Rheological modeling with GENERIC and with the Onsager principle
Miroslav Grmela · 2025
Read Rheological modeling with GENERIC and with the Onsager principle by Miroslav Grmela (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-22144.txt.
Introduction
Miroslav Grmela, a solo author, compares three frameworks for modeling how complex fluids flow in a two thousand twenty-five paper. Rheology is the study of how materials such as polymer solutions flow and change shape. The first framework rests on the conservation of mass, momentum, and energy that comes from mechanics.
The second rests on how fluids left alone settle toward states of balance well described by thermodynamics. The third rests on a rule of least resistance to outside forces. Grmela works through the comparison with polymeric fluids held at one temperature that cannot be compressed. He weighs what each view takes for granted and what each can deliver. The result is a guide for researchers who must pick a base for flow models of complex fluids.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Miroslav Grmela |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 25 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-22144
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Rheological modeling with GENERIC and with the Onsager principle Miroslav Grmela Abstract In this paper we compare three frameworks for modeling flows of complex fluids: (i) local conservations of mass, momentum and energy, (ii) GENERIC, and (iii) Onsager principle. The first is based on the mass, momentum, and energy conservation implied by mechanics, the second on the observed approach of externally unforced fluids to equilibrium states at which their behavior is well described by equilibrium thermodynamics, and the third on the minimal resistance to external influences. The comparison is illustrated on isothermal and incompressible polymeric fluids. 1 Introduction How do complex fluids (like for instance polymeric fluids and suspensions) flow? This question gave birth to rheology. The same question but with simple fluids (like for instance water) replacing the complex fluids gave birth to hydrodynamics [ 1 ] . Rheology is an extension of hydrodynamics from simple fluids to complex fluids. The mathematical models of fluids that are emerging in hydrodynamics and in rheology are expected to reproduce first of all their observed flow behavior. There are however also other types of the behavior of fluids that can be readily observed. For instance it is the overall mass, momentum, and energy conservation or the approach of externally unforced fluids to thermodynamic equilibrium at which their observed behavior is found to be well described by the classical equilibrium thermodynamics. While this type of behavior is not of a direct interest to hydrodynamics and rheology, correct mathematical models have to reproduce it. Due to the universal nature of some of the ”hydrodynamically and rheologically uninteresting” observations the requirement that the governing equations reproduce them can be expected to provide a universal framework for the governing equations. The requirement of the mass, momentum, and energy conservation does indeed provide a framework for the hydrodynamic equations (the equations have the form of local conservation laws: time derivative equals divergence of a flux). This framework can be extended to rheological equations by requiring in addition either the compatibility with the equilibrium thermodynamics [ 2 ] , [ 3 ] , [ 4 ] , [ 5 ] or the compatibility with the Onsager variational principle [ 6 ] . In this paper we compare these two types of requirements. 2 Compatibility with thermodynamics, GENERIC In this section we put our attention on the observed approach of externally (and internally) unforced complex fluids to thermodynamically equilibrium states at which their behaviour is found to be well described by the classical equilibrium thermodynamics. This type of behavior is universally observed. It is the observation that provides the basis for the classical equilibrium thermodynamics. It was Boltzmann [ 7 ] who investigated it first theoretically. His investigation was limited to ideal gases but the mathematical structure of his equation (the Boltzmann kinetic equation) describing the approach to equilibrium turned out [ 2 ] , [ 3 ] , [ 4 ] , [ 5 ] to be applicable to much larger class of macroscopic systems seen on many different scales. The time evolution equations describing the approach to equilibrium are particular realizations of the abstract Boltzmann equation, called GENERIC [ 4 ] , [ 5 ] \dot{x}=LE_{x}(x)+\Xi_{x^{*}}(x,x^{*})|_{x^{*}=S_{x}(x)} (1) By the symbol x we denote in ( 1 ) the variable chosen to describe states of the macroscopic system under investigation, \dot{x}=\frac{dx}{dt} , E is the energy, S is the entropy, L is the Poisson bivector expressing the kinematics of the state variable x , \Xi is the dissipation potential. We use the shorthand notation: A_{x}(x)=\frac{\partial A(x)}{\partial x} where A is a function of x (if x is an element of an infinite dimensional space then A_{x} is an appropriate functional derivative). The quantities L,\Xi,S,E are required to satisfy certain properties. All are listed for instance in [ 8 ] . In this paper we show them only on the particular example discussed below. In the general setting ( 1 ) we only note that solutions of the GENERIC equation ( 1 ) with L,\Xi,S,E satisfying the required properties imply \dot{N}=0;\,\,\dot{E}=0;\,\,\,\dot{S}\geq 0 (2) These properties demonstrate conservations of the number of moles N(x) , the energy E(x) energy (both required by mechanics), and the approach to the equilibrium states \hat{x}(T,\mu) that are solutions to \Phi_{x}=0 , where \Phi(x,T,\mu)=-S(x)+\frac{1}{T}E(x)-\frac{\mu}{T}N(x) (3) is the thermodynamic potential playing the role of the Lyapunov function; T is the temperature and \mu the chemical potential. We note that the maximization of the entropy (MaxEnt principle) is made in the course of the time evolution governed by ( 1 ). The fundamental thermodynamic relation at the equilibrium states \hat{x}(T,\mu) (that is implied by the thermodynamic potential ( 3 )) is S=S(E,N) that is the Legendre transformation of S^{*}(T,\mu)=\Phi(\hat{x}(T,\mu),T,\mu) (4) If we assume that E,N and also S are extensive variables then S=\frac{1}{\lambda}S(\lambda E,\lambda N) , \forall\lambda , which then implies (due to the Euler relation) that S(E,N) can be extended to S(E,N,V) , where V is the volume, and S^{*}(T,\mu)=-\frac{PV}{T} , where P is the conjugate variable to V having the physical interpretation of the pressure. We shall illustrate the application of the GENERIC equation ( 1 ) in rheological modeling on the example of polymeric fluids. We choose the conformation tensor {\boldmath\mbox{$c$}}=c_{ij}({\boldmath\mbox{$r$}});i,j=1,2,3 to characterize their internal structure. The vector {\boldmath\mbox{$r$}}\in\mathbb{R}^{3} is the position vector, {\boldmath\mbox{$c$}}({\boldmath\mbox{$r$}}) is a symmetric and positive definite tensor. We can regarded it as a tensor expressing deformations of the internal structure. We restrict our analysis in this illustration to incompressible and isothermal fluids so that the complete set of state variables is x=({\boldmath\mbox{$u$}}({\boldmath\mbox{$r$}}),{\boldmath\mbox{$c$}}({\boldmath\mbox{$r$}})) (5) where {\boldmath\mbox{$u$}}({\boldmath\mbox{$r$}}) is the momentum field. The first question in the rheological modeling that uses the GENERIC equation ( 1 ) as its framework is of what is the Hamiltonian kinematics of the chosen state variables ( 5 ). The kinematics is expressed mathematically in the Poisson bivector L or alternatively in the Poisson bracket \{A,B\} that is related to the Poisson bivector L by \{A,B\}=<A_{x},LB_{x}> (6) The symbols A and B denote real valued and sufficiently regular functions of x and <,> denotes the scalar product. The ways to find the Hamiltonian kinematics for given state variables are discussed in [ 8 ] . The Poisson bracket corresponding to ( 5 ) is \displaystyle\{A,B\} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\int d{\boldmath\mbox{$r$}}\left[u_{i}(\partial_{j}A_{u_{i}}B_{u_{j}}-\partial_{j}B_{u_{i}}A_{u_{j}})\right] (7) \displaystyle+\int d{\boldmath\mbox{$r$}}\left[c_{ij}(\partial_{k}A_{c_{ij}}B_{u_{k}}-\partial_{k}B_{c_{ij}}A_{u_{k}})\right. \displaystyle\left.+c_{ij}((A_{c_{kj}}+A_{c_{jk}})\partial_{i}B_{u_{k}}-((B_{c_{kj}}+B_{c_{jk}})\partial_{i}A_{u_{k}}))\right] where \partial_{i}=\frac{\partial}{\partial r_{i}} . Its derivation can be found in [ 8 ] . The next question that has to be answered is of what is the energy E({\boldmath\mbox{$u$}},{\boldmath\mbox{$c$}}) and the entropy S({\boldmath\mbox{$u$}},{\boldmath\mbox{$c$}}) . Due to our limitation to incompressible and isothermal fluids it suffices to specify only the thermodynamic potential ( 3 ). We may choose for instance \Phi({\boldmath\mbox{$u$}},{\boldmath\mbox{$c$}},T)=-\int d{\boldmath\mbox{$r$}}\left[\frac{1}{2}\ln\det{\boldmath\mbox{$c$}}+\frac{1}{T}\left(\frac{{\boldmath\mbox{$u$}}^{2}}{2\rho}+\epsilon({\boldmath\mbox{$c$}})\right)\right] (8) Its detailed derivation as well as the list of references where this thermodynamic potential was initially derived can again be found in [ 8 ] . The first term in ( 8 ) is the entropy, T is the constant temperature, \rho is the constant mass density, \epsilon({\boldmath\mbox{$c$}}) is the internal energy of the internal structure (for instance \epsilon({\boldmath\mbox{$c$}})=Htr{\boldmath\mbox{$c$}} if we model the macromolecules as Hookean elastic dumbbells, H is a constant). Finally, we have to specify the dissipation potential \Xi . We assume that the origin of the dissipation is in the