Pseudo-Isometric Surgery
Matt Clay, Josh Thompson · 2025
Read Pseudo-Isometric Surgery by Matt Clay, Josh Thompson (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-23666.txt.
Introduction
Matt Clay and Josh Thompson introduce a surgery operation on metric spaces and ask which properties survive it. The surgery replaces a subspace with a different space, glued in through a given function. When the replacement is discrete, the operation amounts to collapsing the subspace according to that function.
A natural induced map connects the original space to the surgered one. The main question is whether niceness of the gluing function transfers to the induced map. For pseudo-isometries it does: the induced map is again a pseudo-isometry. For quasi-isometries, the standard generalization beloved in geometric group theory, the inheritance fails. The counterexample marks a real boundary between the two notions.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Matt Clay, Josh Thompson |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 26 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-23666
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Pseudo-Isometric Surgery Matt Clay, Josh Thompson Abstract . We introduce a type of surgery on metric spaces. This surgery, in some sense, seeks to replace a subspace S S of a metric space X X with another metric space T T via a function f : S → T f\colon\thinspace S\to T . When T T is a discrete space, this amounts to collapsing the subspace according to the function. This surgery results in a new metric space we denote X ^ f \widehat{X}_{f} and there is a natural function F : X → X ^ f F\colon\thinspace X\to\widehat{X}_{f} induced from f f . Our primary interest is investigating if properties of the original function f f are inherited by the induced function F F . We show that if f f is a pseudo-isometry then so is F F . However, for a quasi-isometry, a very natural generalization of a pseudo-isometry that is prevalent in geometric group theory, such a result does not hold. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification Primary 51F30, 53C23; Secondary 20F65, 20E08 1. Introduction The idea of removing a subset from a space and replacing it with a modified version is one the most basic transformations of mathematics. For example the Möbius band, often obtained as the result of a cut/twist/reglue operation can also arise from a remove/alter/replace operation on the annulus, see Figure 1 . Such transformations are used to produce new spaces that are simulatneously different from, yet similar to, the original. Figure 1. The Möbius band is obtained from a remove/surgery on the annulus. In 1910 Max Dehn introduced a procedure in three dimensions, later referred to as "surgery" by Milnor and Thom [ 1 ] and now known as Dehn Surgery . In it, one first removes a solid torus T from a 3–manifold and then ‘sews it back differently’, see [ 2 ] and [ 3 ] for details. There are many different ways to sew the solid torus back in. Specifically, note that simple closed curves on the torus can be identified with ordered pairs of relatively prime integers (m,n) corresponding to how the curve winds around the surface. Once the solid torus T is removed we can glue it back in so that the (m,n) curve is sewn to the curve that previously matched the (1,0) curve. Each different choice of m and n results in a potentially different 3–manifold. In fact, every closed, orientable, connected 3–manifold can be obtained by Dehn surgery on a collection of solid tori in the 3-sphere; a result known as the Lickorish–Wallace theorem [ 4 ] . One might also examine the impact of surgery on the underlying geometry of a space. Consider \mathbb{R} under the standard metric. For this surgery, instead of ‘sewing it back differently’ we ‘sew in something else’ as follows: remove every interval of the form [2n,2n+1] where n\in\mathbb{Z} and replace each with a single point, see Figure 2 . The resulting space Y with the obvious path metric is isometric to \mathbb{R} . This surgery is clearly not an isometry but, as will become clear later, it is a quasi-isometry (in fact also a pseudo-isometry too). \mathbb{R}: 2n 2n+1 2n+2 2n+3 2n+4 2n+5 2n+6 2n+7 Figure 2. Replacing the red sets by points gives a space quasi-isometric to \mathbb{R} . We formalize this notion of surgery for an arbitrary metric space X using a map f\colon\thinspace S\to T where S is a subspace of X and T is another metric space. The question we ask is whether properties of the (local) map used to sew the space T onto S are inherited by the (global) natural map of the total space to the surgered space. The specific properties we examine in this paper are that of being a quasi-isometry or a pseudo-isometry. Quasi-isometries are a very important class of functions on metric spaces that allow for a controlled distortion. Such a function is a transformation between metric spaces that distorts distances by a uniformly bounded amount, above a given scale. A precise definition is given in Definition 2.1 and its subsequent remark. Implicit in the work of \check{\mbox{S}} varc [ 5 ] in 1955 and Milnor [ 6 ] in 1968, the notion of a quasi-isometry is central to Gromov’s idea of coarse equivalence of metric spaces. In 1981, Gromov [ 7 ] defined quasi-isometry the way it is used today. A standard example of a quasi-isometry is the (discontinuous) map that sends each real number to the greatest integer less than or equal to it [ 8 ] . For a general introduction to quasi-isometries see [ 9 ] . Not all quasi-isometries are discontinous, such as the map that collapses the unit interval in \mathbb{R} to the origin and then scales everything by a factor of two as well as the example illustrated above. These maps are also examples of a pseudo-isometry , a term introduced by Mostow [ 10 ] in 1974 in his study of arbitrary symmetric spaces (see also §5.9 of [ 11 ] ). A pseudo-isometry satisfies a stronger condition than a quasi-isometry in that it has no additive term on the upper bound. Indeed, a pseudo-isometry is a Lipschitz map that distorts distances by a uniformly bounded amount, above a given scale. Not all continuous quasi-isometries are pseudo-isometries. An explicit example is given in Example 4.3 . Our main result is to show that a surgery specified by a pseudo-isometry yields a natural map from the original space to surgered space that is also a pseudo-isometry. Theorem 1.1 . Suppose (X,d_{X}) and (T,d_{T}) are metric spaces and consider a subset S\subset X as a metric space with metric induced from X . If f\colon\thinspace S\to T is a pseudo-isometry, then the natural map F\colon\thinspace X\to\widehat{X}_{f} is a pseudo-isometry as well. The definition of \widehat{X}_{f} appears in Section 2 . The proof of Theorem 1.1 appears in Section 3 . The metric on \widehat{X}_{f} , obtained by variation of the quoteint metric space construction (see e.g., [ 9 , Chapter I.5] ), is defined via certain alternating sequences of pairs of points in X and T taking into account the function f . We call such sequences admissible and the length of such is the sum of the distances for each pair (Definition 2.3 ). The main technical step to prove Theorem 1.1 is Lemma 2.5 where we give a lower bound on the length of an admissible sequence in terms of the distance in X between its endpoints. It is in this lemma that we need to restrict to pseudo-isometries as opposed to quasi-isometries to control the amount of additive error. One example that is covered by Theorem 1.1 is the map F\colon\thinspace\mathbb{R}\to\mathbb{R} that collapses each interval of the form [2n,2n+1] to a point. This is the example discussed above. For this example we have that S=\{[2n,2n+1]\mid n\in\mathbb{Z}\} , T=\mathbb{Z} and f(s)=\lfloor{\frac{s}{2}}\rfloor . In this case as we mentioned above, the surgered space is isometric to \mathbb{R} . We present several examples in Section 4 . First, an application of Theorem 1.1 to regular trees is given in Example 4.1 . This shows that a regular tree of degree four is pseudo-isometric