The study of symmetries: some general techniques
Peter Šemrl · 2025
Read The study of symmetries: some general techniques by Peter Šemrl (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-22572.txt.
Introduction
Peter Semrl surveys general methods for pinning down the form of symmetries in quantum foundations in a 2025 paper. A symmetry here is a one to one map on a set of operators that keeps the key relations or operations intact. The paper explains several ideas that recur across such problems and help force a map into a standard form, offering a toolkit for new symmetry questions.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Peter Šemrl |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 42 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-22572
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The study of symmetries: some general techniques Thanks: The author was supported by grants P1-0288 and N1-0368 from ARIS, Slovenia. Peter Šemrl Abstract Let S ( H ) S(H) be the set of all self-adjoint bonded linear operators on H H and 𝒱 ⊂ S ( H ) \mathcal{V}\subset S(H) a subset that is pertinent in mathematical foundations of quantum mechanics. A symmetry is a bijective map ϕ : 𝒱 → 𝒱 \phi:\mathcal{V}\to\mathcal{V} which is an automorphism with respect to one or more relations and/or operations on 𝒱 \mathcal{V} that are relevant in mathematical physics. We will explain several ideas that can be used when studying the general form of symmetries. AMS classification: 47B15, 47B49, 81R15. Keywords: Self-adjoint operator; Positive operator; Effect algebra; Projection; Symmetry. 1 Introduction Let H be a complex Hilbert space, \dim H\geq 2 . We denote by B(H) and S(H)\subset B(H) the algebra of all bounded linear operators on H and the subset of all self-adjoint operators, respectively. In mathematical foundations of quantum mechanics bounded observables are represented by self-adjoint operators. There are several subsets of S(H) that are important in mathematical formalization of quantum mechanics. Let A\in S(H) . Then A\geq 0 if \langle Ax,x\rangle\geq 0 for every x\in H . Such operators are called positive operators. When A\geq 0 and A is invertible we say that A is a positive definite operator and write A>0 . The set of all positive operators S_{\geq}(H)=\{A\in S(H)\,:\,A\geq 0\} and the set of all positive definite operators S_{>}(H)=\{A\in S(H)\,:\,A>0\} play important roles in physics. The effect algebra E(H)=\{A\in S(H)\,:\,A\geq 0\ \,{\rm and}\ \,I-A\geq 0\} is of basic importance in Ludwig’s axiomatic formulation of quantum mechanics, see [ 1 ] , [ 2 ] , [ 16 ] , [ 17 ] , and [ 18 ] . We denote by P(H) the set of all projections on H , P(H)=\{A\in S(H)\,:\,A^{2}=A=A^{\ast}\} . Pure states are repreented by projections of rank one. We denote by P_{1}(H)=\{P\in P(H)\,:\,\dim{\rm Im}\,(P)=1\} the set of all pure states. On the set S(H) or its subsets we can define several operations and relations that are relevant in mathematical foundations of quantum mechanics. Let A,B\in S(H) . Then A\leq B if and only if B-A\geq 0 , and similarly, A<B\iff B-A>0 . For bounded observables A,B\in S(H) we have A\leq B if and only if the mean value (expectation) of A in every state is less than or equal to the mean value of B in the same state. The relation \leq on S(H) is often called Loewner order. Two bounded observables are compatible if they can be measured jointly. If A,B are the corresponding self-adjoint operators then the two bounded observables are compatible if and only the operators A and B commute. The situation is more involved in the case of effect algebras. Two effects that can be measured together by applying a suitable apparatus are called coexistent effects. When we switch to the language of mathematics this translates into the following definition: Two effects A,B\in E(H) are said to be coexistent if there exist effects E,F,G\in E(H) such that A=E+G\ \ \ {\rm and}\ \ \ B=F+G\ \ \ {\rm and}\ \ \ E+F+G\in E(H). For any effect A we denote by A^{\perp} the orthocomplent of A , A^{\perp}=I-A . For two self-adjoint operators A and B the product AB is in not always self-adjoint. But S(H) is closed for the Jordan product A\circ B=(1/2)(AB+BA) as well as for the triple Jordan product A\circ B=ABA . In the setting of effect algebras a more natural concept is the sequential product defined by A\circ B=A^{1/2}BA^{1/2} . On the set of positive operators an important operation is the geometrical mean defined by A\sharp B=A^{1/2}(A^{-1/2}BA^{-1/2})^{1/2}A^{1/2} . Transition probability between pure states P,Q\in P_{1}(H) is defined as {\rm tr}\,(PQ) , where {\rm tr}\,A stands for the trace of matrix A . In particular, the transistion probability between P and Q is zero if {\rm tr}\,(PQ)=0 , which is easily seen to be equivalent to PQ=QP=0 . In this case we write P\perp Q . It is also easy to see that P\perp Q if and only if P\not=Q and P and Q commute. We can extend the notion of orthogonality to arbitrary projections. For P,Q\in P(H) we write P\perp Q if the images of P and Q are orthogonal which is equivalent to PQ=QP=0 . There are many more subsets of S(H) and relations and operations on these subsets that are relevant in mathematical physics. Let \mathcal{V} be a subset of S(H) and \circ a binary operation on \mathcal{V} . We say that a map \phi:\mathcal{V}\to\mathcal{V} preserves the operation \circ if \phi(A\circ B)=\phi(A)\circ\phi(B),\ \ \ A,B\in\mathcal{V}. Assume that \sim is a relation on \mathcal{V} . Then a map \phi:\mathcal{V}\to\mathcal{V} preserves the relation \sim if for every pair A,B\in\mathcal{V} we have A\sim B\iff\phi(A)\sim\phi(B). A bijective map \phi:\mathcal{V}\to\mathcal{V} that preserves a certain operation \circ is called a symmetry of \mathcal{V} with respect to the operation \circ . Similarly, a bijective map \phi:\mathcal{V}\to\mathcal{V} preserving \sim is called a symmetry of \mathcal{V} with respect to the relation \sim . Sometimes we are interested in symmetries that preserve more than just one operation or relation. For example, a bijective map \phi:E(H)\to E(H) with the property that for every pair A,B\in E(H) we have A\leq B\iff\phi(A)\leq\phi(B) (1) and \phi(A^{\perp})=\phi(A)^{\perp} (2) is called a symmetry of the effect algebra with respect to Loewner order and orthocomplementation. We could have defined symmetries shortly: We assume that \mathcal{V} is a subset of S(H) and that on this subset we have certain relations and/or certain operations. A symmetry of \mathcal{V} with respect to these relations and operations is an automorphism of \mathcal{V} equipped with these relations and operations. In particular, a bijective map \phi:E(H)\to E(H) satisfying ( 1 ) and ( 2 ) is called an ortho-order automorphism of the effect algebra E(H) . Let us give a few examples of symmetries. First we need to recall a definiton of a conjugate-linear operator on H . A map T:H\to H is a bounded conjugate-linear operator if it is continuous and for every pair x,y\in H and every complex number \lambda we have T(x+y)=Tx+Ty and T(\lambda x)=\overline{\lambda}Tx . For every bounded conjugate-linear operator T:H\to H there esists a unique bounded conjugate-linear operator T^{\ast}:H\to H such that for every pair x,y\in H we have \langle Tx,y\rangle=\overline{\langle x,T^{\ast}y\rangle}=\langle T^{\ast}y,x\rangle. In the case that a conjugate-linear operator T is a bijective isometry we say that it is an antiunitary operator, that is, a conjugate-linear operator U:H\to H is antiunitary if it is bijective and \langle Ux,Uy\rangle=\langle y,x\rangle,\ \ \ x,y\in H. Let T:H\to H be an invertible bounded linear or conjugate-linear operator. A map \phi:S_{\geq}(H)\to S_{\geq}(H) defined by \phi(A)=TAT^{\ast},\ \ \ A\in S_{\geq}(H), (3) is a symmetry of S_{\geq}(H) with respect to Loewner order. Similarly, the congruence transformation \phi:S_{>}(H)\to S_{>}(H) defined by \phi(A)=TAT^{\ast},\ \ \ A\in S_{>}(H), (4) is an order automorphism of S_{>}(H) . Let further S\in S(H) be any self-adjoint operator. Then the map \phi:S(H)\to S(H) given by \phi(A)=TAT^{\ast}+S,\ \ \ A\in S(H), (5) is a symmetry of S(H) with respect to Loewner order. Let U:H\to H be a unitary or antiunitary operator. Then the unitary-antiunitary similarity