Correcting Misperceptions at a Glance: Using Data Visualizations to Reduce Political Sectarianism

\authororcid Douglas Markant0000-0003-0568-2648, \authororcid Subham Sah0009-0007-9446-6731, \authororcid Alireza Karduni0000-0001-9719-7513, \authororcid Milad Rogha0000-0002-1464-2157, \authororcid My Thai0000-0003-0503-2012, \authororcid Wenwen Dou0000-0003-0319-9484 · 2025

Read Correcting Misperceptions at a Glance: Using Data Visualizations to Reduce Political Sectarianism by \authororcid Douglas Markant0000-0003-0568-2648, \authororcid Subham Sah0009-0007-9446-6731, \authororcid Alireza Karduni0000-0001-9719-7513, \authororcid Milad Rogha0000-0002-1464-2157, \authororcid My Thai0000-0003-0503-2012, \authororcid Wenwen Dou0000-0003-0319-9484 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-00233.txt.

Introduction

Douglas Markant and co-authors test whether charts can fix wrong beliefs about the other party in politics. Their 2025 study notes that people often overstate how many rivals back extreme acts, and that fixing that error can cool one's own hard views. Nearly five hundred United States adults from both parties took part.

Each person first guessed rival support for violence and anti-democratic acts, then saw true survey values in one of three chart forms. A plain average and a full dot spread corrected beliefs most; a band form worked less well. The full spread also left the best memory of the true values later. Chart design, the authors conclude, shapes how well the fix lands.

Catalog record

CREATOR\authororcid Douglas Markant0000-0003-0568-2648, \authororcid Subham Sah0009-0007-9446-6731, \authororcid Alireza Karduni0000-0001-9719-7513, \authororcid Milad Rogha0000-0002-1464-2157, \authororcid My Thai0000-0003-0503-2012, \authororcid Wenwen Dou0000-0003-0319-9484
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE64 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-00233

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Correcting Misperceptions at a Glance: Using Data Visualizations to Reduce Political Sectarianism \authororcid Douglas Markant0000-0003-0568-2648, \authororcid Subham Sah0009-0007-9446-6731, \authororcid Alireza Karduni0000-0001-9719-7513, \authororcid Milad Rogha0000-0002-1464-2157, \authororcid My Thai0000-0003-0503-2012, \authororcid Wenwen Dou0000-0003-0319-9484 Abstract Political sectarianism is fueled in part by misperceptions of political opponents: People commonly overestimate the support for extreme policies among members of the other party. These misperceptions inflame partisan animosity and may be used to justify extremism among one’s own party. Research suggests that correcting partisan misperceptions—by informing people about the actual views of outparty members—may reduce one’s own expressed support for political extremism, including partisan violence and anti-democratic actions. However, there remains a limited understanding of how the design of correction interventions drives these effects. The present study investigated how correction effects depend on different representations of outparty views communicated through data visualizations. Building on prior interventions that present the average outparty view, we consider the impact of visualizations that more fully convey the range of views among outparty members. We conducted an experiment with U.S.-based participants from Prolific (N=239 Democrats, N=244 Republicans). Participants made predictions about support for political violence and undemocratic practices among members of their political outparty. They were then presented with data from an earlier survey on the actual views of outparty members. Some participants viewed only the average response (Mean-Only condition), while other groups were shown visual representations of the range of views from 75% of the outparty (Mean+Interval condition) or the full distribution of responses (Mean+Points condition). Compared to a control group that was not informed about outparty views, we observed the strongest correction effects (i.e., lower support for political violence and undemocratic practices) among participants in the Mean-only and Mean+Points condition, while correction effects were weaker in the Mean+Interval condition. In addition, participants who observed the full distribution of out-party views (Mean+Points condition) were most accurate at later recalling the degree of support among the outparty. Our findings suggest that data visualizations can be an important tool for correcting pervasive distortions in beliefs about other groups. However, the way in which variability in outparty views is visualized can significantly shape how people interpret and respond to corrective information. Supplemental materials for this paper are available at this OSF repository . \onlineid 1695 \vgtccategory Research \vgtcpapertype Theoretical/Empirical \authorfooter Douglas Markant, Subham Sah, Milad Rogha, and Wenwen Dou are with the University of North Carolina at Charlotte. Email: {dmarkant, ssah1, mrogha, wdou1}@charlotte.edu. Alireza Karduni is with Simon Fraser University. E-mail: [email protected]. My Thai is with the University of Florida. E-mail: [email protected]. \teaser Our experiment evaluated correction effects of different visual representations of outparty views on one’s own support for political extremism. The study included 5 steps, with the overall design and findings annotated in the figure. keywords uncertainty visualization, political communication, partisan misperception 1 Introduction Political sectarianism is increasingly recognized not just as a threat to democratic institutions, but as a force that fractures societies and harms individual health and well-being [ 31 , 11 , 10 ] . Evidence suggests that, while political polarization has increased by some measures, people’s perception of the extent of partisan polarization is far more extreme than warranted [ 21 , 35 ] . False polarization refers to the phenomenon that people perceive the views of other groups to be more extreme (and less diverse) than they actually are [ 34 ] . For instance, Democrats overestimate the proportion of Republicans who express support for political violence (and vice versa). False polarization can sustain, and potentially accelerate, actual ideological and affective polarization, as it can cause extreme actions to be seen as more representative of the out-party, be used to justify more extreme actions by one’s in-party, and lessen the perceived prospects of compromise [ 3 , 27 ] . Motivation. Past work has sought to correct false polarization by exposing gaps between perceived and actual views [ 7 , 8 , 20 , 24 , 33 ] . Correction interventions typically first ask individuals to make a prediction about an out-party view. Respondents are then shown the actual level of support expressed by members of the other party according to previously collected data. These corrections have been shown to reduce the perception gap about the other party [ 3 ] . Interestingly, the corrections also reduce respondents’ own expressed extremism when then asked whether they support the same positions [ 3 , 8 ] . This has led to the suggestion that correcting partisan misperceptions can disrupt the cycle of hyperpartisanship and reinforce mainstream political norms. Recent work has highlighted some important limitations of these interventions. While they typically correct misperceptions about other groups’ views, some studies have failed to show effects on participants’ own attitudes [ 7 ] . Correction effects from interventions may also be easily undermined. For instance, [ 8 ] found that following a correction with a caveat about the inherent uncertainty of opinion polling led to the correction having no effect. Thus there are open questions about the robustness of correction effects and how they are driven by different aspects of the intervention design. A more fundamental limitation of past work in this area concerns a nearly exclusive focus on the average or most common view of the out-party, while omitting information about the variability or distribution of views. Corrections that only communicate the central tendency may obscure important information about the outparty, such as the smaller but concerning prevalence of extreme views across the political spectrum. For example, [ 24 ] found that approximately 5-10% of respondents in both political parties expressed some willingness to engage in political violence. A correction that only shows the central tendency (e.g., low average support for violence among the outparty) may leave participants with a distorted understanding of outparty views, repeating the error of other forms of political communication by using generic statements about opposing political groups [ 28 ] . Alternatively, not communicating the range of outparty views may make it more difficult to reconcile a correction with well-established beliefs about the outparty. If people are frequently exposed to examples of extremism on the other side (e.g., due to hyperpartisanship in media coverage and among political elites [ 35 ] ) , a focus on an average outparty view that sharply contradicts that prior experience could lead to distrust and rejection of the correction. This idea is consistent with misinformation research showing that simply refuting a false belief is less effective than providing alternative explanations or contextual details that help people make sense of conflicting evidence [ 22 ] . Communicating variability may allow people to realize that while extreme views are indeed present in the outparty, they are far less common than their experience would suggest. Present study. These limitations point to a need to consider the effects of including information about the variability or distribution of views (in addition to the average view) when correcting partisan misperceptions. The present study examines the use of data visualizations in correcting misperceptions about the other party. Data visualizations offer an efficient means for communicating more complex information about variability in viewpoints. In addition, visual formats may be especially effective for a correction intervention because they make more salient the gap between a participant’s prediction

Read the complete text