A Keynesian Intertemporal Synthesis (KIS) Model: Towards a unified and empirically grounded framework for fiscal policy
Ricardo Alonzo Fernández Salguero · 2025
Read A Keynesian Intertemporal Synthesis (KIS) Model: Towards a unified and empirically grounded framework for fiscal policy by Ricardo Alonzo Fernández Salguero (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-00224.txt.
Introduction
Ricardo Alonzo Fernández Salguero rebuilds a Keynesian model of fiscal policy on firmer evidence. His Keynesian Intertemporal Synthesis model tries to unite the strengths of two rival schools, post-Keynesian and new Keynesian, inside one optimizing framework. The headline change swaps the standard Cobb-Douglas production function for a form that lets machines and labor substitute for each other at a rate set by data rather than fixed at one.
That change is driven by a meta-analysis rejecting a substitution rate of one. The model also absorbs findings on how fiscal multipliers grow in crises, which spending tools work best, how public capital raises output, and why households do not fully offset government debt. Households differ, value wealth, and dislike debt, and policy rates can stick at zero. In this setup, public investment lifts demand more than equal consumption spending, and its boost swells sharply in downturns.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ricardo Alonzo Fernández Salguero |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 62 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-00224
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Keynesian Intertemporal Synthesis (KIS) Model: Towards a unified and empirically grounded framework for fiscal policy Ricardo Alonzo Fernández Salguero Abstract This paper develops a new generation of the Keynesian Intertemporal Synthesis (KIS) Model, a macroeconomic framework designed to reconcile the empirical strengths of the Post-Keynesian (PK) and New Keynesian (NK) traditions. The central innovation of this work is the abandonment of the traditional Cobb-Douglas production function in favor of a Constant Elasticity of Substitution (CES) specification. This modification is directly motivated by the compelling evidence from the meta-analysis by Gechert et al. (2021), which emphatically rejects the hypothesis of a unit elasticity of substitution between capital and labor. We integrate this finding with the conclusions from a wide range of meta-analyses on the state-dependent heterogeneity of fiscal multipliers (Gechert and Rannenberg, 2018), the productivity of public capital (Bom and Ligthart, 2014), the effectiveness hierarchy of spending instruments (Gechert, 2015), and the empirical failure of Ricardian Equivalence (Stanley, 1998). The resulting KIS-CES model, while based on intertemporal optimization, incorporates household heterogeneity, non-standard preferences that value wealth and penalize debt, and a monetary policy constrained by the zero lower bound. The mathematical derivations reveal that the elasticity of substitution, calibrated to an empirically plausible value of σ < 1 \sigma<1 , becomes a key parameter that modulates income distribution and magnifies the crowding-in effect of public investment. The model generates an endogenous MPC, a nonlinear fiscal multiplier that increases dramatically in crises, and a multiplier for public investment that is structurally higher than that for consumption, thus offering a unified, rigorous, and, above all, empirically disciplined theoretical framework. 1 Introduction The debate over the effectiveness of fiscal policy has resurfaced with unprecedented intensity following the Great Financial Crisis of 2008, catalyzing an explosion of empirical research whose often contradictory results have left a confusing landscape for policymakers. At this Gordian knot of contemporary macroeconomics, two main theoretical paradigms, the New Keynesian (NK) and the Post-Keynesian (PK), have offered frameworks for interpreting these phenomena, although, as the exhaustive analysis by Gechert [ 14 ] demonstrates, neither is capable of capturing the full range of stylized facts that the evidence has revealed. The NK framework, with its rigorous microfoundations based on intertemporal optimization and the inclusion of nominal rigidities, has provided a convincing explanation for one of the most robust empirical findings of the last decade: the marked state-dependency of fiscal multipliers on the economic cycle. Specifically, the power of fiscal policy is greatly magnified when monetary policy is constrained by the Zero Lower Bound (ZLB), a theoretical result from models like that of Christiano et al. [ 5 ] that has been overwhelmingly confirmed by the meta-analysis of Gechert and Rannenberg [ 10 ] . However, this same paradigm struggles to explain the size of the multiplier in normal times (which evidence places around unity) and the microeconomic evidence showing a high and heterogeneous Marginal Propensity to Consume (MPC) among households, a clear contradiction to the Permanent Income Hypothesis in its purest form. On the other hand, the Post-Keynesian tradition, with its emphasis on the principle of effective demand, inherent instability, and social stratification, offers a more natural explanation for the high average MPC and the importance of income distribution, but its framework often lacks the dynamic formalization necessary to explain the non-linearity of the multiplier or to engage effectively with the mainstream. The situation is further complicated when considering the conclusions of other meta-analyses that have synthesized decades of empirical research. The work of Gechert [ 9 ] establishes a clear hierarchy in the effectiveness of different fiscal instruments: multipliers for public investment spending systematically outperform those for consumption spending, and both are larger than those for taxes and transfers. This finding suggests that the composition of the fiscal adjustment is of first-order importance, a nuance that models with a single aggregate of public spending ( G ) cannot capture. In parallel, the literature on the productivity of public capital, synthesized by Bom and Ligthart [ 2 ] and Nijkamp and Poot [ 23 ] , confirms that public investment is not a mere demand stimulus but a factor that increases the economy’s productive capacity in the long run, although its effect is more moderate than what the seminal early studies suggested. Finally, the premise of Ricardian Equivalence (RE), which underpins fiscal ineffectiveness in many neoclassical models, has been resoundingly rejected by aggregate empirical evidence, as demonstrated by the meta-analysis of Stanley [ 24 ] , who concludes that the literature, taken as a whole, is strongly inconsistent with Ricardian equivalence. This rich and often bewildering confluence of stylized facts demands a new theoretical approach. The objective of this paper is to propose and mathematically develop an alternative framework that transcends the traditional dichotomy: the Keynesian Intertemporal Synthesis (KIS) Model . This model does not seek a paradigmatic victory, but a pragmatic and empirically disciplined synthesis, building a theoretical bridge based on the strengths of each tradition. To this end, the KIS adopts the rigorous language of intertemporal optimization, characteristic of the NK framework, but enriches it with more realistic behavioral premises and assumptions, directly inspired by Keynes’s ideas, behavioral economics, and the quantitative findings of the aforementioned meta-analyses. The model is founded on a set of axioms designed to directly address the shortcomings of existing models: (i) explicit household heterogeneity to break Ricardian Equivalence; (ii) a hybrid utility function that captures saving and borrowing motives beyond consumption, to generate a realistic MPC; (iii) an explicit distinction between productive (investment) and non-productive (consumption) public spending to explain the hierarchy of multipliers; and (iv) interaction with a monetary policy constrained by the ZLB to generate state-dependent non-linearity. Through rigorous mathematical development, we will demonstrate how this architecture not only qualitatively replicates the stylized facts but also offers a quantitatively plausible framework for understanding the complex dance between fiscal policy, the business cycle, and the economic structure. 2 Literature review Contemporary macroeconomics is at a crossroads, a period of deep introspection and re-evaluation forced by the 2008 Great Financial Crisis and subsequent economic turmoil. The old consensus, often referred to as the New Neoclassical-Keynesian Synthesis or the Washington-Berlin Consensus, which prescribed restrictive fiscal and monetary policies along with widespread deregulation, has been called into question not only by real-world events but also by a rising tide of quantitative empirical evidence [ 12 ] . In this context, meta-analysis has emerged as an indispensable tool, a rigorous methodology for navigating the vast and often contradictory empirical literature, allowing researchers to synthesize results, quantify uncertainty, and identify and correct for publication biases that may have perpetuated theoretical consensuses on fragile empirical grounds. As Irsova et al. [ 16 ] argue in their guide for practitioners, modern meta-analysis is not simply an averaging exercise, but a forensic investigation of the literature itself, examining how methodological choices, data characteristics, and selective reporting biases shape economic facts. This literature review seeks to map out a new emerging consensus, one that is being built not from pure theoretical axioms, but from the systematic synthesis of empirical evidence in key areas such as fiscal policy, the structure of production, and financial frictions, using the findings of the most comprehensive available