A blessing or a burden? Exploring worker perspectives of using a social robot in a church

Andrew Blair, Peggy Gregory, Mary Ellen Foster · 2025

Read A blessing or a burden? Exploring worker perspectives of using a social robot in a church by Andrew Blair, Peggy Gregory, Mary Ellen Foster (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-22903.txt.

Introduction

Andrew Blair and co-authors asked church workers how they would feel about a social robot colleague, in a 2025 study. The site is a working church that doubles as a visitor attraction. Fifteen people across stakeholder groups sat for interviews. Care, not profit, drives this workplace.

Reactions to a robot helper came out mixed. Many stressed the church duty of empathy toward people. Fears of unintended consequences sat beside clear upsides. Handing out information and doing dull tasks won support. The study shows service robots land differently where care is the mission.

Catalog record

CREATORAndrew Blair, Peggy Gregory, Mary Ellen Foster
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE30 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-22903

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A blessing or a burden? Exploring worker perspectives of using a social robot in a church Andrew Blair, Peggy Gregory, Mary Ellen Foster Abstract Recent technological advances have allowed robots to assist in the service sector, and consequently accelerate job and sector transformation. Less attention has been paid to the use of robots in real-world organisations where social benefits, as opposed to profits, are the primary motivator. To explore these opportunities, we have partnered with a working church and visitor attraction. We conducted interviews with 15 participants from a range of stakeholder groups within the church to understand worker perspectives of introducing a social robot to the church and analysed the results using reflexive thematic analysis. Findings indicate mixed responses to the use of a robot, with participants highlighting the empathetic responsibility the church has towards people and the potential for unintended consequences. However, information provision and alleviation of menial or mundane tasks were identified as potential use cases. This highlights the need to consider not only the financial aspects of robot introduction, but also how social and intangible values shape what roles a robot should take on within an organisation. I Introduction Robots have altered the workplace since the 1960s, when the first programmable industrial robot arm was deployed into an assembly line [ 1 ] . Since then, many industrial and service robots have been developed for the manufacturing sector, with line-following robots moving materials throughout factories and robotic arms performing complex tasks such as spray painting or spot welding [ 2 ] . Until recently, real-world robots were deployed almost exclusively in the industrial and manufacturing sectors due to their controlled environments. However, advances in localisation, mapping and algorithms have enabled autonomous robots to operate reliably in less predictable working environments [ 3 ] . This has resulted in the service sector being able to integrate robots into their workflows: for example, hospitality staff can now be assisted to serve customers in restaurants [ 4 ] , and home deliveries can be completed autonomously [ 5 ] . Traditionally, robots assist with manual, physical tasks. However, with the introduction of end-to-end transformer-based automatic speech recognition [ 6 ] , large language models [ 7 ] and advancements in social signal processing, tasks and interactions reliant on conversation can now also be supported by robots. This means that effects on job transformation and displacement can now additionally be seen within information provision roles [ 8 ] . This extension to knowledge-based domains has resulted in social robots being seen in public spaces such as airports [ 9 ] , shopping centres [ 10 ] , and train stations [ 11 ] . These public spaces can be categorised as primarily functional spaces, in which the focus is on transactional interactions that help the user achieve goals, such as guiding them to their flight or purchasing goods. Within these spaces, robot introduction could be seen through a purely capitalist lens, with deployment decisions based on a cost-benefit analysis comparing robot to human labour [ 12 ] . However, if profit and efficiency are not the only motivators for an organisation, such as in the public or third sector, there are additional competing factors influencing robot introduction. These sort of deployment contexts are generally under-explored, although two sub-sectors have seen some work. Social robots have been seen within university buildings [ 13 ] , often benefitting from the innovative culture and openness to novel experiences. Museums, who often have to balance profits with creating an experience for a visitor, have also explored social robots as a means of engagement [ 14 , 15 , 16 ] . However, these robots are most often deployed within science museums [ 17 ] , with the robot being an attraction in itself rather than necessarily delivering value as an assistant in its own right. A more overlooked context, with an even more diverse set of motivators, is that of churches: they provide spiritual and emotional support, assist with educational opportunities, undertake advocacy work and host community events [ 18 ] . This is underpinned by a strong focus on community, with Dietrich Bonhoeffer famously stating “The Church is the Church only when it exists for others” [ 19 ] . These non-monetary values and social benefits are considerably more challenging to assess, and they present a more complex challenge for robot introduction than for functional spaces like airports. The nature of a church creates a unique blend of competing stakeholder priorities and values, and to ensure a successful robot deployment, these values must be explored and considered with church workers to produce a system fit for everyone’s needs. To address this under-researched area, we have partnered with a large working church and visitor attraction in the United Kingdom to explore the potential roles of a social robot within the church. The church attracts a wide range of people, with some viewing the space as a centuries-old spiritual sanctuary and others seeing it as a place of architectural beauty with great photo opportunities. Total visitor numbers are increasing year on year, putting growing pressure on an understaffed organisation. They are currently looking for ways to decrease this pressure, and one potential solution is the use of social robots. In this paper, we explore how workers within the church perceive and respond to the proposed introduction of a social robot. We seek to answer the following research questions: • RQ1: How do staff respond to the idea of a social robot being introduced to the church? • RQ2: What are the competing human perspectives from staff about the tasks the robot should do? • RQ3: How is robot introduction affected by competing values in value-rich spaces? II Background This paper seeks to contribute to and extend existing research by combining two under-explored areas. We elicit perspectives about introducing a social robot from a diverse set of workers, and do so within the unique deployment context of a spiritual institution. II-A Robots within spiritual institutions Automation within spiritual institutions has a long history, with the first vending machine in the form of a coin-operated automata to dispense holy water being placed within a temple in 215 BC, to alleviate the demands on priests [ 20 ] . Automata could commonly be found in Catholic churches in the medieval period, often as additions to mechanised clocks and representing clergy or religious figures [ 21 ] . However, robots that depict social agents within a spiritual or religious context have largely been confined to theoretical work [ 22 ] . Limited social robot deployments have been trialled, with various platforms being used to provide remote attendance to funerals [ 23 ] , as a tool to disseminate homilies and bible verses [ 24 ] , and to give blessings to visitors [ 25 ] . II-B Diverse Worker Engagement Traditionally when exploring real-world deployment contexts researchers focus solely on end-user perspectives towards robot introduction [ 26 , 27 , 28 ] , but recently some researchers have investigated worker perspectives and impacts on organisational dynamics. The Eurofound research project, exploring human-robot workplace changes [ 29 ] , found productivity gains were the main reason for adopting robots. Additionally,

Read the complete text