Charge acceleration without radiation
Yakir Aharonov a,b,c , Daniel Collins d and Sandu Popescu d · 2025
Read Charge acceleration without radiation by Yakir Aharonov a,b,c , Daniel Collins d and Sandu Popescu d (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-23650.txt.
Introduction
Every school treatment of radiation rests on one rule: accelerate an electric charge and it radiates. Yakir Aharonov, Daniel Collins, and Sandu Popescu prove the rule has a quantum exception. Their setup leans on the Aharonov-Bohm effect, in which a particle can be accelerated even where no force acts on it, and they show that a charge accelerated this way emits nothing.
The arrangement, they say, is relatively simple once known, but the reasons run deep, and the result is the tip of an iceberg: the basic understanding of radiation needs rethinking. They also argue the trick is not confined to electromagnetism; any kind of radiation should admit the same loophole. A universal law becomes, on inspection, a classical habit.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yakir Aharonov a,b,c , Daniel Collins d and Sandu Popescu d |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 26 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-23650
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Charge acceleration without radiation Yakir Aharonov a,b,c , Daniel Collins d and Sandu Popescu d Abstract The existence of electromagnetic radiation - radio-waves, microwaves, light, x-rays and so on - is one of the most important physical phenomena, and our ability to manipulate them is one of the most significant technological achievement of humankind. Underlying this ability is our understanding of how radiation is produced: whenever an electric charge is accelerated, it radiates. Or, at least, this is how it has been hitherto universally thought. Here we prove that quantum mechanically electric charges can be accelerated without radiating. The physical setup leading to this behavior is relatively simple (once one knows what to do) but its reasons are deep: it relies on the fact that quantum mechanically particles can be accelerated even when no forces act on them, via the Aharonov-Bohm effect. As we argue, the effect presented here is just them tip of an iceberg - it implies the need to reconsider the basic understanding of radiation. Finally, it seems clear that the effect goes far beyond electromagnetism and applies to any kind of radiation. I Introduction Accelerated electric charges radiate. Arguably, this is one of the most important physical phenomena. Understanding the origin of radiation by J.C. Maxwell Maxwell 1865 has been one of the greatest triumphs of physics. In going from classical electromagnetism to quantum electrodynamics (QED), the same idea, i.e. that a charge undergoing a acceleration radiates, is generally presumed to be true. However, the theory is formulated in a completely different manner than the classical one. In quantum mechanics the notion of acceleration does not play a central role; it does not even enter explicitly in the basic equations. Given this, we raise the question whether the general presumption that accelerated charges radiate is true. The answer, as we show here, is that quantum mechanically it is possible to accelerate charges without them radiating. The issue stems from the fundamental difference between classical and quantum dynamics. In classical physics forces are necessary to change how a system moves. In quantum mechanics the behaviour of systems can be affected even when particles move in force-free regions. Aharonov and Bohm discovered Aharonov and Bohm 1959 that changes in interference patterns in electron interference experiments may occur even though the electron never experiences any force. In subsequent work Aharonov et al. 1969 ; Aharonov 1984 , Aharonov et al. explicitly showed that the momentum distribution of quantum particles can be changed without forces. This is dynamical non-locality Popescu 2010 - for a particle whose state is composed of a superposition of wavepackets separated in space, the effect depends on the difference of potential between the remote locations of the different wavepackets, and it is non-zero even though the potential is constant (hence no force) at the location of each wavepacket. Of course, a change of momentum of a (non-relativistic) particle involves acceleration, hence quantum mechanically acceleration can occur without forces. We will show that when acceleration is produced in this non-local way no radiation occurs. II Main Experiment Describing electromagnetic radiation in the full quantum electrodynamics (QED) theory in anything but trivial situations is complicated, but for our purpose it is enough to consider a regime in which full QED treatment is not necessary. We will consider the electron moving with non-relativistic speed, and situations in which no electron-positron pairs may be created. The main facts that are relevant for us are that an electron moving with constant velocity is characterised by a Coulomb field in which the magnitude of the electric field {\bf E} decreases proportionally to 1/R^{2} , while any radiation it may emit when perturbed is characterised by an electric field that, at least in some directions, decreases only by 1/R , where R is the distance from the electron to the point where the field is observed Thomson 1904 ; Feynman et al. 1964 . Figure 1: An electron starts in a wavepacket aligned above the x-axis, and moves downwards in the z-direction. Let us first consider an electron whose state \Psi_{L}(x,y,z) is a cylindrical wavepacket of length d and small radius r , with the axis along the x axis from x=-(d+a) to x=-a , with positive a , y=0 and z=z_{0}>r , as illustrated in Fig. 1 . Let the wavepacket move in the direction of negative z . What will happen to the electron and its electromagnetic field during its time evolution? The answer is that there is no radiation. Indeed, had the electron started in a state of well-defined momentum, and since being a free particle its momentum (and hence velocity) does not change, it will not radiate. However, we considered the electron initially confined in a limited space region which means that the superposition of momentum eigenstates. Yet it will also not radiate because for each component in the superposition the magnitude of the associated Coulomb electric field decays as 1/R^{2} , and therefore any superposition of such electric fields will also decay as 1/R^{2} . Hence there is no radiation. Consider now an infinitely long and thin solenoid containing a magnetic flux \Phi oriented parallel to the y axis and intersecting the x-z plane at z=0 , as illustrated in Fig. 2 . Figure 2: An electron moves past a solenoid with flux \Phi which is oriented along the y-axis. We use the singular gauge for the vector potential {\bf A} , taking it to be non-zero only along the half-plane with z=0 and x>0 . Suppose that the wavepacket moves quickly enough so that the electron wavefunction, although spreading, does not enter the solenoid during the time it passes by it. What will happen now? The answer is that there will still be no radiation. The reason is that there is no electromagnetic field at the location of the electron, and the electron does not touch the solenoid nor encircle it, so the electron behaves as a free particle. Hence the wavepacket does not change its evolution versus what it would have been in the absence of the solenoid, in which case, as discussed, the electron does not radiate. Consider now that instead of being prepared in \Psi_{L} the electron is prepared in the state \Psi_{R} , which is identical to \Psi_{L} but which is placed from x=a to x=d+a , i.e. on the other side of the y-z plane to \Psi_{L} (Fig. 3 ). Now the electron passes on the right side of the solenoid and, similar to the previous case, there is no radiation. Figure 3: The electron moves past the right of the solenoid. It crosses the singular line of the vector potential, acquiring an overall phase in our gauge. Finally, consider that the electron was initially prepared in a superposition of the two wavepackets as in Fig. 4 , \Psi=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(\Psi_{L}+\Psi_{R}). (1) Figure 4: The electron, in the superposition \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(\Psi_{L}+\Psi_{R}) , moves past the solnoid. The momentum distribution changes, without radiation. Due to the linearity of quantum mechanics, the time evolution of each wavepacket is the same as when it is alone and not in the superposition. Hence none of the terms in the superposition radiates. Also, the quantum superposition of Coulomb fields of