Two-neutrino β ​ β \beta\beta decay to excited states at next-to-leading order Journal: Physics Letters B

Daniel Castillo, Dorian Frycz, Beatriz Benavente, Javier Menéndez · 2025

Read Two-neutrino β ​ β \beta\beta decay to excited states at next-to-leading order Journal: Physics Letters B by Daniel Castillo, Dorian Frycz, Beatriz Benavente, Javier Menéndez (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-21868.txt.

Introduction

Daniel Castillo and co-authors wrote this 2025 nuclear physics paper on a rare decay inside atomic nuclei. In two-neutrino double-beta decay, a nucleus sheds two electrons and two antineutrinos at once. Most studies cover decay to the ground state. This team studied decay into a first excited state instead, for four nuclei used in real experiments.

They computed the decay's key numbers with a shell model of the nucleus, trying several force recipes. A newer, next-order long-range term added only a few percent in most cases. Shape differences between the start and end nuclei tended to shrink the numbers. Their predicted half-lives sit near current test limits, giving experimenters sharper targets for the search.

Catalog record

CREATORDaniel Castillo, Dorian Frycz, Beatriz Benavente, Javier Menéndez
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE33 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-21868

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Two-neutrino β ​ β \beta\beta decay to excited states at next-to-leading order Journal: Physics Letters B Daniel Castillo, Dorian Frycz, Beatriz Benavente, Javier Menéndez Abstract We study two-neutrino double-beta decay ( 2 ​ ν ​ β ​ β 2\nu\beta\beta ) into first-excited 0 2 + 0^{+}_{2} states of nuclei used in β ​ β \beta\beta decay experiments, including 76 Ge, 82 Se, 130 Te, and 136 Xe. We calculate the corresponding nuclear matrix elements (NMEs) within the nuclear shell model, using various Hamiltonians that describe well the spectroscopy of the initial and final nuclei. We evaluate the next-to-leading order (NLO) long-range NMEs recently introduced within chiral effective field theory, keeping three terms in the expansion of the energy denominator. In most cases, NLO contributions to the half-life are below 5%, but they can increase to 25% due to cancellations in the leading-order Gamow-Teller NME. A detailed analysis in terms of nuclear deformation, including triaxiality, indicates that larger deformation differences between the initial and final states generally lead to smaller NMEs, but the seniority structure of the states also plays a relevant role. The lower range of our predicted half-lives, with uncertainties dominated by the nuclear Hamiltonian used, are slightly longer than the current experimental limit in 76 Ge and the very recent half-life indication in 82 Se. 1 Introduction In two-neutrino double-beta ( 2\nu\beta\beta ) decay two neutrons convert into two protons. This process is accompanied by the emission of two electrons and two antineutrinos simultaneously Saakyan:2013yna , Engel17 : \begin{split}&(A,Z)\xrightarrow{}(A,Z+2)+2e^{-}+2\bar{\nu}_{e}\,,\end{split} (1) and represents the slowest decay ever measured, with half-lives that can exceed 10^{21} years Barabash23 , Barabash20 . 2\nu\beta\beta decay is closely related to the neutrinoless \beta\beta decay, where no antineutrinos are emitted. The latter is a hypothetical decay not allowed within the standard model of particle physics, as it violates lepton number conservation. Its observation would be groundbreaking, confirming that neutrinos are their own antiparticles and providing insights into the matter-antimatter asymmetry in the universe Agostini23 , Gomez-Cadenas:2023vca . The connection between the two \beta\beta modes appears not only because both involve the same initial and final states, but in addition various studies have found that the nuclear matrix elements (NMEs) for both decays are correlated Jokiniemi:2022ayc , Horoi:2022ley , Horoi:2023uah . A detailed understanding of 2\nu\beta\beta decay is thus key to improve predictions for the neutrinoless \beta\beta mode. 2\nu\beta\beta decays have been measured in several nuclei, mainly for ground-state-to-ground-state transitions ( 0^{+}_{\rm gs}\xrightarrow{}0^{+}_{\rm gs} ) PhysRevD.93.112008 , GERDA23 , CUPID23 , NEMO-Se , PhysRevC.98.024617 , CUPID-Mo23 , NEMO-319 , Barabash18 , LZ:2024wvs , PhysRevC.106.024328 , CUORE:2025xue , PhysRevC.105.055501 , PandaX-4TGS , KamLAND-Zen19 , PhysRevD.94.072003 . However, theoretical calculations are challenged by the evaluation of a second-order weak process that depends on both initial and final states as well as the intermediate odd-odd nucleus. In fact, most many-body methods, such as the nuclear shell model (NSM) Caurier:1990dc , Poves:1995rg , Horoi:2007xe , CAURIER201262 , Horoi:2013jx , the quasiparticle random-phase approximation (QRPA) method EJIRI20191 , Hinohara:2022uip , or the interacting boson model (IBM) PhysRevC.91.034304 , overestimate 2\nu\beta\beta decay NMEs. This is because missing nuclear correlations and the lack of two-nucleon currents, as demonstrated in Refs. Gysbers2019 , Stroberg:2021guc for Gamow-Teller (GT) \beta decays. Notable exceptions are an effective field theory for \beta decays (EFT β ) CoelloPerez:2024dzt , Jokiniemi:2022yfr , PhysRevC.106.034309 , PhysRevC.98.045501 , with couplings fitted to GT data, and calculations with renormalized operators using coupled cluster theory PhysRevLett.126.182502 and the NSM Coraggio:2022vgy , Coraggio:2018tuo , that can also include two-nucleon currents Coraggio24 . Nonetheless, the overestimation, or need for quenching , of the NMEs is systematic within the same mass region Wildenthal83 , Chou93 , Martinez96 , and common to GT and 2\nu\beta\beta decays. Therefore, it can be accounted for phenomenologically. Indeed, this approach allowed the theoretical prediction by the NSM of the 48 Ca 2\nu\beta\beta decay Caurier:1990dc , Poves:1995rg and double-electron capture in 124 Xe CoelloPerez:2018ghg before their measurement—the latter was also predicted by the EFT β and QRPA XENON:2019dti . In this work, we follow this strategy and calculate within the NSM the 2\nu\beta\beta half-lives of ground-state-to-excited-state ( 0^{+}_{\rm gs}\xrightarrow{}0^{+}_{2} ) 2\nu\beta\beta decays in 48 Ca, 76 Ge, 82 Se, 124 Sn, 130 Te, and 136 Xe. Previous NSM works have studied 48 Ca PhysRevC.87.014320 , 76 Ge gerda_collaboration_2_2015 , 124 Sn horoi_shell_2016 , and 136 Xe Jokiniemi:2022yfr , besides 48 Ca, 76 Ge, and 82 Se with a renormalized operator and two-nucleon currents Coraggio24 . 2\nu\beta\beta decays to excited states have also been explored with the EFT β Jokiniemi:2022yfr , PhysRevC.98.045501 , QRPA PhysRevC.91.054309 , Jokiniemi:2022yfr and IBM PhysRevC.91.034304 , Jokiniemi:2022yfr . In order to obtain more reliable results, we follow an improved formalism expanding the lepton energies Simkovic18 . Further, in the spirit of Ref. Castillo:2024jfj , which explored next-to-next-to-leading order neutrinoless \beta\beta decay NMEs, we evaluate for the first time in these decays next-to-leading order (NLO) 2\nu\beta\beta terms derived within chiral effective field theory ( \chi EFT) morabit20242nubetabetaspectrumchiraleffective . 2\nu\beta\beta 0^{+}_{\rm gs}\xrightarrow{}0^{+}_{2} decays have been measured in 100 Mo Augier23 , 150 Nd Aguerre23 , Polishcuk21 , and there is a very recent experimental indication for 82 Se Barabash:2025bxa . Lower half-life limits have been set for instance in 48 Ca Bakalyarov:2002wu , 76 Ge Arnquist24 , 82 Se Arnold20 , 116 Cd Barabash18 , 124 Sn DAWSON2008167 , 130 Te Adams21 , and 136 Xe PANDAX-4T , AlKharusi_2023 , ASAKURA2016171 . To better compare with experimental data, we consider various nuclear Hamiltonians that describe well the structure of both initial and final states. In addition, we explore the impact of nuclear deformation, an aspect extensively discussed for neutrinoless \beta\beta decay Menendez:2008jf , Rodriguez:2010mn , Fang:2011da , Mustonen:2013zu , Song:2014vra , Yao:2016oxk , Yao:2019rck , Wang:2021shq , Tsunoda:2023fqw , Jiao:2023poq , Wang:2023hkc but less so for the 2\nu\beta\beta mode Alvarez-Rodriguez:2004ueg , Yousef:2008jw , Nitescu:2024ruw , Hinohara:2022uip . In particular, we analyze the shape invariants of the initial and final nuclei, taking into account the impact of triaxiality and configuration mixing on the 2\nu\beta\beta NMEs. 2 Two-neutrino \beta\beta decay At leading order, the 2\nu\beta\beta half-life is, \left(T^{2\nu}_{1/2}\right)^{-1}=g^{4}_{A}G^{2\nu}_{0}\left(M^{(-1)}_{\rm GT}\right)^{2}\,, (2) with g_{A}=1.27 the axial coupling, G^{2\nu}_{0} the phase-space factor (PSF), and M^{(-1)}_{\rm GT} the leading-order NME. This expression can be improved in two ways. First, we follow Ref. Simkovic18 and Taylor expand the lepton energies, introducing higher-order terms that couple additional PSFs and subleading GT NMEs. The latter are given by Simkovic18 , \displaystyle M^{(-2m-1)}_{\rm GT}=m_{e}(2m_{e})^{2m} \displaystyle\times\sum_{n} \displaystyle\frac{\langle 0^{+}_{f}||\sum_{j}\tau^{-}_{j}\boldsymbol{\sigma}_{j}||1^{+}_{n}\rangle\langle 1^{+}_{n}||\sum_{i}\tau^{-}_{i}\boldsymbol{\sigma}_{i}||0^{+}_{i}\rangle}{(E_{n}-(E_{i}+E_{f})/2)^{2m+1}}, (3) where |0^{+}_{i}\rangle and |0^{+}_{f}\rangle denote the angular momentum-parity J^{\pi}=0^{+} initial and final states, with energies E_{i} and E_{f} , respectively, and |1^{+}_{n}\rangle represents each available state of the intermediate odd-odd nucleus, with energy E_{n} . Here, \tau^{-} is the isospin ladder operator, \boldsymbol{\sigma} the spin operator, and m_{e} the electron mass. We keep additional NMEs up to m\leq 2 , M^{(-3)}_{\rm GT} and M^{(-5)}_{\rm GT} , which are sufficient to converge our results to the percent level. These NMEs have been explored for 0^{+}_{\rm gs}\xrightarrow{}0^{+}_{\rm gs} decays in 136 Xe KamLAND-Zen19 , 100 Mo CUPID-Mo23 , and 130 Te CUORE:2025xue in studies of the 2\nu\beta\beta spectrum. Table 1 : PSFs and \mathcal{Q} Ovidiu21 , NNDC for all 2\nu\beta\beta 0^{+}_{\rm gs}\xrightarrow{}0^{+}_{2} decays studied

Read the complete text