Solitons, chaos, and quantum phenomena: a deterministic approach to the Schrödinger equation
Damià Gomila · 2025
Read Solitons, chaos, and quantum phenomena: a deterministic approach to the Schrödinger equation by Damià Gomila (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-22868.txt.
Introduction
Damià Gomila put forth in 2025 a picture in which quantum acts spring from classical solitons that move through a chaotic field. Solitons are lumps that act like particles. On a calm, zero field they move as Newton said, in plain paths. On a field with a wild, noisy base, their place and push wobble. The wobble fits the exact uncertainty relation.
From that relation Gomila derives the Schrodinger equation as the mean motion of a soliton ensemble. The size of the base noise plays the role of Planck's constant. In computer runs, solitons hit a potential barrier, and the share that got through matched the tunneling odds from the equation. He notes the view needs no gap between how a test is set and what it finds. It gives a classical base that copies quantum calls, at least in the cases he ran and checked.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Damià Gomila |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 41 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-22868
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Solitons, chaos, and quantum phenomena: a deterministic approach to the Schrödinger equation Damià Gomila Abstract We show that the Schrödinger equation describes the ensemble mean dynamics of solitons in a Galilean invariant field theory where we interpret solitons as particles. On a zero background, solitons move classically, following Newton‘s second law, however, on a non-zero amplitude chaotic background, their momentum and position fluctuate fulfilling an exact uncertainty relation, which give rise to the emergence of quantum phenomena. The Schrodinger equation for the ensemble of solitons is obtained from this exact uncertainty relation, and the amplitude of the background fluctuations is what corresponds to the value of ℏ \hbar . We confirm our analytical results running simulations of solitons moving against a potential barrier and comparing the ensemble probabilities with the predictions of the time dependent Schrödinger equation, providing a deterministic version of the quantum tunneling effect. We conclude with a discussion of how our theory does not present statistical independence between measurement and experiment outcome. I Introduction The interpretation of quantum mechanics has been a subject of intense debate since its inception in the mid-1920s, largely due to its probabilistic nature and the concept of wave-particle duality. The Copenhagen interpretation, which is the most widely accepted, posits that quantum mechanics is fundamentally indeterministic, with the wave function amplitude serving as a probability distribution for potential measurement outcomes. In this ontic view, the wave function is the primary entity, and there are no actual particles with defined trajectories until we measure. Despite its widespread acceptance, this statistical description that lacks an underlying physical reality remains controversial Bush and Oza 2020 ; Hance et al. 2022 ; Hance and Hossenfelder 2022 ; Hall 2024 . An alternative to the Copenhagen interpretation is the set of hidden variables theories which seek to provide a deterministic framework consistent with the statistical predictions of standard quantum mechanics. Several deterministic interpretations of quantum mechanics have been proposed in the literature Cetto et al. 2021 , including those based on Bohmian mechanics, or quantum pilot-wave theories Dewdney 2023 . These approaches describe particles as moving under the influence of a background field and successfully replicate certain quantum mechanical features. Notably, even macroscopic hydrodynamic pilot-wave systems have been shown to exhibit quantum-like behavior Bush and Oza 2020 . However, the separation of the concept of a point particle from the background field in these theories and their explicit nonlocal character introduce certain technical difficulties to make them compatible with special relativity Drezet 2023 ; Hatifi 2024 . A more natural approach could involve solitons, which are solutions to nonlinear field equations and can embody both particle and field characteristics simultaneously. Although solitons have been interpreted as particles within quantum field theory, this has traditionally been done from a standard quantum mechanics perspective Skyrme 1961 ; Derrick 1964 ; Manton and Sutcliffe 2004 ; Manton 2008 ; Bowcock et al. 2009 ; de Melo et al. 2016 ; Lozanov et al. 2025 . The idea of treating solitons as classical particles whose collective dynamics reproduce standard quantum behavior has been relatively unexplored, with only recent studies considering solitons in a pilot-wave context Drezet 2023 . In this paper, we demonstrate that the solitons of a Galilean-invariant nonlinear field can reproduce aspects of the quantum dynamics of microscopic particles in one dimension, as described by the Schrödinger equation (SE), without invoking a pilot wave. Building on an exact soliton uncertainty relation Hall and Reginatto 2002 , we show that the SE accurately captures the ensemble behavior of these solitons, with excellent agreement between averages over deterministic soliton trajectories and the predictions of the time-dependent SE. This provides a local, realistic interpretation of selected quantum features within the scope of our approximations. We further discuss how our framework might remain consistent with violations of Bell inequalities if the assumption of measurement independence is relaxed—an idea that arises naturally here due to the chaotic nature of the background field Palmer 2009 ; Hall 2010 ; Hall 2011 . Overall, our results contribute to the ongoing discussion surrounding deterministic interpretations of quantum mechanics and offer an alternative perspective that warrants further investigation. II Model and Soliton Solutions Starting from a relativistic complex scalar field theory with global U (1) symmetry supporting solitons Bowcock et al. 2009 , in which a complex field \phi(x,t) can be defined by the Lagrangian density \mathcal{L}=\frac{1}{1-|\phi|^{2}}\left[\partial_{\mu}\phi^{*}\partial^{\mu}\phi+|\phi|^{2}-|\phi|^{4}+V(x)|\phi|^{2}\right], (1) one can obtain from the corresponding equations of motion a Galilean version of the complex sine-Gordon equation (GCSGE) in 1+1 dimensions de Melo et al. 2016 : \displaystyle 2m^{\prime}\partial_{t}\phi= \displaystyle- \displaystyle i(1-|\phi|^{2})^{2}\phi+i(1-|\phi|^{2})\partial_{xx}\phi+ (2) \displaystyle+ \displaystyle i\phi^{*}(\partial_{x}\phi)^{2}-iV(x)\phi, where m^{\prime} is a parameter of the ansatz used in the projection to obtain Galilean invariance from the relativistic Lagrangian density, and V(x) is an external potential acting on \phi . In the following we set m^{\prime}=1/2 without loss of generality. Eq. ( 2 ) has a Noether charge associated with the global U (1) symmetry that provides robustness to non-topological solitons. With V(x)=0 , given the Galilean invariance, a soliton moving at an arbitrary velocity can be obtained from a boost of a stationary solution Bowcock et al. 2009 ; de Melo et al. 2016 . A soliton with amplitude w^{\prime} , moving at velocity v_{0} is given by: \displaystyle\phi_{s}(x,t,w^{\prime},v_{0})= \displaystyle=w^{\prime}\text{sech} \displaystyle{[w^{\prime}(x-X_{s})]}e^{i\frac{v_{0}}{2}(x-X_{s})}e^{i(-1+w^{\prime 2}+\frac{v_{0}^{2}}{4})t}, (3) where X_{s}(t)=X_{s}(0)+v_{0}t is the soliton position. The width of the soliton is \pi/\sqrt{6w^{\prime}} and its wavelength 4\pi/v_{0} . Solutions such as ( 3 ) are known as Q-balls in field theory Bowcock et al. 2009 ; de Melo et al. 2016 , where they are used to describe condensates of a large number of squarks or slepton particles. Here we interpret solitons differently, literally as individual finite-size particles Manton 2008 , in a deterministic way. The momentum density of field \phi is p(\phi)=\frac{i}{2(1-|\phi|^{2})}(\phi\partial_{x}\phi^{*}-\phi^{*}\partial_{x}\phi). (4) Evaluating ( 4 ) for soliton ( 3 ) and integrating over space we obtain that the soliton momentum is given by: P_{s}=\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}p(\phi_{s})dx=mv_{0}, (5) where m=\frac{1}{2}\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}\frac{|\phi_{s}|^{2}}{1-|\phi_{s}|^{2}}dx is the mass of the soliton. In presence of a nonzero external potential gradient, \partial_{x}V(x)\neq 0 , form the stress-energy tensor and conservation theorems one obtains \partial_{t}p(\phi_{s})=\partial_{x}J^{p}(\phi_{s})-\frac{|\phi_{s}|^{2}}{1-|\phi_{s}|^{2}}\partial_{x}V, (6) where J^{p} is the current associated to the momentum density Bowcock et al. 2009 ; Goldstein 1980 . For simplicity, in the rest of this work we consider small particles ( w^{\prime}\ll 1 ) and gentle potential gradients. Under the latter approximation, the main effect of the potential is changing the soliton velocity, and deformations of the soliton profile can be disregarded. Thus, integrating ( 6 ) over space, we obtain Newton’s second law: \dot{P_{s}}=m\dot{v_{0}}=-\partial_{X_{s}}V_{p}(X_{s}), (7) where V_{p}(X_{s})=\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}\frac{|\phi_{s}(x-X_{s})|^{2}}{1-|\phi_{s}(x-X_{s})|^{2}}V(x)dx (8) is the particle’s potential energy at position X_{s} . Newton’s second law commonly appears in field theories as an emergent property of solitons Manton and Sutcliffe 2004 . To illustrate this Newtonian mechanics, we show in Fig. 1 the dynamics of a soliton moving on a linear piece-wise potential with different slopes. We observe how it gets accelerated according to ( 7 ). As the slope of the potential is gentle, the soliton does barely get deformed by the acceleration, and the only visible effect at naked eye is the increase of the wavenumber k of the field inside the soliton with the