Quantum scarring enhances non-Markovianity of subsystem dynamics
Aditya Banerjee · 2025
Read Quantum scarring enhances non-Markovianity of subsystem dynamics by Aditya Banerjee (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-23757.txt.
Introduction
Aditya Banerjee gives numeric proof that odd, non-thermal states inside a quantum system make its parts hold a memory of their past. His 2025 paper starts from a basic split: any part of a closed quantum system acts as an open system of its own. Its motion can be memory-free or can carry echoes of what came before, and echoes slow the drift toward calm.
The odd states are called quantum many-body scars. They sit inside a sea of normal states yet refuse to heat up. In a model known for scar-driven swings, Banerjee tracks how facts flow back into small parts over time. When the scars are boosted, the memory grows; when they are wiped, it fades. First states rich in scars show the same pattern.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Aditya Banerjee |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 52 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-23757
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Quantum scarring enhances non-Markovianity of subsystem dynamics Aditya Banerjee Abstract Given that any subsystem of a closed out-of-equilibrium quantum system is an open quantum system, its dynamics (reduced from the full system’s unitary evolution) can be either Markovian (memory-less) or non-Markovian, with the latter necessarily impeding the process of relaxation and thermalization. Seemingly independently, such non-ergodic dynamics occurs when an initial state has spectral weight on the so-called quantum scar states, which are non-thermalizing states embedded deep in the spectrum of otherwise thermal states. In this article, we present numerical evidence that the presence of quantum scars is a microscopic ingredient that enables and enhances non-Markovianity of the dynamics of subsystems. We exemplify this with the PXP model and its deformations which either enhance or erase the signatures of scarred dynamics when quenched from a simple product state that is known to have significant overlaps with the scarred subspace in the spectrum. By probing information backflows with the dynamical behaviour of the distances between temporally-separated states of small subsystems, systematic signatures of subsystem non-Markovianity in these models are presented, and it is seen that scarring-enhancing (erasing) deformations also exhibit enhanced (diminished) subsystem non-Markovianity. This sheds new light on the dynamical memories associated with quantum scarring, and opens interesting new questions at the interface of quantum scarring and an open quantum systems approach to investigating far-from-equilibrium and non-thermalizing isolated quantum many-body systems. I Introduction Non-integrable quantum many-body systems (QMBS) that are far away from equilibrium are expected to thermalize when their Hamiltonian evolutions are initiated from generic, typical initial states Gogolin and Eisert 2016 . By ”typical”, one means an initial state that has a well spread support over the eigenstates of the Hamiltonian in an appropriate microcanonical window and ideally has approximately equal weights on a majority of those eigenstates. For a QMBS that can thermalize in principle, its eigenstates which are sufficiently higher in the spectrum from the ground state(s) are volume-law entangled and satisfy the Eigenstate Thermalization Hypothesis (ETH) Deutsch 2018 . Sometimes such eigenstates are also referred to as thermal eigenstates. Notwithstanding this typical picture, in recent years an atypical situation of special interest is that of the so-called quantum scar states Chandran et al. 2023 . These are high energy eigenstates in the bulk of the spectrum of a QMBS that are non-thermal : they are usually entangled sub-extensively, violate the ETH and when an initial state has a notable overlap with them, full system fidelity revivals and other signatures of non-thermalizing dynamics follow. What is remarkable is that these non-thermal scar states exist amongst thermal states in the spectrum, and generally speaking the number of these states is only polynomial in system size and therefore exponentially suppressed relative to the remainder of the spectrum. Furthermore, the quality of fidelity revivals is naturally dependent on how significantly overlapping a given initial state is with the set of scars in the system’s spectrum. Thus, when these overlaps are not particularly significant yet not negligible (and therefore the strength of fidelity revivals is not perfect), one expects thermalization to eventually follow within experimental or computational times after a prolonged ”pre-thermalization” regime. Since this is more generally the case with most known examples of scarred QMBS, quantum scarred dynamics are an example of weakly-broken ergodicity Turner et al. 2018a . Indeed, for systems in the thermodynamic limit, perfect fidelity revivals are an exceptionally rare occurrence in general and any scarred dynamics can only result in a slower approach to an otherwise guaranteed thermalization in the long-time limit. The actual attainment of thermal equilibrium for sufficiently large systems in some cases can be well beyond computational and experimental times and resources, however. It so happens with many scarred models that their scar states are approximately equally spaced in energy and so the scarred subspaces take the form of towers Moudgalya et al. 2022 ; Chandran et al. 2023 . When an initial state in a quench dynamics of these systems happens to be a superposition of these tower states, observables and entanglement entropies are expected to exhibit oscillations for long times. However, it turns out that this does not happen for most known models of scarred QMBS, owing to a recently proposed no-go theorem that seems to govern most of these cases O’Dea and Sriram 2025 . As such, scarred QMBS with oscillatory entanglement dynamics are a minority and therefore of special interest. The most well-known quantum scarred model, the PXP model, exhibits imperfect signatures (fidelity revivals and oscillations in entanglement entropies) of scarred dynamics in its base form, but these become stronger and more persistent with the inclusion of certain quasi-local terms in the PXP Hamiltonian with tunable and optimal coefficients Choi et al. 2019 . A different aspect of the non-equilibrium dynamics of a closed QMBS is the (non-)Markovianity of the dynamics of its subsystems, which however can also depend on the size of the subsystems in question in addition to other physical parameters of a given system Banerjee 2025 . This is rooted in two essential facts : any subsystem of a closed out-of-equilibrium QMBS is a bonafide open quantum system interacting with an environment which is the remainder part of the full system, and the dynamics of any open system interacting with an environment can be characterized as either memory-less (Markovian) with a monotonic loss of information out of the system into its environment, or it can retain memory of its past due to information backflows from the environment back to the system (non-Markovian) Vacchini 2024 . Let us describe the scenario briefly. When the coupling between a quantum system in question and its environment is weak (in comparison to the interaction timescales of the environment, in which case the environment can act as a ”bath” in self-equilibrium unaffected by the dynamics of the quantum system), the dynamics is generically Markovian because the bath, owing to it being unaffected by its coupling to the quantum system in question, instead drives the quantum system to an equilibrium state compatible with its own equilibrium (the bath provides the temperature to which the quantum system should equilibrate to - this is thus ultimately going to be described by the canonical ensemble picture of statistical mechanics). In such a dynamics, the quantum system monotonically loses memory of its past states, with a one-way flow of such information from the system out into the bath, but since the bath is unaffected by the dynamics of the system at hand, such information flows are lost forever (information is not a conserved quantity). As such, the future state of the quantum system is only dependent on its present state and not on the past states. When the system and its environment are strongly coupled such that the environment is affected by the system’s dynamics and its intrinsic correlation timescales are comparable to their coupling strength, it results typically in non-Markovianity of the dynamics of the system (or equivalently, one says that the environment is non-Markovian). In this case, the information loss is not monotonic, in that there is usually an information backflow from the environment back into the system, and thus the dynamics of the quantum system in question depends on its past