Generalizing the Penrose cut-and-paste method: Null shells with pressure and energy flux

Miguel Manzano, Argam Ohanyan, Roland Steinbauer · 2025

Read Generalizing the Penrose cut-and-paste method: Null shells with pressure and energy flux by Miguel Manzano, Argam Ohanyan, Roland Steinbauer (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-00231.txt.

Introduction

Miguel Manzano, Argam Ohanyan, and Roland Steinbauer extend a classic method for building thin light-speed shells in spacetime, in a paper from 2025. Penrose's cut-and-paste trick joins two spacetime regions along a lightlike surface to model a shell. Until now it handled only pure gravity or lightlike dust shells.

The authors first write the joined metric in a well-behaved continuous form for the most general matching of constant-curvature regions. They then derive the change of coordinates that puts it in cut-and-paste form with a sharp delta term. An example shell in flat space carries real energy density, energy flux, and pressure.

Catalog record

CREATORMiguel Manzano, Argam Ohanyan, Roland Steinbauer
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE102 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-00231

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Generalizing the Penrose cut-and-paste method: Null shells with pressure and energy flux Miguel Manzano, Argam Ohanyan, Roland Steinbauer Abstract The cut-and-paste method is a procedure for constructing null thin shells by matching two regions of the same spacetime across a null hypersurface. Originally proposed by Penrose, it has so far allowed to describe purely gravitational and null-dust shells in constant-curvature backgrounds. In this paper, we extend the cut-and-paste method to null shells with arbitrary gravitational/matter content. To that aim, we first derive a locally Lipschitz continuous form of the metric of the spacetime resulting from the most general matching of two constant-curvature spacetimes with totally geodesic null boundaries, and then obtain the coordinate transformation that turns this metric into the cut-and-paste form with a Dirac-delta term. The paper includes an example of a null shell with non-trivial energy density, energy flux and pressure in Minkowski space. Contents 1 Introduction In nature, it is common to find neighbouring spacetime regions with different matter content, for instance the interior and exterior of a neutron star. Metric theories of gravity must hence be capable of matching spacetimes, i.e. of constructing one single spacetime by suitably gluing regions with distinct matter-energy properties. In particular, null matchings, i.e. matchings across a null hypersurface, are of special relevance in General Relativity since they are key to describing gravitational waves, as well as black holes and gravitational collapse. As a result, countless examples of null shells have been studied in various scenarios and contexts, see e.g. [ 3 , 17 , 45 ] and references therein. There exist two approaches to null matchings: the standard matching theory going back to Darmois [ 8 ] in the timelike/spacelike cases and later generalized to the null [ 4 ] and to the arbitrary causal character cases [ 33 , 34 ] , and Penroses’s so-called “cut-and-paste” method [ 40 ] . In the context of the former, particularly relevant to this paper are the recent works [ 24 , 25 , 26 ] . Based on the formalism of hypersurface data [ 29 , 30 , 31 ] , they provide a completely general approach—that is, without a-priori assumptions on the matching hypersurface or the spacetimes to be matched—which at the same time allows to obtain very explicit results, e.g. the gravitational/matter content of any null shell, or the first example of a null shell with pressure in Minkowski space. It is worth emphasizing, however, that [ 24 , 25 , 26 ] concentrate primarily on identifying the geometric objects that encode the full information of the matching and on deriving the expression for the energy-momentum tensor of the null shell, rather than on obtaining an explicit form of the metric of the matched spacetime. Alternatively Penrose has put forward his vivid cut-and-paste method [ 40 ] . Originally, he used it to construct impulsive pp -waves propagating in Minkowski space by cutting it into two “halves” along a null hyperplane \widetilde{\mathcal{N}}=\{\mathcal{U}=0\} , and reattaching them with a shift along the null generators of \widetilde{\mathcal{N}} . This identification of boundary points with a jump along the null direction are called the Penrose junction conditions. The matched spacetime is then described by a metric with a Dirac \delta -term supported on \widetilde{\mathcal{N}} , ds^{2}=-2d\mathcal{U}d\mathcal{V}+d\mathcal{X}^{2}+d\mathcal{Y}^{2}+2\mathcal{H}(\mathcal{X},\mathcal{Y})\delta(\mathcal{U})d\mathcal{U}^{2}, (1.1) clearly displaying curvature concentrated on the single wave surface \widetilde{\mathcal{N}} . In fact, this metric lies beyond the largest general class of metrics that enables a stable definition of (distributional) curvature [ 11 , 23 , 52 ] , but the high symmetry nevertheless allows one to calculate the curvature explicitly. Penrose also has constructed expanding, spherical impulsive waves in Minkowski space, and later on the method has been extended to all constant-curvature backgrounds, see [ 14 , Ch. 20] , and also [ 42 ] for a recent pedagogical review. In his seminal work [ 40 ] , Penrose also has introduced a continuous form of the metric ( 1.1 ), which was clearly “physically equivalent”, but the precise relation between the two metrics remained obscure. In later works the geometric meaning of the notorious “discontinuous coordinate transformation” relating the two metric forms has been made transparent [ 51 ] , and formulated in a mathematically rigorous way [ 19 ] , recently even with a non-zero cosmological constant [ 41 , 46 ] . An important limitation of the cut-and-paste method is that, so far, it has only allowed for the construction of purely gravitational or null-dust shells. However, null shells with much more general matter contents have been built in [ 24 , 25 , 26 ] —both in constant curvature backgrounds and in more general settings—, and in [ 24 ] a firm connection to the cut-and-paste method has been established. In this work we generalize the cut-and-paste method for all constant-curvature spacetimes to produce null shells with completely general energy-momentum tensors. We also obtain explicit expressions for the corresponding metric forms, which encode the matter content of the shell in a transparent way in the metric functions. In particular, we first derive a locally Lipschitz continuous form of the metric g of the spacetime (\mathcal{M},g) resulting from the most general matching of two regions of Minkowski or (anti-)de Sitter space across a totally geodesic null hypersurface (Sections 4 and 6 ). In this context, we also revisit the general matching of semi-Riemannian manifolds (Appendix A ) and prove that under natural mild conditions the metric of the matched manifold is locally Lipschitz (w.r.t. its natural smooth differentiable structure), thereby straightening an old result of [ 7 ] . Then we also derive a vivid distributional form of the metric, again displaying a Dirac- \delta term supported on the matching hypersurface. To do so, we first introduce a “discontinuous coordinate transformation” together with a distributional ansatz for g , and prove that the ansatz and the Lipschitz continuous metric forms are related by the proposed coordinate transformation (Sections 5 and 6 ). Here we defer some technical calculations regarding regularizations of distributional products to Appendix B . While our treatment here cannot be considered final, we firmly prepare the ground for future studies of the geodesics in these distributional geometries, which we expect in analogy to the classical cut-and-paste case to open the gates to a full nonlinear distributional analysis of the notorious transformation, cf. [ 48 , 47 , 41 , 46 ] . Our results not only extend the cut-and-paste construction to generic null shells in spacetimes with constant curvature, but also yield the corresponding generalized Penrose junction conditions, which determine the shift along the null generators of the matching hypersurface. Finally, we include an explicit example of a null shell with non-trivial energy density, energy flux and pressure in Minkowski space (Section 7 ). 1.1 Notation and conventions All manifolds are smooth and connected. Given a manifold \mathcal{M} we use \mathcal{F}\left(\mathcal{M}\right){\mathrel{{\mathop{\,\,=\,\,}\limits}}}C^{\infty}\left(\mathcal{M},\mathbb{R}\right) , and \mathcal{F}^{\star}\left(\mathcal{M}\right)\subset\mathcal{F}\left(\mathcal{M}\right) for the subset of no-where zero functions. The tangent bundle is denoted by T\mathcal{M} , and \Gamma\left(T\mathcal{M}\right) is the set of sections (i.e. vector fields). We use \pounds , d for the Lie derivative and exterior derivative. Given a differentiable map \phi between manifolds, we use the standard notation of \phi^{\star} and \phi_{\star} for

Read the complete text