Measuring leadership and productivity in an organisational structure
2025
Read Measuring leadership and productivity in an organisational structure (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-00181.txt.
Introduction
Ramón Flores, Elisenda Molina, and Juan Tejada build a game-theoretic way to score leadership and productivity inside an organization chart, in a 2025 paper. People become nodes and reporting lines become arrows in a directed graph. Drawing on cooperative game theory, they define a leadership score by averaging each person's marginal contribution over every possible hierarchical team shape.
A matching productivity score totals the value those team shapes produce. The paper proves basic properties of the leadership measure and studies how it reacts when the chart changes. A Monte Carlo algorithm makes the scores computable for large organizations. The authors aim the tool at spotting structurally strong leaders.
Catalog record
| YEAR | 2025 |
|---|---|
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 61 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-00181
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Measuring leadership and productivity in an organisational structure Abstract This paper develops a novel methodological framework for assessing leadership potential and productivity within organisational structure represented by directed graphs. In this setting, individuals are modeled as nodes and asymmetric supervisory or reporting relationships as directed edges. Leveraging the theory of transferable utility cooperative games, we introduce the Average Forest (AF) measure, a marginalist leadership measure grounded in the enumeration of maximal spanning forests, where teams are hierarchically structured as arborescences. The AF measure captures each agent‘s expected contribution across all feasible team configurations under the assumption of superadditivity of the underlying game. We further define a measure of organisational productivity as the expected aggregate value derived from these configurations. The paper investigates key theoretical properties of the AF measure -such as linearity, component feasibility, and monotonicity- and analyzes its sensitivity to structural modifications in the underlying digraph. To address computational challenges in large networks, a Monte Carlo simulation algorithm is proposed for practical estimation. This framework enables the identification of structurally optimal leaders and enhances understanding of how network design impacts collective performance. Keywords: TU game, directed hierarchical structure, marginal contribution vector, average tree solution JEL Classification Number: C71 Mathematics Subject Classification 2000: 91A12, 91A43 Ramón Flores Instituto de Matemáticas de la Universidad de Sevilla (IMUS), Departamento de Geometría y Topología, Universidad de Sevilla, Spain e-mail: [email protected] Elisenda Molina Instituto de Matemática Interdisciplinar (IMI), Departamento de Estadística e Investigación Operativa, Universidad Complutense de Madrid, Spain e-mail: [email protected] Juan Tejada 1 1 1 Proyectos Instituto de Matemática Interdisciplinar (IMI), Departamento de Estadística e Investigación Operativa, Universidad Complutense de Madrid, Spain e-mail: [email protected] 1 Introduction and Motivation The measurement of leadership skills in individuals is an important topic in organisational studies, which has generally been conducted through questionnaires and qualitative techniques (Batista-Foguet et al., 2021), in an attempt to explore the potential of such individuals. Our approach, however, considers leadership evaluation of an individual by taking into account their current position in the organisational structure, as well as their potential to add value to the formation of working teams that they could lead. To this end, we will consider the organisation to be represented by its organisational chart, i.e. a directed graph, and the possible synergies of forming different working teams as a value function reflecting the potential benefits that the organisation could obtain by assigning a project to that team. In our approach, it is fundamental to establish which type of working team we should consider. We understand that a working team facing a concrete project must be hierarchically structured. Such a hierarchical structure has long been associated with increased efficiency in project execution due to its capacity to streamline communication, clarify responsibilities, and optimize decision-making. In hierarchical structures, the flow of information follows a well-defined path, reducing ambiguity and minimising the risk of redundant or conflicting efforts. Such structure ensures that each team member knows their role and to whom they report, which enhances accountability and allows for a more straightforward delegation of tasks (Mintzberg, 1983). Moreover, hierarchical structures are particularly well-suited to projects that require high levels of coordination across different functional areas, as they establish authority gradients that help in managing interdependencies and aligning sub-teams toward common goals (Galbraith, 1973). This clarity becomes even more vital in complex or large-scale projects, where inefficiencies stemming from unclear reporting chains can lead to costly delays or misallocation of resources. In relation with the problem of team formation in expertise social networks, the advantages of hierarchy directly support the core assumptions of the model presented. The assumption that working teams are organised in hierarchies resonates with findings that structured leadership fosters cohesion and enhances performance, particularly when team tasks are interdependent and time-bound. Furthermore, empirical evidence suggests that hierarchical arrangements promote stability in collaboration patterns, enabling agents to form effective subgroups under recognized leadership (Ahuja, Soda, & Zaheer, 2012). When leadership is tied both to the structural position within a digraph and the actual productivity of the teams led, as proposed in our model below, the hierarchical organisation not only becomes a governance mechanism but also a driver of measurable performance. By embedding leadership valuation into the network structure, the model aligns with observed organisational dynamics where authority and competence interact to form efficient and adaptive teams. In this work, we focus on organisational structures in which there is no apparent hierarchical order at first, but which must be hierarchically organised through working teams to develop a project in order to optimize the desired performance. To be specific, we model an organisation by a digraph, where the nodes represent the members of the organisation, and the arcs reflect the non-symmetric relation among them: (i,j) represents the ability of agents i and j for collaborating effectively under player i ’s supervision. Observe that any node with several incoming arcs in the digraph may be interpreted as a competition among the superiors/managers for the leadership on the subordinate located at the node. Each player located at a node with several incoming arcs may chose which of his immediate predecessors, who offer the player to join their teams, to follow, but he can follow only one of them. Formally such an assumption is equivalent to the statement that a digraph under scrutiny can be represented by any of its spanning forests, when all the spanning forests are feasible. Given prior information about the performance of the respective working teams, our aim is to evaluate the efficiency of the structure in terms of its capacity to form working teams. Additionally, we seek to identify the individuals best suited to act as leaders of these working teams. This is achieved by measuring their leadership ability , which is related to each agent’s position in the organisational structure, but also with the performance of each working team that each agent is able to lead. We propose a marginalistic leadership valuation which is based on four main assumptions: (i) working teams are organised in hierarchies, (ii) the worth of a working team depends only on its members, (iii) maximal hierarchies are the most productive ones, and (iv) all maximal hierarchies are equally probable to form. Assumptions (ii) and (iii) support to describe each working group’s worth by means of an appropriate superadditive TU game, whereas assumption (iv) leads to a non-informative a priori valuation of each agent’s leadership. Theoretically, we define the Average Forest (AF) measure and we study its properties. With respect to its properties, special attention is devoted to the right notion of efficiency in this setting, and to the concept of network productivity, as a measure of the ability of the structure to promote the formation of productive teams. We also study the behavior of the Average Forest measure when an existing arc is removed, or a non existing arc is added. Notwithstanding the fact that the objective of this study is not to define a value for games on digraphs, but rather to measure leadership in the restricted context of organisational situations, the extension of which to more general communication situations may not make sense. The proposed leadership measure does follow a marginalist approach inspired on Average Tree -like values for graph games, such