The cycloid as brachistochrone: A one-page proof, from first principles, without calculus

Gavin R. Putland · 2025

Read The cycloid as brachistochrone: A one-page proof, from first principles, without calculus by Gavin R. Putland (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-22548.txt.

Introduction

Gavin Putland gives a one page proof, without calculus, that the cycloid is the curve of fastest descent in a 2025 note. The classic brachistochrone problem asks which path lets a sliding bead reach the bottom quickest. Bernoulli famously solved it by an optical analogy with light refraction. Putland rebuilds that optical solution on underlying non optical principles, from first principles, and only afterwards supplies the optical reading. The short note aims to make the elegant argument accessible to readers who lack calculus.

Catalog record

CREATORGavin R. Putland
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE6 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-22548

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The cycloid as brachistochrone: A one-page proof, from first principles, without calculus
Gavin R. Putland

Abstract




A
cycloid
is the plane curve traced by a point (
generating point
) on a circle (
generating circle
) which
rolls, without slip, along a fixed line (
generating line
). If
the line is horizontal with the circle hanging vertically below it,
the cycloid is “
inverted
”​.  In the diagram, a circle with
radius
a\>\!
has rolled along segment
OD
of the
x
-axis,
turning through angle
\theta
(radians) and traveling
distance
a\theta
, so that the generating point
P
, starting
from
O
, has traced the arc
OP
of the inverted
cycloid
OPB
.

Normal chord:

The infinitesimal piece of the circle at
D
​ has no velocity
component in the
x
direction (no slip) or in the
y
direction
(because it has reached maximum
y
): its instantaneous velocity is
zero. Hence the motion of
P
must be
normal to PD
(or else the
said piece of the circle would have a velocity component
along
PD
). Thus
PD is the normal to cycloid OPB at P
;
and in general,
the normal to a cycloid at a point is given by
the chord of the generating circle from that point (as generating
point) to the point of contact with the generating line
.

Normal cycloids (& cycloidal cylinders):

If a second circle, congruent to and superimposed on the first, rolls
along the bottom line
AB
, the points of that circle trace
cycloids, one of which, namely
HPF
, passes through
P
, where
cycloid
HPF
has normal chord
PG
and
cycloid
OPB
has normal chord
PD
. As the normal
chords make a right angle with each other (angle in a semicircle),

the cycloids are normal to each other at P
. The same applies to
later positions of
P
and
HPF
, including (by symmetry)
positions for which the part of
HPF
left of
H\>\!

intersects the part of
OPB
right of
B
. Thus

cycloid OPB is an
orthogonal trajectory
to the family
of cycloids generated by circle GPD and line AB
—and to the
family of
cycloidal cylinders
generated by the latter cycloids
if they move in the
z
direction (normal to the
xy
plane).

Horizontal & normal velocities:

Let angle
PDC
be
\color[rgb]{1,0,0}\phi
​ as shown. Let
cycloid
HPF
travel in the
x
direction at speed
u
, and let

v
be its resulting
normal
speed at
P
(measured
along
PG
​
). Then

v/u=\cos\phi\,.\vskip-4.30554pt

(1)

At
P
,
{y=-\textit{DP}\cos\phi}
.  But
{\textit{DP}=2a\cos\phi}

(from the right-angled triangle
DPG
). Back-substituting
for
DP
​ we have, at
P
,

y=-2a\cos^{2\!}\phi\,.

(2)

Eliminating
\cos\phi
between eqs. (
1
) and (
2
)
gives

\mbox{\large$\frac{\,1\,}{2}v^{2}+\frac{\;u^{2}}{4a}\>\!y=0$}\,.\vskip-6.45831pt

(3)

Motion under gravity:

The first term in eq. (
3
) is the kinetic energy, per unit
mass, of a particle with speed
v
. In a uniform gravitational
field
g
in the
-y
direction, the particle’s gravitational
potential energy per unit mass is
gy
(relative to
y
​= ​0).
Hence, if the particle is released from rest at
{y\!=\!0}
and moves
under gravity at speed
v
along a frictionless path, conservation of
energy gives

\textstyle\frac{\,1\,}{2}v^{2}+gy=0\,.\vskip-8.61108pt

(4)

Path of least time:

Given an origin
O
​ and a destination point
Z
(not illustrated),
with
Z
no higher than
O
, let us choose the radius
a
and the

x
direction so that cycloid
OPB
passes through
Z
. Then
eq. (
4
) determines
v
as a ​
function
of
y
, say
v(y)
, on all frictionless paths from
O

to
Z
—including cycloid
OPB
—if the
particle is released from rest at
O
. Now let the horizontal speed

u
of cycloidal cylinder
HPF
be

u=\sqrt{4ga}\,.

(5)

With this substitution, (
3
) becomes (
4
),
so that
v(y)
becomes the
normal
speed of the cycloidal
cylinder
HPF
, i.e. the speed of its intersection with its
orthogonal cycloid
OPB
. Now let the particle be released
from
O
when cylinder
HPF
crosses
O
. If the frictionless
path is cycloid
OPB
, the particle will
just
keep up
with cylinder
HPF
, and will reach
Z
when
cylinder
HPF
crosses
Z
. But if the path from
O
to
Z

departs from cycloid
OPB
, then for part of the path ​ the
same
v(y)
over the same range of
y
will
not
be normal to
cylinder
HPF
, so that the particle will need to travel

further at the same speed
between successive positions of
cylinder
HPF
and will therefore fall behind it, taking more
time to reach
Z
. Thus
the path of least time
(
brachistochrone)
from
O
to
Z
is an inverted cycloid
meeting its generating line at
O
and passing through
Z
.

Optical interpretation:

Johann Bernoulli’s proof of 1696 (see the “Reference”) has the
premise that the path given by the law of refraction satisfies
Fermat’s principle of least time. The present proof needs no optical
premises.
But:
The traveling cycloidal cylinder
HPF
is
an admissible
wavefront
in an isotropic but non-homogeneous
medium whose propagation speed
v
is given by (
4
). Each
associated
ray
path is a path of least time between successive
positions of the wavefront, hence a path of least time between any two
points on the path. In an
isotropic
medium, a path of least
time between successive positions of the wavefront is an orthogonal
trajectory—e.g. cycloid
OPB
. The law
of
refraction
follows from the premise that the incident &
refracted wavefronts have a common intersection with the
interface. In a
stratified
medium, which behaves like many
parallel plane interfaces, this premise is satisfied by a wavefront
that holds its shape while traveling parallel to the strata—like cylinder
HPF
.  Eq. (
1
) says that

{v/\!\cos\phi}
is constant, i.e.
{v/\!\sin\alpha}
is constant,
where
\color[rgb]{0,0.5,1}\alpha
(in the diagram) is the angle
between the wave-normal and the normal to the strata; this is
“Snell’s law” for a stratified medium.

Reference:

E. Hairer & G. ​Wanner,
Analysis by its History
(4th

Read the complete text