Opinion formation in Wikipedia Ising networks

Leonardo Ermann, Klaus M. Frahm, Dima L. Shepelyansky · 2025

Read Opinion formation in Wikipedia Ising networks by Leonardo Ermann, Klaus M. Frahm, Dima L. Shepelyansky (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-22254.txt.

Introduction

Leonardo Ermann, Klaus Frahm, and Dima Shepelyansky wrote this 2025 paper on how opinions settle across Wikipedia. Each article is a node, linked by citations, in a web of millions. The team plants spin-like stances on the nodes: a few start fixed for one side or the other, and the rest take the majority view of their neighbors, step by step.

The contest settles into a steady split that shrugs off small shakes. That split then scores every node's lean. The authors play the game with rival leaders, lands, and ideas, then widen it to three camps at once, across the English, Russian, and Chinese editions of March 2025. They argue the toy model captures opinion contests on many tangled networks.

Catalog record

CREATORLeonardo Ermann, Klaus M. Frahm, Dima L. Shepelyansky
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE68 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-22254

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Opinion formation in Wikipedia Ising networks Leonardo Ermann, Klaus M. Frahm, Dima L. Shepelyansky Abstract We study properties of opinion formation on Wikipedia Ising Networks. Each Wikipedia article is represented as a node and links are formed by citations of one article to another generating a directed network of a given language edition with millions of nodes. Ising spins are placed at each node and their orientation up or down is determined by a majority vote of connected neighbors. At the initial stage there are only a few nodes from two groups with fixed competing opinions up and down while other nodes are assumed to have no initial opinion with no effect on the vote. The competition of two opinions is modeled by an asynchronous Monte Carlo process converging to a spin polarized steady-state phase. This phase remains stable with respect to small fluctuations induced by an effective temperature of the Monte Carlo process. The opinion polarization at the steady-state provides opinion (spin) preferences for each node. In the framework of this Ising Network Opinion Formation model we analyze the influence and competition between political leaders, world countries and social concepts. This approach is also generalized to the competition between three groups of different opinions described by three colors, for example Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin, Xi Jinping or USA, Russia, China within English, Russian and Chinese editions of Wikipedia of March 2025. We argue that this approach provides a generic description of opinion formation in various complex networks. I Introduction The process of opinion formation in human society gains higher and higher importance with the development of social networks which start to produce an important impact on political views and elections (see e.g. Wikipedia contributors 2024 ; Fujiwara et al. 2023 ). The statistical properties of such social networks typically have a scale-free structure as reviewed in Castellano et al. 2009 ; Dorogovtsev 2010 . Various voter models have been proposed and studied by different groups with a development of physical concepts and their applications to sociophysics Castellano et al. 2009 ; Galam 1982 ; Galam 1986 ; Sznajd-Weron and Sznajd 2000 ; Sood and Redner 2005 ; Watts and Dodds 2007 ; Galam 2008 ; Schmittmann and Mukhopadhyay 2010 ; Kandiah and Shepelyansky 2012 ; Eom and Shepelyansky 2015 . Recently, we proposed the Ising Network Opinion Formation (INOF) model and analyzed its applications to Wikipedia networks for 6 language editions of 2017 Ermann and Shepelyansky 2024 . This model allows to determine opinion polarization for all Wikipedia articles (or nodes) induced by two groups of nodes with fixed opposite opinions (red or blue, spin up or down). In this INOF model the initial two groups of one or a few nodes have fixed opposite opinions represented by spin up (red color) or spin down (blue color). All other nodes have initially an undecided opinion (spin zero or white color). The formation of a steady-state opinion of each node emerges as a result of an asynchronous Monte Carlo process in which an opinion of a given node i is determined by a majority vote of his friends presented by spins up or down or zero from all network nodes j that have links to node i . Such spin flips, induced by local majority votes, are done for all nodes without repetitions in random order over all N nodes. These procedure is repeated up to convergence to a steady-state for a sufficiently long time \tau and corresponds to a particular random path pathway realization for the order of spins to be flipped. Finally, an average over a high number of pathways realizations is done to obtain averages and distributions of the opinions for nodes or the whole network (see next section for more technical details). A somewhat similar procedure is used in the studies of problems of associative memory (see e.g. Hopfield 1982 ; Benedetti et al. 2024 ) even if there are significant differences from the INOF model due to the absence of certain fixed nodes and other initially white nodes and the use of positive/negative transition elements between nodes while all of them are positive for the INOF case considered here. We also note that the INOF approach is generic and can be applied to various directed networks. In particular, it has also been applied to the analysis of fibrosis progression in the MetaCore network of protein-protein interactions Frahm et al. 2024 . A similar approach, without white nodes, was used to study the competition of dollar and possible BRICS currencies in the world trade network Coquide et al. 2024 . In this work, we extend the studies of the INOF model Ermann and Shepelyansky 2024 to more recent Wikipedia networks collected either in October 2024, as described in Frahm and Shepelyansky 2025 , or collected at 20 March 2025 and to new specific initial groups with fixed opinions. For example, we analyze the competition between Apple Inc. vs. Microsoft, Donald Trump vs. Vladimir Putin and others. Furthermore, the competition of three entries is also considered for several cases and finally, we also examine the effects of fluctuations appearing as a result of a certain effective temperature in the voting process. Wikipedia networks have rather exceptional features as compared to other networks: the meaning of their nodes is very clear, they represent all aspects of nature and human activity and the presence of multiple language editions allows to analyze various cultural views of humanity. A variety of academic research of Wikipedia with analysis of different aspects of nature and society was reviewed in Reagle 2010 ; Nielsen 2012 ; Ball 2023 ; Arroyo-Machado et al. 2024 ; Frahm and Shepelyansky 2025 . Therefore we hope that the INOF approach to Wikipedia Ising networks (WIN) will find multiple and divers applications. The article is composed as follows: Section 2 describes the INOF model and the used Wikipedia data sets, Section 3 presents results for the confrontation of opinions for two groups of entries, Section 4 presents results for a three groups contest, Section 5 analyzes effects of fluctuations induced by an effective temperature and Section 6 contains discussion and conclusion. Finally, the Appendix provides some additional Figures and data. II Model description and data sets In this work, we use mostly use three very recent Wikipedia editions (English EN, Russian RU, Chinese ZH) collected at 20 March 2025 with the number of network nodes/articles N=6969712,\,2035086,\,1468935 and the number of links N_{\ell}=190031938,\,44188839,\,21160179 for EN, RU, ZH respectively. For certain cases, we also use the English (EN) and French (FR) Wikipedia network collected at 1 October 2024 and already used Frahm and Shepelyansky 2025 with N=6891535,2638634 and N_{\ell}=185658675,76118849 for EN (2024), FR (2024) respectively. A description of the extraction procedure to create the wikipedia networks from raw dump files is given in Frahm and Shepelyansky 2025 . Wikipedia articles correspond to network nodes and citation from a given article j to another article i correspond to a directed link with the adjacency matrix element A_{ij}=1 (and A_{ij}=0 in absence of a link from j to i ); multiple citations from j to i are considered as only one link. Then the matrix of Markov transitions is defined by S_{ij}=A_{ij}/k_{j} where

Read the complete text