Estimating cluster masses: a comparative study between machine learning and maximum likelihood

Raeed Mundow, Adi Nusser · 2025

Read Estimating cluster masses: a comparative study between machine learning and maximum likelihood by Raeed Mundow, Adi Nusser (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-21876.txt.

Introduction

Raeed Mundow and Adi Nusser compare a neural network with a classic statistical method for weighing galaxy clusters, in a paper from twenty twenty-five. Cluster mass is a key cosmic quantity, yet the galaxies around a cluster mix members with stray passers-by that fool simple counts.

The network, an autoencoder with convolutional layers, learned from mock galaxy catalogs. The classic method assumes clusters of like mass share one galaxy pattern. Tested on simulated clusters, the network's mass guesses scattered about a third less than the classic method's when using galaxy positions. It also won with velocity-based inputs, despite a bias that distorts distant samples. The authors present machine learning as the sharper scale for clusters.

Catalog record

CREATORRaeed Mundow, Adi Nusser
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE39 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-21876

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Estimating cluster masses: a comparative study between machine learning and maximum likelihood Raeed Mundow, Adi Nusser Abstract We compare an autoencoder convolutional neural network (AE-CNN) with a conventional maximum-likelihood estimator (MLE) for inferring cluster virial masses, M v M_{\mathrm{v}} , directly from the galaxy distribution around clusters, without identifying members or interlopers. The AE-CNN is trained on mock galaxy catalogues, whereas the MLE assumes that clusters of similar mass share the same phase-space galaxy profile. Conceptually, the MLE returns an unbiased estimate of log ⁡ M v \log M_{\mathrm{v}} at fixed true mass, whereas the AE-CNN approximates the posterior mean, so the true log ⁡ M v \log M_{\mathrm{v}} is unbiased at fixed estimate. Using MDPL2 mock clusters with redshift space number density as input, the AE-CNN attains an rms scatter of 0.10 ​ dex 0.10\,\textrm{dex} between predicted and true log ⁡ M v \log M_{\mathrm{v}} , compared with 0.16 ​ dex 0.16\,\textrm{dex} for the MLE. With inputs based on mean peculiar velocities, binned in redshift space or observed distance, the AE-CNN achieves scatters of 0.12 ​ dex 0.12\,\textrm{dex} and 0.16 ​ dex 0.16\,\textrm{dex} , respectively, despite strong inhomogeneous Malmquist bias. I Introduction Galaxy clusters, the most massive gravitationally virialized objects in the universe, comprise galaxies, hot intracluster gas (ICM), and dark matter (DM), serving as valuable laboratories for studying cosmology and astrophysics. Determining their abundance as a function of mass provides essential constraints on the matter and energy content of the Universe as well as the amplitude of mass fluctuations. Various techniques have been developed to estimate cluster masses, including gravitational lensing, which infers the projected mass distribution from the distortion of background galaxy images ( Lotz et al. 2017 , e.g.) , and X-ray spectroscopy, which derives mass profiles based on the ICM temperature and density under the assumption of hydrostatic equilibrium. Additionally, the Sunyaev-Zel’dovich (SZ) effect, which results from the distortion of cosmic microwave background radiation by the hot ICM, offers an alternative mass estimation method when combined with X-ray data ( Allingham et al. 2024 ) . The current study is concerned with estimation of cluster mass through observations of the kinematics of galaxies bound to clusters and galaxies in the vicinity of clusters. Most algorithms for identifying members of groups and clusters in observations of galaxies in redshift surveys are based on Friends-of-Friends (FoF) type of algorithms ( Tempel et al. 2016 ; Marini et al. 2025 , e.g.,) . By measuring the line-of-sight velocities of cluster members, the velocity dispersion can be determined. Through the Jeans equation, the observed kinematics of a spherical system can be related to its mass profile ( Carlberg et al. 1997 ; Mamon et al. 2013 , e.g.) . This approach assumes the system is virialized and may be affected by interlopers—galaxies that are not gravitationally bound to the cluster. In contrast, the caustic ( Diaferio 1999 ; Pizzardo et al. 2024 ) technique estimates cluster mass profiles by measuring galaxy escape velocities as a function of cluster-centric distance. Unlike virial methods, it does not require dynamical equilibrium assumptions and performs well in cluster outskirts, while naturally filtering out interlopers through its velocity threshold criteria. This approach has been validated using hydrodynamical simulations ( Pizzardo et al. 2023 ) , demonstrating its complementary role to virial-based estimates. Here we focus on comparing Neural Networks (NNs) and Maximum-Likelihood Estimation (MLE) approaches for determining the mass based on galaxy redshift surveys, particularly by analyzing the distribution and motions of galaxies within clusters and their surroundings. The large virialized motions of galaxies bound to a cluster’s gravitational potential cause the observed distribution of these galaxies to appear elongated along the line-of-sight in redshift space, a distortion known as the Finger of God (FoG) effect. The methods employed in this study account for all galaxies within the FoG region, irrespective of whether they are actual cluster members or merely lie in the vicinity of the cluster. The MLE approach involves positing a probability distribution (likelihood function) for the observed data given some unknown parameters, \theta . The goal of MLE is to find the parameter values that make the observed data most probable under this assumed model. In practice, this means finding the \theta that maximizes it the likelihood function L(\theta)=P(\text{data}|\theta) . Given a robust assumed model, MLE provides interpretable results in terms of the fitted parameters and their corresponding confidence level. Machine learning has opened a new avenue for studying and analyzing cosmological observations, including clusters of galaxies. A key advantage of NNs over MLE is their ability to identify complex relationships between observables and the physical properties of a system. NNs learn patterns and mappings directly from training data, incorporating a wide range of physical effects and observational limitations. Many of these effects are too intricate for simplified models to capture accurately or too computationally expensive to evaluate during inference in an MLE framework. As a result, recent years have seen a growing number of studies utilizing NNs. For instance, ( Lucie-Smith et al. 2022 ) trained a deep learning model to predict the mass profile of halo clusters using their mass accretion history as input, aiming to elucidate the contributions of the accretion history and initial density fluctuations to the final halo mass buildup. NNs have also been used for reconstructing cluster properties from limited projected observations ( Iqbal et al. 2023 ; Caro et al. 2024 , e.g.,) . Despite their advantages, NNs do not explicitly exploit well-known physical properties of a system the way MLE-based methods do. Capturing these properties with NNs is possible, but requires that a sufficiently large and reliable training dataset is available. A goal of this work is to present a comparative study of NN and MLE approaches for estimating cluster masses from a fair sample of the redshift space distribution of tracers (galaxies) in the vicinity of clusters. In the MLE approach here, we estimate the virial mass of a cluster only from the redshift distribution of “galaxies” in and around clusters. On the NNs side, in addition to training on redshift space distributions, we will also consider NNs trained on “observed” line-of-sight peculiar velocities of galaxies. A major challenge in this context is whether NNs can mitigate the effects of Inhomogeneous Malmquist Bias resulting from placing galaxies at either their redshift coordinate or observed noisy distances rather than true positions. The paper is organized as follows. In § II , we describe the simulation data used in this work. Our implementation of the MLE approach, along with its underlying assumptions, is presented in § III . In § IV , we outline the architecture of the neural network (NN), detail the training and validation datasets, and report the model’s performance based on the loss function. In § V , we provide a clarification of a fundamental difference between the MLE and NN approaches, focusing on how their outputs should be interpreted. The results of applying MLE and NNs are presented in § VI . We end with a discussion in § VII . II Simulation data Assessment of the MLE and NN estimation of cluster masses from kinematical data, will rely on the data extracted from the MultiDark Planck 2 (MDPL2) N-body

Read the complete text