Different arrival times of CM and CI-like bodies from the outer Solar System to the asteroid belt

Sarah E. Anderson, Pierre Vernazza, Miroslav Brož · 2025

Read Different arrival times of CM and CI-like bodies from the outer Solar System to the asteroid belt by Sarah E. Anderson, Pierre Vernazza, Miroslav Brož (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-22649.txt.

Introduction

Sarah Anderson and co-authors trace where two meteorite kinds were born in this 2025 paper. CM and CI meteorites are among the most primitive space rocks known. Simulations of young giant planets growing and drifting show their parent bodies came from far apart zones.

CM parents formed near Saturn's birthplace, while CI parents came from beyond Uranus. The two kinds reached the asteroid belt at different times, the team shows. Comet-like bodies arrived with the CI group. Only the CM group, they add, could have fed water to the rocky planets. The timing also pins where the small grains inside CM rocks formed.

Catalog record

CREATORSarah E. Anderson, Pierre Vernazza, Miroslav Brož
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE46 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-22649

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Different arrival times of CM and CI-like bodies from the outer Solar System to the asteroid belt Sarah E. Anderson, Pierre Vernazza, Miroslav Brož Abstract Understanding the provenance of CI and CM chondrites, the most primitive materials in our meteorite collections, is critical for shedding light on the Solar System’s early evolution ( Morbidelli2005 ; Bottke2006 ; Levison2009 ; Walsh2011 ; Raymond2017a ) and contextualizing findings from recent sample return missions ( Marsset_2024arXiv240308548M ; Broz_2024arXiv240308552B ) . Here we show that the parent bodies of CM chondrites originate from the Saturn formation region, whereas those of CI chondrites originate essentially from the primordial trans-Uranian disk. Using N-body simulations to investigate the effect of giant planet growth and inward Type-I migration ( Nesvorn2015 ; Deienno2017 ) , along with the current observed distribution of CM, CI, and comet-like (P types) bodies in the asteroid belt ( DeMeo2013 ) , we demonstrate that CI and CM-like bodies must have been implanted at different times in the belt, while CI and comet-like bodies were implanted at the same time. These different implantation periods are imposed by the fact that the gas disk profile entirely governs the radial distribution of bodies implanted by aerodynamic drag in the asteroid belt. A preferred location coincides with the inner edge of a ‘gap’ opened by Jupiter. Saturn’s growth likely drove the migration of CM-like bodies, whereas CI and comet-like bodies were transported at a later stage, during the outward migration of Uranus and Neptune driven by remaining planetesimals. Since CM chondrites are chondrule-rich, it follows that chondrule formation occurred mostly inward of the ice giant’s formation zone ( ≤ \leq 10 au). A by-product of our simulations is that only CM-like (not CI-like) bodies contributed to the water budget of the telluric planets. keywords solar system formation, small bodies, asteroid belt, chondrites † † equal-contributors: These authors contributed equally to this work. To date, the vast majority of meteorites ( \geq 99%) originate from asteroids in orbits between Mars and Jupiter ( Marsset_2024arXiv240308548M ; Broz_2024arXiv240308552B ) . The challenge of aligning the large chemical, compositional, and isotopic diversity of meteorites with a model of in-situ formation in the asteroid belt has long eluded consensus. Dynamical models have significantly shifted this paradigm, suggesting that main-belt asteroids — hence meteorites — formed over a large range of heliocentric distances ( Morbidelli2005 ; Bottke2006 ; Levison2009 ; Walsh2011 ; Raymond2017a ) , from the terrestrial planet formation region to the Kuiper Belt. This view has been progressively supported by meteorite measurements revealing first a dichotomy between carbonaceous and non-carbonaceous chondrites ( Warren2011 ; Budde2016 ; Kruijer2017 ) and more recently a further dichotomy among carbonaceous chondrites (CCs), between CIs and the remaining CCs ( Hopp2022 ) . Whereas specific formation locations have been proposed for the different CC groups (most CCs: Jupiter-Saturn formation region, CI chondrites: Neptune formation region; ( Nesvorn2024 ) ) no single dynamical model has been able to correlate these putative formation locations with the current observed compositional distribution of the asteroid belt. Apart from a general consensus that most CCs formed beyond Jupiter —and even this remains to be unambiguously demonstrated —the origin of the diversity among CC groups, including their various formation locations, remains a mystery. Today, two meteorite classes are over-represented among CC-like asteroids namely CM chondrites (Ch, Cgh-types ( Vernazza2016 ) ) and CI chondrites (B, C, Cb, and Cg-types ( DeMeo2022 ; Ito2022 ; Hopp2022 ; Yada2022 ; Yokoyama2023 ) ). The parent bodies of these two meteorite classes represent more than 50% of the mass of the asteroid belt (not counting Ceres) ( DeMeo2013 ) . In contrast, the parent bodies of the remaining CC classes (CO, CV, CK) represent a minority ( \leq 1%) of all main belt asteroids ( DeMeo2013 ) . The radial distribution of CM- and CI-like bodies in the asteroid belt appear very different (Fig. 1 ), with CM-like bodies displaying a rather Gaussian, symmetric profile, whereas CI-like bodies display a markedly asymmetric profile. Of great interest, the distribution of CI-like bodies is remarkably similar to that of comet-like P-type asteroids (Fig. 1 ), suggesting a common origin. A common link between these two asteroid compositions is not new as they were already linked based on spectroscopic and density measurements ( Vernazza2015 ; Vernazza2021 ) , with a proposed link to interplanetary dust particles (IDPs). To constrain the formation location of CM- and CI-like bodies, and shed light on the origin of the isotopic dichotomy among CCs ( Hopp2022 ) , we used an orbital model to investigate the injection of planetesimals into the asteroid belt following giant planet growth. We conducted simulations using REBOUND (ref. ( Rein2012 ) ), consisting of 20,000 test particles each, representing 100-km-sized planetesimals. Our five-planet model was motivated by the works of Nesvorný ( Nesvorn2015 ) and Dienno ( Deienno2017 ) and featured Jupiter, Saturn, an additional ice giant (which is commonly ejected from the solar system), Uranus, and Neptune. Initially, planets were located on low-eccentricity orbits, with Jupiter at 5.4 au and Saturn at the edge of its gap, at 7.3 au. We chose to neglect the influence of telluric planets, which, having relatively small orbits, require more computation time. We placed Neptune at two different locations, namely in a ‘tight’ configuration at 16.2 au, in a 3:2, 3:2, 3:2, 3:2 resonance chain, or in a ‘wide’ configuration at 20.3 au, in a 3:2, 3:2, 2:1, 3:2 resonance chain ( Deienno2017 ) . The test particles’ semi-major axes were initialized uniformly between 7 au and 1 au beyond the orbit of Neptune. We then examined the effect of gas profile ( \Sigma_{\rm g} ), planetary growth timescale ( \tau_{\text{growth}} ), or the viscosity parameter ( \alpha ) on the distribution of planetesimals implanted in the asteroid belt (see SI for more details). Notably, we investigated three different gas profiles: the traditional canonical model with a radial dependency of \Sigma_{\rm g}\propto r^{-0.5} ( Cresswell2008 ) , the Desch ( Desch2018 ) model, and the Raymond & Izidoro ( Raymond2017 ) model. We find that the most influential factor for the distribution of objects within the asteroid belt proves to be the gas profile of the protoplanetary disk rather than the formation location of small bodies, the giant planet growth timescales, the viscosity parameter of the disk, or the configuration of the planets. The final distribution of objects successfully implanted in the asteroid belt strongly reflects the shape of the gas profile (Fig. 2 ). We tested our hypothesis further by simulating pressure bumps within the protoplanetary disk, by introducing gas profiles characterized by Gaussian peaks. These artificial constructs highlight the paramount importance of the gas profile in the final distribution of planetesimals interior to Jupiter, regardless of their origin: bodies formed around Saturn will end up with the same radial distribution as those that originate around Neptune. Whatever the gas profile, it is interesting to note a small inward radial shift of implanted bodies relative to the gas distribution (Fig. 2 ). In the absence of giant planet migration, the vast majority ( >90\% , see Tab. 1 ) of small bodies captured in the asteroid belt originate from the

Read the complete text