A Perturbative Approach to Symmetric Mass Generation

Simon Martin, Tarun Grover · 2025

Read A Perturbative Approach to Symmetric Mass Generation by Simon Martin, Tarun Grover (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-23032.txt.

Introduction

Simon Martin and Tarun Grover build a step by step math route to a change called symmetric mass generation. The Landau frame explains changes that break a symmetry. But shifts between two phases that both keep their symmetry are less well mapped. In this change, forces drive a gapless phase that keeps its symmetry into a gapped phase that also keeps it. No symmetry breaks at any point.

Their route rests on a small step expansion near the key size. At that size, the force that drives the change turns marginal. They run the route on two distinct models. In each case they find a shift tuned by one knob. They hold that these shifts catch the shared core traits of the change in each model. They work out shared values for the shifts. Those values give firm calls for a change that lacked a firm theory.

Catalog record

CREATORSimon Martin, Tarun Grover
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE128 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-23032

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Perturbative Approach to Symmetric Mass Generation Simon Martin, Tarun Grover Abstract The Landau paradigm has been a powerful framework for understanding phase transitions involving spontaneous symmetry breaking. In contrast, phase transitions between two symmetric phases, where neither phase breaks any symmetry, remain less explored. One intriguing class of such transitions involves “symmetric mass generation” (SMG), where interactions drive a transition from a gapless symmetric phase to a gapped symmetric phase. In this work, we develop a controlled perturbative approach to study a class of such transitions, based on an ϵ \epsilon -expansion around the critical dimension where the SMG-inducing-interaction becomes marginal. Applying this method to two distinct models, we identify a single-parameter-tuned transition in each case, which we conjecture captures the universal critical behavior of the SMG transition in these models. We compute universal quantities associated with these transitions. A large part of our understanding of quantum phase transitions builds on the intuition from the generalized Landau paradigm, where one condenses an order parameter charged under some global symmetry. Not all quantum phase transitions however are readily described in terms of order parameters. A prominent example is the phenomenon of “symmetric mass generation” (SMG) whose prototypical examples involve mass generation for gapless fermions without breaking any global symmetry spontaneously (see Ref. Wang and You 2022 for a review). The presence of an SMG phase hinges on the absence of any anomalies that prohibit a symmetric, gapped phase without topological order, which may sometimes even prohibit any gapped phase at all. Such anomalies can be either non-perturbative, as in the context of interaction-reduced classification of symmetry protected topological phases Fidkowski and Kitaev 2010 ; Fidkowski et al. 2013 ; Wang and Senthil 2014 ; Metlitski et al. 2014 ; Ryu and Zhang 2012 ; Qi 2013 ; Yao and Ryu 2013 ; Gu and Levin 2014 , or, they can be perturbative, which relates to the question of regularizing chiral fermions on lattices Eichten and Preskill 1986 ; Wen 2013 ; You et al. 2014 ; BenTov and Zee 2016 ; Wang and Wen 2023 ; Tong 2022 ; Razamat and Tong 2021 ; Wang and Wen 2019 ; Zeng et al. 2022 ; Catterall 2021 ; Butt et al. 2025 . Although there has been remarkable progress in understanding the SMG phase itself, including concrete lattice models that host such a phase Slagle et al. 2015 ; Ayyar and Chandrasekharan 2015 ; Ayyar and Chandrasekharan 2016 ; Catterall 2016 ; He et al. 2016 ; Hou and You 2023 ; Liu et al. 2024 ; Catterall and Schaich 2017 , analytical progress on the universal aspects of the SMG phase transition is rather limited. In this work, we pursue a controlled, perturbative renormalization group (RG) approach to the SMG critical point in a class of models. We primarily focus on a 2+1-D field theory motivated by the lattice models in Refs. Slagle et al. 2015 ; Ayyar and Chandrasekharan 2015 ; Ayyar and Chandrasekharan 2016 ; Catterall 2016 ; He et al. 2016 ; Hou and You 2023 which involve four-fermion interactions favoring a gapped, symmetric phase. Additionally, we study a non-relativistic model of fermions, which is also expected to host SMG. Our main result is the identification of a new fixed point with a single relevant direction arising from a field-theory analog of the SMG-inducing interaction. This leads us to conjecture that this fixed point describes the SMG critical point in these models. It is instructive to recall the simplest manifestation of SMG in the quantum mechanical problem of N (an even number) Majorana modes \chi_{a} with two symmetries: time reversal that acts as \chi_{a}\to\chi_{a},\mathrm{i}\to-\mathrm{i} , and fermion parity that acts as \chi_{a}\to-\chi_{a},\mathrm{i}\to\mathrm{i} Wang and You 2022 . In the absence of interactions, the Hamiltonian is zero, since there exists no fermion bilinear that respects the aforementioned symmetries. Correspondingly, the ground state degeneracy is 2^{N/2} . However, in the presence of interactions, and when the number of Majorana fermions is a multiple of eight, one can indeed find a Hamiltonian with a unique, symmetric ground state. For example, when N=8 , two such Hamiltonians are given by H_{\pm}=\pm\left(c_{1}c_{2}c_{3}c_{4}+\textrm{h.c.}\right) , where c_{i}=\left(\chi_{2i-1}+\mathrm{i}\chi_{2i}\right)/2 are complex fermions. The unique, gapped ground state of H_{\pm} is |{\psi}_{\pm}\rangle=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\left(|0000\rangle\mp|1111\rangle\right) , where a basis state |n_{1}n_{2}n_{3}n_{4}\rangle is defined as the simultaneous eigenstate of the number operators c^{\dagger}_{i}c^{\phantom{\dagger}}_{i} . Relatedly, precisely when the number of modes is a multiple of eight, the 0+1-D system can be interpreted as the boundary of a trivial SPT phase with the aforementioned symmetries, and hence can be gapped out Fidkowski and Kitaev 2010 . This relation between gappable SPT boundary and SMG extends to higher dimensions as well. For example, 3+1-D topological superconductors in the class DIII have a \mathbb{Z}_{16} classification Kapustin et al. 2015 and correspondingly, sixteen copies of Majorana fermions in 2+1-D with time-reversal and fermion parity can be gapped out without breaking any symmetry. Crucially, any four-fermion interaction at the free Majorana fixed point is perturbatively irrelevant and therefore, this raises the possibility of a phase transition between the non-interacting, gapless Majorana phase and the SMG phase Slagle et al. 2015 ; Ayyar and Chandrasekharan 2015 ; Ayyar and Chandrasekharan 2016 ; Catterall 2016 ; He et al. 2016 ; Hou and You 2023 . A candidate theory for the SMG transition for the models in Refs. Slagle et al. 2015 ; Ayyar and Chandrasekharan 2015 ; Ayyar and Chandrasekharan 2016 ; Catterall 2016 ; He et al. 2016 ; Hou and You 2023 was proposed in Refs. You et al. 2018a ; You et al. 2018b . It involves fractionalizing the physical fermion in terms of a boson and a fermion which results in an SU(4) QCD-Higgs gauge theory. The massless Dirac phase corresponds to the Higgs phase of this theory, where the bosonic partons condense, while the SMG phase was argued to be the confining phase, under the assumption that confinement does not break any global symmetries. This approach leads to a strongly-coupled field theory for the SMG transition, involving non-abelian gauge fields coupled to both bosonic and fermionic matter. Therefore, it is also desirable to find a weakly coupled description of this transition. Here we will pursue a different approach that leads to a weakly coupled candidate, and which is formulated directly in terms of the physical fermions. Our basic observation is that in a field-theoretic description of the models for SMG in Refs. Slagle et al. 2015 ; Ayyar and Chandrasekharan 2015 ; Ayyar and Chandrasekharan 2016 ; Catterall 2016 ; He et al. 2016 ; Hou and You 2023 , all four-fermion terms, including the ones that induce SMG, are simultaneously marginal at tree level in a certain spacetime dimension D^{*} . This allows a framework to search for the SMG critical point on the same footing as standard symmetry-breaking transitions. This is done by considering the theory in D^{*}+\epsilon dimensions, and performing a controlled RG expansion in the parameter \epsilon , akin to the 2+\epsilon or 4-\epsilon expansion for the O(N) model. In the absence of the SMG term, this approach recovers the standard Gross-Neveu-type transitions that correspond to spontaneous breaking of various global symmetries. Crucially, this approach does not rely

Read the complete text