 0\right|T\{J^{0}(x){J^{0{\dagger}}}(0)\}\left|0\right\rangle \displaystyle\Pi^{1}_{\mu\nu}(p) \displaystyle=i\int{{d^{4}}x}{e^{ip\cdot x}}\left\langle 0\right|T\{J^{1}_{\mu}(x)J^{1{\dagger}}_{\nu}(0)\}\left|0\right\rangle \displaystyle\Pi^{2}_{\mu\nu}(p) \displaystyle=i\int{{d^{4}}x}{e^{ip\cdot x}}\left\langle 0\right|T\{J^{2}_{\mu}(x)J^{2{\dagger}}_{\nu}(0)\}\left|0\right\rangle (1) where T is the time ordered product, and J^{0}(x) , J^{1}_{\mu}(x) and J^{2}_{\mu}(x) are the interpolating currents with the same quantum numbers as studied states. The currents of these states can be expressed as, \displaystyle J^{0}(x)= \displaystyle\frac{1}{{\sqrt{2}}}[{{\bar{s}}^{m}}(x)i{\gamma_{5}}{u^{m}}(x){{\bar{u}}^{n}}(x)i{\gamma_{5}}{Q^{n}}(x) \displaystyle+{{\bar{s}}^{m}}(x)i{\gamma_{5}}{d^{m}}(x){{\bar{d}}^{n}}(x)i{\gamma_{5}}{Q^{n}}(x)] \displaystyle J_{\mu}^{1}(x)= \displaystyle\frac{1}{{\sqrt{2}}}[{{\bar{s}}^{m}}(x)i{\gamma_{5}}{u^{m}}(x){{\bar{u}}^{n}}(x){\gamma_{\mu}}{Q^{n}}(x) \displaystyle+{{\bar{s}}^{m}}(x)i{\gamma_{5}}{d^{m}}(x){{\bar{d}}^{n}}(x){\gamma_{\mu}}{Q^{n}}(x)] \displaystyle J_{\mu}^{2}(x)= \displaystyle\frac{1}{{\sqrt{2}}}[{{\bar{s}}^{m}}(x){\gamma_{\mu}}{u^{m}}(x){{\bar{u}}^{n}}(x)i{\gamma_{5}}{Q^{n}}(x) \displaystyle+{{\bar{s}}^{m}}(x){\gamma_{\mu}}{d^{m}}(x){{\bar{d}}^{n}}(x)i{\gamma_{5}}{Q^{n}}(x)] (2) Here, m , n are color indexes, and Q stands for c or b quark field. The currents J^{0}(x) , J_{\mu}^{1}(x) and J_{\mu}^{2}(x) represent DK , D^{*}K and DK^{*} tetraquark